Commentary: Most school levies failed, which prompts a review of how we fund schools

The author argues that school districts have become overly reliant on local property taxpayers, who are in turn increasingly rejecting local levies. (Photo by Kevin Hardy/Stateline)
The recent election sent a contradictory message about Minnesota public education. About 73% of voters approved a constitutional amendment increasing payouts from the state’s Permanent School Fund, which generates revenue from school trust lands. It is welcome news, but small: $33 more per student, from about $68 to $101, with the first payment in July 2027.
Yet voters rejected 55 of the 83 school funding questions on local ballots, according to unofficial results.
How do we reconcile those results? The amendment was promoted as a way to raise school funding without raising taxes. Do Minnesotans support public education when it won’t cost them anything, but pull back when their property taxes are at stake?
If so, students unlucky enough to live in a community that is unable or unwilling to pay more in property taxes will get fewer opportunities than their classmates in other communities.
Does that seem fair?
Education is a statewide responsibility
Voters should have a say in major local spending decisions, and school boards should be accountable for their budgets. The basic opportunities available to students should not be determined primarily by a community’s willingness to repeatedly approve property tax increases.
If Minnesota truly believes public education is a statewide priority, shouldn’t the responsibility for funding it also be shared statewide?
Rejection of school levies is not new, but the Minnesota School Boards Association reports that just 30% of operating referendums, 36% of bond requests and 42% of capital project requests passed this year. In 2024, 35 of 64 school questions failed.
The gap shows up in rural Minnesota too. In the Lake Park-Audubon district, the schools’ own leaflet estimated that its two school funding questions together would cost about $60 a year, or $5 a month, on a $300,000 home, with lake cabins paying nothing. Even so, both failed with just over 40% of the vote. In Frazee-Vergas, about 46% supported its request.
When a levy fails, the financial pressure does not disappear. Last November, Marshall voters rejected a $2 million, 10-year operating referendum. The school board then approved cuts of at least $1.8 million for 2026-27, including districtwide staffing reductions and the elimination of programs.
In Deer River, after multiple referendums failed, the district must now cut $2 million, or 12% of its budget. Nearly 70% of that budget goes toward staff costs, so most of the cuts will fall on staffing.
In a June 2026 survey by the Minnesota Rural Education Association, 61% of 105 responding rural districts reported reducing instructional staff, and the survey’s write-up mentions larger class sizes and fewer secondary course offerings. The whole community feels it. If we believe rural communities must remain viable, we must consider what happens when their schools cannot adequately serve their students.
Is it time to rethink how Minnesota pays for schools?
Perhaps the bigger problem is not that voters reject referendums. Rather, Minnesota has become too dependent on local property taxpayers to finance an essential statewide responsibility.
That creates inequities. Communities with different property tax capacity, enrollment and economic circumstances face very different odds of raising the same amount. A student’s opportunities should not depend so heavily on their ZIP code.
It is time to examine a different balance between statewide and local funding. Options include a more progressive income tax; a carefully designed tax on accumulated wealth; and redirecting existing alcohol, tobacco and cannabis tax revenue to schools.
Each option shifts who pays, and the state’s own numbers show how differently. The Department of Revenue’s 2026 tax incidence study found that the individual income tax is the only major progressive tax. Redirecting money the state already collects is another option. Alcohol and tobacco taxes together raised about $655 million in fiscal year 2024, compared with $14.9 billion from the income tax, and the cannabis tax is now 15%. Dedicating that revenue to schools would not raise anyone’s taxes, but the general fund would lose it unless lawmakers replaced it.
A wealth tax is a different kind of idea. This year’s HF 4616, which proposed a 1% tax on wealth above $10 million, would have reached about 5,600 taxpayers and raised an estimated $288 million in its first year, but it never reached a floor vote, and opponents warned of avoidance and departures. Just 4 of the 38 nations in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development countries had net wealth taxes in 2017, down from 12 in 1990, and the OECD found their revenues generally low.
Another starts with the local tax base itself. Seasonal recreational property, such as lake cabins, is excluded from the base for operating referendums, so other property owners carry that cost. The exclusion dates to 2001. Cabin owners still pay other taxes, including the state levy and local building levies, but whether they should share operating costs deserves a hearing.
None of these options is a complete solution. Each deserves an honest look at who pays, who benefits and how reliably the revenue can support schools.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
