Rhode Island Current
16/11/2026 07:00

Commentary: Rhode Island pays the highest prices for public safety. Where is the receipt?

Local and state law enforcement officers are shown on the Elm Street Pier in Newport where a stolen yacht with the body of a suspect aboard was towed on the morning of Aug. 26, 2026. Police were on scene in the Point neighborhood until well into the evening conducting an investigation. (Photo by Janine L. Weisman/Rhode Island Current)

Every investigator learns the same lesson early: A number by itself proves nothing. You need to know what it measures and what it leaves out. The Rhode Island Public Expenditure Council (RIPEC) recently handed taxpayers numbers worth investigating.

In August, the business-backed research group reported the state’s cities and towns spent $931 million on police and fire protection in fiscal 2024. Fire spending ranked first in the nation per capita, at 1.8 times the national average. Police spending ranked ninth. Together, the two departments consume about a quarter of municipal budgets, and RIPEC names them a key driver of property tax growth.

Now the other side of the ledger. Rhode Island posted the fourth-lowest violent crime rate and the third-lowest property crime rate among the states in 2024. Fires accounted for roughly 2% of fire department calls in 2023. Medical calls made up more than 70%.

First in spending. Near the bottom in crime. Fires are a rounding error in the call log. The people paying for this picture deserve to see the evidence behind it.

I spent 20 years with the East Providence Police Department. Nothing here argues that those jobs do not matter or that the people doing them earn too much. Median firefighter pay in Rhode Island ranks 12th nationally; median police pay ranks 20th. Salaries do not explain a first-place ranking.

Staffing models do. Rhode Island ranks first in professional firefighters per capita, at nearly twice the national rate, because most of the country leans on volunteers. We built a system sized to fight fires, then sent it, overwhelmingly, to medical emergencies. Maybe that is the right design. Nobody can say, because we rarely measure what each dollar buys.

Consider overtime. A 2019 state law mandates time-and-a-half for firefighters averaging more than 42 hours a week, and it counts paid leave as hours worked. Take a sick day, then pick up an extra shift at premium rates. The Hummel Report estimated the practice cost Warwick about $500,000 in a single year. When the bill passed, a union lobbyist argued it was a fairness issue.

Then put that language, and its price tag, in public view.

Pensions add their own weight, eating more than a fifth of police spending and more than a quarter of fire spending, with at least eight local plans under 60% funded.

Then there is Newport, which spent $1,586 per resident on police and fire, the most in the state, and fields 3.4 officers per 1,000 residents against a New England benchmark of 1.8.

On paper, the worst offender.

But an investigator checks the denominator before trusting the ratio. Per capita figures count roughly 25,000 year-round residents. The city puts annual visitors near 5 million. RIPEC itself concedes Newport’s staffing may partly reflect seasonal residents and visitors its population count misses.

On Aug. 26, the Newport harbormaster’s office spotted a 40-foot sailboat reported stolen from New Jersey at anchor in Newport Harbor. Police say when officers went out to it, the man aboard retreated into the cabin, armed himself, and opened fire. A sergeant took a round in the leg. Officers returned fire and killed the suspect. The city has released body camera footage. State police and the attorney general’s office continue to investigate, and nothing here prejudges their findings.

The staffing lesson stands on its own. The call demanded officers on the water while the rest of the city still needed patrol coverage. Anyone who has run a shift knows the math. A department sized for 25,000 residents lacks the bench to do both. 

First in spending. Near the bottom in crime. Fires are a rounding error in the call log. The people paying for this picture deserve to see the evidence behind it.

So here is the real question for Newport and every seasonal community from Narragansett to Westerly. Staff year-round for the peak, or staff for the baseline and buy the surge through seasonal hires, overtime, and mutual aid with neighboring departments? Each answer carries a cost and a risk.

Defenders of current spending raise fair points. Dense cities and old wood-frame housing carry real fire risk. Low crime may reflect, in part, the policing we pay for; you cannot prove a negative by pointing at the outcome you bought. The core question remains: What do we get for the money, and how would we know?

Here is where to start.

First, require every city and town to publish an annual public safety report in one standard format: calls by type and by month, response times, staffing, overtime hours and dollars, injured-on-duty cases, and pension cost per active member.

Second, match the response to the call. If 7 in 10 calls involve medicine, communities should test dedicated medical units instead of rolling a full engine company to every chest pain.

Regional dispatch centers and shared services belong in the same discussion.

Third, the General Assembly should stop passing labor mandates without a price. Every bill touching municipal public safety staffing or overtime needs a fiscal note before the vote, starting with a fresh look at the paid-leave provision in the 42-hour law. RIPEC’s own recommendations include limiting costly state mandates.

None of this cuts a single firefighter or police officer. It demands what every investigator, every auditor, and every taxpayer has the right to ask: Show me the evidence.

We pay first-place prices. We deserve a receipt.

The recent report by the Rhode Island Public Expenditure Council shows Newport had the highest municipal spending on police and fire services among Rhode Island’s 39 cities and towns in fiscal year 2024 as a share of total non-education spending. (From “Police and Fire Protection in Rhode Island,” Rhode Island Public Expenditure Council, Aug. 31, 2026.)

GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.

SUBSCRIBE
📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Rhode Island Current.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Offshore wind offered a ‘limitless’ future for CT. Trump scuttled the plan.
Rhode Island Current
This article first appeared on CT Mirror and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDeriv…
Flights grounded at T.F. Green as FAA halts departures nationwide
Rhode Island Current
All departing flights at Rhode Island T.F. Green International Airport were halted Friday afternoon after the…
Global Microsoft outage disrupts locally
Rhode Island Current
The Narragansett Police Department could not access Outlook Thursday, but it could access Facebook. “Well, ou…
FM to send workers to Massachusetts as part of HQ relocation
Rhode Island Current
Downtown Providence isn’t the only target destination for FM’s planned departure from Johnston. The global in…
A rare request for clemency in Rhode Island could help 2 refugees fight deportation
Rhode Island Current
For two Cambodian refugees fighting to remain in the U.S., an extraordinary request made to Rhode Island Gov.…
Commentary: The small mind of a big man on campus
Rhode Island Current
Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth proposed an answer that won’t work to a problem that doesn’t exist during h…