Plantation man sent woman with deadly allergy card smeared with peanut butter, cops say
A Plantation man was arrested a year after he sent a woman with a deadly allergy a card smeared with peanut butter following a contentious divorce with her best friend, police said.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, is facing charges of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence in the incident that happened in August of 2025.
According to an arrest report, the victim returned home from work and emptied her mailbox to find a "blue envelope that appeared greasy with handwriting she did not recognize."
Inside, she found a greeting card with a substance she immediately recognized as peanut butter spread inside, the arrest report states.
Her exposure to the peanut butter on the card caused her to break out in "hives on both arms" and produced "a tingling sensation in both arms that lasted 6 hours," police said.
Police describe the victim as "deathly allergic," someone who has to be vocal about her allergy at restaurants and does not accept food without explaining that "she cannot come into contact with peanuts, peanut oil or items that have been cross contaminated." Authorities said she "can experience a reaction by touch, ingestion or through the air as peanuts give off an airborne toxin," and "without immediate medical intervention she could die."
She said Cancellare, who was married to her best friend, would "absolutely know about her allergy as the couples went to dinner countless times in which [redacted] had to be mindful of accidentally coming into contact with peanuts."
The arrest report is redacted, but it states that Cancellare's divorce from the victim's best friend was viewed as "contentious" and he "largely blamed [redacted] for the divorce."
Police said they also contacted the Postal Inspector for the investigation since the greeting card was sent via the United States Postal Service.
An investigation found that Cancellare was captured on camera purchasing the two stamps used on the envelope sent to the victim. The arrest report states that his "hatred for [redacted]" was not just shared in confidence, but that he also "made it well known in their friend group that he wished [redacted] harm."
"Despite over 3 years passing, Joseph drove to a USPS store in a different city than where he lived. He walked in, and continued to wear his sunglasses inside of the business in an attempt to disguise his identity," police said. "He further attempted to conceal his identity by writing a fictious name and return address on the envelope."
It was not immediately clear why the investigation was not concluded until more than a year later, but police said "the experience caused her extreme distress that was still visible when she provided the statement over a year later" and she said she "wishes to press charges."
Cancellare was arrested Friday, and taken to a hospital for medical clearance before he was taken to the Broward Sheriff's Office and booked.
His bond was set at $20,000.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
