Action News 5 Memphis — News
16/11/2026 16:01

These doctors had a history of being disciplined. Prison officials hired them anyway

KANKAKEE, Ill. — (InvestigateTV)

When John Paris married his wife, Vikki, in 2008 he took the vow to see her through sickness and in health, for better or for worse. Even before saying those words, he knew what would be required – given his new bride was serving time behind bars in an Illinois prison.

“We loved each other deeply and didn’t care what anybody else thought,” he said.

Their relationship would be tested again a decade later, when Vikki – a bladder cancer survivor – had testing done that revealed potential warning signs the disease could be making a return.

A year went by before Vikki was finally seen and got the diagnosis they’d been dreading. It was bladder cancer.

But by then, it was too late – the disease had already spread to her lungs and kidneys.

Within months, Vikki was dead. Her husband claimed in a civil lawsuit that prison doctors were negligent and delayed Vikki’s care - leaving him without his best friend.

“Just basically took everything from me,” he said. “She deserved a lot better.”

But what John learned later from InvestigateTV added to his dread. Several of the physicians involved in Vikki’s case had histories of providing inadequate care, according to an InvestigateTV analysis of state medical board records.

Their disciplinary histories show sanctions for failures to diagnose, follow-up and notify patients about important medical issues.

But the issue is not isolated to Illinois. InvestigateTV spent months analyzing personnel records from state correctional agencies nationwide and searching for matches in state medical board disciplinary records. We found dozens of doctors with disciplinary histories practicing behind bars.

Those physicians, InvestigateTV’s research uncovered, had records that included medical license suspensions, restrictions that limited what procedures they could do and who they could treat, as well as medical license revocations.

In a small number of cases, InvestigateTV even found doctors whose histories showed their licenses had at one point been limited to practicing only within a correctional setting.

And these doctors - paid by tax dollars - were, with the full knowledge of state officials, hired or allowed to remain on the prison medical staff to treat men and women who can’t choose their own doctors.

“I don’t know if it’s widely known that these health care providers, some of whom have quite serious histories of misconduct, are essentially being foisted upon a captive population who has no choice,” said David Fathi, the director of the ACLU’S National Prison Project.

Andrea Armstrong, a professor of law at Loyola University New Orleans College of Law said, “if it’s your brother, if it’s your uncle, if it’s your cousin, if it’s your neighbor. You know, these are things that matter.”

Many prisons keep doctors’ names secret

Many prison officials refused to turn over names of physicians working behind bars for a variety of reasons, even though their positions are paid with tax dollars.

InvestigateTV filed public records requests with the correctional agencies in all 50 states.

Michigan estimated that it would need $800 in payment from InvestigateTV to fill the request. Nebraska wanted as much as $4,500 for the 140 hours of staff time the state claimed would be needed to respond.

Others, including Tennessee and North Carolina, delayed responding for months despite repeated attempts to follow up and gain access to records.

Eighteen other states either denied InvestigateTV’s requests, said they had no responsive records, or referred us to private contractors that provide medical care in state prisons. Idaho redacted provider names as “trade secrets” and Vermont shielded physicians from disclosure, saying the release of contracted names is exempt “due to privacy concerns”.

“We, as taxpayers and residents – we have the right to understand what the government is doing in our names and with our tax dollars. So, the failure to provide records is bewildering,” said Armstrong.

When unable to obtain information about providers through public records requests, InvestigateTV used salary databases made available online by individual state governments to track down some physicians working in state prison systems.

Ultimately, InvestigateTV was able to obtain the names of prison doctors employed in prison systems from 25 states, some dating as far back as 2020.

Doctors of ‘last resort’

After obtaining the names of prison providers, InvestigateTV used publicly searchable records from state medical boards to determine if doctors working in correctional settings had disciplinary histories.

Our team spent six months reviewing records for nearly 1,500 doctors from across the nation - finding at least 120 physicians in 17 states had at some point been disciplined by medical boards. While all had active licenses at the time of employment, some physicians had multiple actions against them, including discipline handed down after criminal convictions.

At least 30 had faced suspensions in the past.

Other physicians had practice restrictions, and some had surrendered their licenses or had them revoked – including some doctors who had been employed as Medical Directors in correctional settings.

“When somebody’s been disciplined, especially when their license has been restricted, that means that a colleague has expressed doubts about their ability to safely deliver care,” said Armstrong. “Just like in the real world, people make mistakes. They’re disciplined for those. And we as consumers of health care have an opportunity to choose our doctors. But that looks radically different behind bars because there is no choice.”

The conduct that resulted in discipline included drug and alcohol abuse, criminal convictions for drug offenses, DUI and fraud, sexual misconduct, missed diagnoses, improper prescribing, involvement in pill mills, drug diversion and inadequate care, records showed.

“What we know is that most of these systems are using doctors of, in some ways, last resort,” Armstrong said. “These are people who cannot practice anywhere else. And so, if they want to earn a living with the degree that they earned, then it only happens behind bars.”

Some doctors themselves had served time in prison. Some could see patients only with a chaperone, and some were barred from treating female patients. A few were even restricted at some point to practicing solely in prison settings.

“There should be no double standard,” Fathi said. “Doctors found unqualified to treat people in the community should not treat incarcerated patients.”

Yet that’s what happened in a South Carolina case settled in August that involved a physician with multiple license suspensions in his history in multiple states following incidents of self-prescribing, substandard care as well as a conviction for domestic violence.

Court filings in that civil lawsuit claim the doctor was working on behalf of a contractor that provides prison healthcare in several states and had been hired despite egregious conduct in his history. The suit claims negligent care led to the 2023 death of a young man who was being held in a county jail.

While the doctor died last year - before his death, records showed, his license had been limited, with the state medical board saying he “must work only at sites within the South Carolina Department of Corrections.”

The South Carolina Board of Medical Examiners told InvestigateTV the physician applied for and was offered a position in a correctional setting, which the board approved. They said he was not mandated to work in a correctional institution and was free to petition the board to remove the restriction or request approval to change employment – which did not happen before his death.

The South Carolina Department of Corrections did not respond to requests for comment.

‘Incarcerated people pay, often with their health, and sometimes with their lives’

South Carolina isn’t the only state where families say a risky hire had real consequences.

The Paris case in Illinois is another example. Vikki Paris was convicted in Illinois in 2005 in the shooting death of her first husband. Multiple records said the shooting followed years of spousal abuse. She took a plea deal and was given 20 years in state prison.

Her husband, John Paris, says she ended up with a death sentence instead, because of delays in her care.

“Your Hippocratic oath does not say heal all except those in prison. No, no. Do no harm is the main thing. And by ignoring people, that’s the exact opposite of your oath,” he said.

In 2021, Paris filed a civil lawsuit against five of the doctors involved in his wife’s care as well as Wexford, the company contracted by the Illinois Department of Corrections and paid with tax dollars to provide medical services.

Despite Vikki Paris experiencing months of severe pain and repeatedly reporting blood in her urine, the suit claims prison doctors didn’t get a second opinion, order additional testing or refer her to a urologist – delaying her diagnosis until it was too late.

Wexford declined to comment, and the Illinois Department of Corrections never responded to repeated requests from InvestigateTV. Just days before securing a settlement, the physicians involved were dropped from the suit – none provided responses to questions sent by email.

But InvestigateTV found three of the doctors named as defendants had prior disciplinary records, including action taken because of problems with patient care. One of the physicians had been reprimanded by the Illinois State Medical Board just three years before Vikki’s cancer reemerged.

Records show that disciplinary action followed settlement in a case that resulted from an “an alleged failure to timely diagnose breast cancer leading to a delay in treatment and poor prognosis” in a different patient.

That physician, InvestigateTV found, is still listed as an independent contractor in the Illinois prison system.

David Fathi said he was disturbed but not surprised by the discovery.

Second chances for problem providers

Dr. Keith Ivens, a Tennessee-based physician who oversaw prison health care for his own company and private contractors in states nationwide before retiring, said hiring for medical jobs in prisons can be challenging.

Lower paying salaries, the often-remote location of prison facilities and the complexity of the patient population are key reasons he said correctional institutions struggle to consistently hire top providers into the industry.

“If I had a university professor who wanted to work in my facility versus somebody with a fraud or sexual crime history, I want to hire the university professor,” Ivens said. “University professors are not lining up to take my jobs. I have to get medical providers into these institutions.”

Ivens admitted hiring doctors with serious discipline in their history does involve risk, but he said employers can and must monitor those with difficult histories. In his experience, he said some doctors with a dark past have performed “extraordinarily well” when given an opportunity to return to medicine through work in a correctional setting.

David Fathi with the ACLU doesn’t see it that way.

“If an airline is having trouble hiring enough pilots, they don’t get to say, well, we’ll just hire the person who lost their license for a while because they were flying while drunk. No, they have to hire someone who’s qualified, and the rule should be exactly the same when it comes to health care, which is every bit as much a matter of life and death,” he said.

‘Safe, competent care’ must be a priority

Until last month, Ivens chaired the National Commission on Correctional Health Care, a nonprofit that sets voluntary national quality standards for prison medicine. InvestigateTV sent the organization our findings.

The organization wouldn’t comment specifically but said in an emailed statement “Our mission is to improve correctional health care, not to defend inadequate practices or excuse shortcomings. Correctional facilities face significant challenges recruiting and retaining qualified health care professionals, reflecting broader workforce shortages across the country. However, staffing challenges do not justify compromising professional qualifications or standards of care. NCCHC’s position is that incarceration should never mean accepting a lower standard of health care. Ensuring that patients receive safe, competent care must always be the priority.”

The organization said its standards, which are voluntary, call for facilities to check providers’ licenses and credentials, including querying state licensing boards and a national repository of disciplinary information for any sanctions or disciplinary actions. The standards, the statement said, also prohibits clinicians from practicing under licenses that restrict their practice solely to correctional health care – in contrast to what InvestigateTV found in a few situations.

The commission emphasized there’s an important distinction between a history of professional discipline and a current license restriction, writing, “Disciplinary actions vary in severity, and restrictions may subsequently be lifted. NCCHC standards require verification of disciplinary histories but do not automatically prohibit employment based solely on past disciplinary action.”

InvestigateTV contacted correctional agencies in the 17 states that our investigation found employed physicians with a disciplinary history – either directly or through a contractor – asking about specific provider conduct and overall policies related to the employment of previously sanctioned doctors.

Only a few including Kentucky, Louisiana, North Carolina, Oregon and Washington provided full responses – with states saying the disciplinary actions identified by the investigation had been resolved and that doctors, like the people in their care, deserve a second chance.

SEE FULL STATE RESPONSES BELOW

Improving care: ‘We have a long way to go’

Experts from industry and advocacy agree that there are solutions that could improve healthcare provided behind bars.

Fathi said staffing shortages can be addressed by offering higher pay, more vacation or flexible hours. When courts have required prison systems to increase medical staffing, he said, those systems have found a way to do so.

Dr. Ivens echoed the call for higher salaries to entice more desirable candidates and pointed to telemedicine as a way to get in-demand physicians into the system without requiring them to move to rural locations.

For her part, Armstrong suggested partnering with public health agencies already experienced in providing complex care to the wider population. But she and others said the real solution is drastically reducing the number of people in incarceration so that their care can be managed effectively.

“There has to be a level at which a prison can say, “No, I can’t safely take any more people into custody because I don’t have the staff to provide the constitutionally required services,’ and that’s on the prisons to alert the public that they cannot do what they’re obligated to do because of the numbers,” Armstrong said.

Until changes happen, the loved ones of people impacted by the care provided by problematic doctors believe the incarcerated will pay the price.

“You’re costing money and lives. That’s all there is to it,” John Paris said.

Paris fought tirelessly for his wife’s release after her diagnosis, successfully securing clemency from Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker in March 2020.

Vikki Paris was home just four days before she died from cancer that her lawsuit claims could have been treated if it was caught earlier.

“She said, ‘Don’t worry about it. I’ve made my peace. I’m home with you. You kept your promise. You’re not letting me die in prison’,” he said.

RESPONSES FROM STATE CORRECTIONAL AGENCIES TO QUESTIONS FROM INVESTIGATETV

CALIFORNIA: “California Correctional Health Care Services (CCHCS) is committed to providing safe, appropriate, and professional medical care to incarcerated patients. Because personnel records and peer review information are confidential, CCHCS cannot comment on specific employees, former employees, or allegations involving individual providers.”

IDAHO: “The Idaho Department of Correction follows the terms of our contract with Centurion regarding information they designate as confidential or proprietary. When Centurion marks information as a protected trade secret under Idaho Code 74‑107(1), IDOC is required to review and redact that information before release. For additional information about Centurion’s classification of provider identities, you may contact Centurion directly."

INDIANA: “Thank you again for your inquiry. Unfortunately, since the individuals whose names you’ve requested are employees of Centurion and not the State of Indiana, we need to direct you to Centurion’s media team.”

IOWA: “Sounds like you reached out to most of the States with this request. Please reach out to our Open Records staff at [email protected] if you are wanting more information.”

KENTUCKY: “The Kentucky Department of Corrections is committed to ensuring the safety and well-being of all individuals in state custody. The Department of Corrections has several contracts in place with a variety of medical providers. Currently, the Department contracts with Wellpath, an independent medical provider, to afford those in state custody access to medical care and treatment; Diamond Pharmaceuticals has the contract for all prescription medication; Mid-America has the contract for dental care. These vendors are responsible for employing qualified medical personnel and ensuring they meet applicable licensing and professional requirements. All employees providing services through these contracted vendors are employed by the vendor and not the state. For a list of medical providers/employees, you would need to contact the vendor directly. At any time, the Department is made aware of inappropriate behavior, misconduct, or actions not aligned with departmental policy, the vendor is immediately notified, and if warranted, the Department will request the employee not be allowed further admission to the prison. Thank you.”

LOUISIANA: “The Louisiana Department of Public Safety & Corrections takes all allegations of professional misconduct seriously and recognizes its responsibility to ensure that individuals employed in medical positions are qualified to perform their duties and provide appropriate care to those in our custody.

The Department thoroughly reviews matters brought to its attention and considers relevant circumstances, professional qualifications, licensure status, and applicable employment requirements when making hiring and personnel decisions. A history of disciplinary action or criminal involvement does not necessarily constitute an automatic disqualification from employment, provided an individual meets the legal and professional requirements of the position.

As an agency that emphasizes rehabilitation, reentry, and second chances for the individuals in our custody, we believe those principles should extend beyond the walls of our correctional facilities. It would be inconsistent with our mission to advocate for second chances while categorically denying employment opportunities to qualified individuals who have taken the necessary steps to move forward from past mistakes.

Our responsibility is to evaluate individuals based on their qualifications, their ability to fulfill the essential duties of their positions, and their adherence to the professional and ethical standards expected of Department employees. We remain committed to maintaining those standards while recognizing that past mistakes do not necessarily define an individual’s ability to contribute meaningfully to our workforce."

NEVADA: “Medical contractors are reviewed before being hired. We can’t release personnel information, but we can say any disciplinary cases were closed before hire.”

NORTH CAROLINA: “The Department of Adult Correction takes seriously its responsibility to provide health care services to the incarcerated population by providing care that is consistent with standards of care that would be received in the community.

The people on the list you provided are all currently employed with the NC Department of Adult Correction. For the five you highlighted, we are aware of the past actions by the NC Medical Board.

Those physicians are fully licensed to practice medicine in North Carolina with unrestricted licenses. They have resolved their past issues—none of which involved criminal allegations or charges—to the full satisfaction of the medical board.

All NCDAC employees undergo a thorough criminal background check before employment. With all our medical professionals, we monitor all licensure actions and review in detail every two years with re-credentialing.”

OREGON: “The health and well-being of those in our care is a high priority. Too often the people coming into our prison system have complex medical conditions, high mental health needs, substance use disorders, and co-occurring disorders. It’s also an aging population with approximately 1,400 adults in custody age 60 years or older. We recognize the challenges facing correctional healthcare in Oregon, and as an agency we are dedicated to addressing them with innovation and process improvement. Patient-centered care must be central to what we do, and I am grateful for the dedication and hard work of our healthcare staff. As we move forward, I am committed to a transparent process of change in our Health Services Division to ensure we have the leadership, resources, and support needed to provide the highest standard of care.”

SOUTH CAROLINA: “The SC Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation issues medical licenses and determines whether someone is eligible to practice medicine in South Carolina. Those licenses are necessary for employment. If someone has a valid medical license in SC, they are eligible to be considered for employment. Also, SCDC believes in second chances. Every day we ask employers and community members to give inmates second chances. A previous act does not always define a person’s current reality.”

TEXAS: “The agency partners with University of Texas Medical Branch and Texas Tech to conduct medical care. Thus, these individuals would be employees of those institutions. Please reach out to them.”

VERMONT: “Our medical provider is WellPath.”

WASHINGTON: “DOC holds its medical professionals to high standards. Before being hired, they are subjected to background checks through the National Crime Information Center (NCIC) and under the Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA). We also seek board certifications, where appropriate, and confirm that candidates have an active license.

If a current employee is accused of misconduct that violates their license, the alleged violation is reported to the Department of Health and DOC also conducts its own investigation. If the allegations are substantiated and the individual loses their license, they are terminated.

Incarcerated individuals in our care and custody deserve excellent health care. The agency has made significant strides in recent years to improve the level of care we offer. Our Health Services division has transitioned to a model centered on the patient and focused on prevention to improve outcomes. We implemented a fatality review process that examines each unexpected death in our facilities to determine if anything could have been done differently. DOC is currently implementing a much-needed electronic health records system that will replace an antiquated and inefficient paper system.”

RESPONSES FROM PRISON MEDICINE CONTRACTORS TO QUESTIONS FROM INVESTIGATETV

THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS MEDICAL BRANCH: “The University of Texas Medical Branch is committed to providing patients in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice system with safe, high-quality care. Everyone UTMB hires for Correctional Managed Care must go through TDCJ’s clearance process before they start. When we hire licensed clinicians, UTMB reviews their licensure and board history. After that, they are required to report any change in license status to UTMB. Any exception is reviewed on a case-by-case basis and approved by TDCJ. As a matter of policy, UTMB does not comment on individual personnel matters.”

Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center: “Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center is committed to providing safe, high-quality healthcare to the patients we serve, including those in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ) system. TTUHSC maintains rigorous standards for clinical quality, patient safety and professional accountability.

Prior to employment, all physicians undergo a comprehensive credentialing process that includes verification of licensure, training, qualifications, professional history and review of any disciplinary actions or restrictions associated with their medical license. When appropriate, other specialists, including representatives from human resources, compliance and legal, may provide input on a pending application. Physicians hired to provide care through TTUHSC’s correctional healthcare programs must also complete the TDCJ’s clearance process before beginning employment.

Following employment, concerns related to patient care or professional conduct are evaluated through established peer review processes and may result in corrective action, termination, and, when appropriate, reporting to the Texas Medical Board.

As a matter of policy, TTUHSC does not comment on individual personnel matters."

WEXFORD: “Wexford Health appreciates your inquiry, but we do not have any comment or response at this time.”

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Action News 5 Memphis — News.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

18-year-old man charged after high-speed pursuit ends with crash into Frayser home
Action News 5 Memphis — News
An 18-year-old man faces charges after a high-speed pursuit ended in a crash into a Frayser home, injuring tw…
City of Memphis once again distributing free food boxes ahead of Thanksgiving. Here’s where:
Action News 5 Memphis — News
Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and the City of Memphis is once again stepping up to ensure everyone …
THE BREAKDOWN: November 2026 El Niño Update
Action News 5 Memphis — News
A Very Strong, or “Super” El Niño has developed in the Pacific Ocean as winter approaches
Zoo monitoring Fiona the hippo after she ingested object ‘tossed’ by visitor
Action News 5 Memphis — News
Zoo staff are watching the hippo around the clock after a visitor's hat landed in Hippo Cove.
Cross County Sheriff’s Office welcomes new K-9
Action News 5 Memphis — News
The Cross County Sheriff’s Office welcomes its newest furry member, Bane!
SpaceXAI affiliate buys more than 96 acres in Whitehaven for $5.5 million
Action News 5 Memphis — News
A SpaceXAI affiliate purchased more than 96 acres in Whitehaven for $5.5 million, according to a deed filed w…