Cook County Jail wrongful death lawsuit set to settle for record $7.25 million
This story was produced by Injustice Watch, a nonprofit newsroom in Chicago that investigates issues of equity and justice in the Cook County court system. Sign up here to get their weekly newsletter.
The family of a man with mental illness who died at the Cook County Jail after being beaten by correctional officers has agreed to dismiss a wrongful death lawsuit against the county in exchange for $7.25 million.
The Cook County Board of Commissioners Finance Committee is set to vote Wednesday on the deal, which if approved by the full board would be the county’s largest single payout for a jail-related lawsuit since at least 2007, according to an Injustice Watch analysis of settlement data.
The lawsuit revolves around the death of 41-year-old Cory Ulmer in June 2024. Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart’s office, which runs the jail, told Ulmer’s family only that he died following a medical emergency, but an internal report leaked to Injustice Watch just days after his demise showed officers repeatedly struck him in the jail’s emergency room after Ulmer became “combative.”
Records obtained since then show the sheriff’s internal investigators found several officers committed misconduct against Ulmer, with two officers now facing termination. One of those officers had been recommended for firing a decade ago but was allowed to remain on the job, records show.
Officers began striking Ulmer after he tried running out of a small, bedless holding cell in the jail’s basement known as a “bullpen,” where he had been kept for at least 24 hours awaiting transfer to a psychiatric unit, records show. Officers then dragged Ulmer into the emergency room and witnesses told investigators the officers proceeded to kick, punch, and knee him as he lay facedown, shackled and facing away from security cameras, records show. Ulmer was then injected with sedatives and became unresponsive and was declared dead upon arrival soon after at Mount Sinai Hospital, records show. The Cook County medical examiner ruled his death a homicide.
Ulmer was taken to jail just a day before he died for violating his court-ordered curfew following 2023 assault and armed robbery charges. The arresting officers with the sheriff’s electronic monitoring unit noted Ulmer was unwell; he was walking on the road shirtless after midnight, and one of the officers speculated Ulmer was “off his meds,” records show. The officers considered taking Ulmer home or to a hospital but took him to the jail instead, records show.
Ulmer’s stepfather, Robert Robinson, sued the county in federal court last year, alleging the officers used excessive force against Ulmer in violation of his constitutional rights and that the jail’s medical staff failed to provide him with adequate care or antipsychotic medications, “despite obvious signs that his mental state was deteriorating.” In court filings, the county denied those allegations.
Ulmer died less than two weeks after Injustice Watch published “Dying on Dart’s Watch,” which revealed inadequate medical care and supervision underlying at least half of the 18 deaths at the jail in 2023. That was the most deaths there in any year since 2013, when the jail’s average daily population was twice as high.
Since Ulmer’s death, at least another 28 detainees have died at the jail, records show.
In a statement, Robinson’s attorney, Jesse Guth, said there was “no excuse for the brutality that Cory suffered” and called on lawmakers to open the jail to independent monitoring, to review conditions at the facility for detainees.
“History will continue to repeat itself until changes are implemented,” Guth said.
Dart handily won another four-year term in this month’s general election. Citing pending litigation, he declined to be interviewed, as did Dr. Priscilla Ware, medical director of the jail’s healthcare provider, Cermak Health Services. Ware was not a defendant in the lawsuit.
Firings, suspensions held up in arbitration
The sheriff’s Office of Professional Review closed its internal investigation into Ulmer’s death in December 2025, a year and a half after he died, records show. Investigators probed the actions of 18 correctional officers and said two should be fired and six should be suspended.
Of the 11 medical staffers named in the lawsuit, one has since left the jail, records show. The others — including doctors, nurses and mental health specialists — continued to work there as of late October. In response to emailed questions, a spokesperson for Cermak Health Services, a division of Cook County Health, did not say whether any of the medical staff had been disciplined.
Investigators recommended that Sgt. Enrique Reyes and correctional officer Jason Jackson be terminated from their jobs at the jail, records show. Injustice Watch could not reach Reyes and Jackson directly. Their attorneys did not respond to requests for comment.
Both used unnecessary force against Ulmer, investigators found; a medical staff member who witnessed the beating told investigators that Jackson hit Ulmer the most, and even kicked him in the head multiple times. Investigators also found that Reyes told medical staff to “leave the area” and turned off his body-worn camera during the incident. Reyes told investigators he turned his camera off because Ulmer was about to receive medical attention, but investigators found that to be untrue, records show.
Jackson’s fate now lies with the sheriff’s Merit Board, a seven-member body appointed by Dart and approved by a majority of county commissioners with final say over firings of correctional officers. Reyes’ firing is before an arbitrator, as is required by the correctional sergeant’s union contract, according to Dart’s spokesperson. In the meantime, both have been stripped of their police powers and were assigned to work at a warehouse, the spokesperson said.
Reyes and Jackson had each been investigated for misconduct several times prior to Ulmer’s death, according to data provided by Dart’s office through a public records request.
Investigators recommended that Jackson be fired a year after he was hired in 2016 for allowing detainees to enter a visiting area without permission, and failing to stop those detainees from masturbating in view of visitors. However, his case was instead handled by an arbitrator, who ruled that Dart’s office should reinstate Jackson six months later, according to the sheriff’s spokesperson.
“Given the fact that Jackson was suspended without pay for approximately 140 workdays … the Sheriff’s Office considered his unpaid suspension to be appropriate disciplinary action and did not initiate further proceedings,” the spokesperson said in a statement.
The sheriff’s internal investigators would go on to sustain misconduct allegations against Jackson in four more disciplinary cases for several policy violations such as using unnecessary force and threatening another person with bodily harm, records show.
Reyes was investigated on allegations he used excessive force in 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2021, and for allegedly failing to follow policy in 2023. Investigators either exonerated him, closed the investigation without a disposition, or did not sustain the allegations, data show.
The other six officers with sustained misconduct allegations in Ulmer’s investigation face suspensions ranging from 45 to 120 days for using unnecessary force and being untruthful to investigators, among other policy violations, records show. So far, only one officer has served a suspension, and an arbitrator reduced it from 45 days to five; the rest are still in arbitration, Dart’s spokesperson said. According to investigators, three of those officers failed to report a separate use of force against Ulmer on the morning of the day he died. That incident resulted in Ulmer falling and hitting the back of his head; it was discovered only after the jail’s surveillance team reviewed all of Ulmer’s movements from that day, records show.
Representatives for the correctional officers’ union, Teamsters Local 700, did not respond to requests for comment. A spokesperson for the correctional sergeants’ union, AFSCME Council 31 Local 3692, said the union does not answer questions about pending grievances.
Dart’s internal investigators did not look into why jail officials failed to notify the Cook County medical examiner when Ulmer died, records show.
Under county code, law enforcement officers should “immediately” notify the medical examiner upon a death in custody. The medical examiner then dispatches investigators to the scene to take photos, conduct interviews, and produce a report. The medical examiner was instead notified by a Mount Sinai nurse nearly six hours after Ulmer was pronounced dead, records show. By then, the jail’s emergency room, where officers beat him, had been cleaned.
In an email, Dart’s spokesperson did not deny jail officials failed to notify the medical examiner but said the sheriff’s office “worked to support every independent investigation conducted by outside agencies in this case.”
Jail officials enacted a dozen policy changes and directives following Ulmer’s death, including installing cameras to eliminate blind spots in the jail’s hospital, and instructing staff to provide water to detainees in the bullpen, records show.
Growing calls for independent oversight
The vote to settle the Ulmer lawsuit comes alongside calls for more oversight of the jail and the sheriff’s office.
Currently, only the Illinois Department of Corrections provides external monitoring of the jail through its jail and detention standards unit, which conducts annual inspections of the facility and issues yearly reports. But advocates and their allies on the Cook County Board of Commissioners say more oversight of the jail is needed to protect people incarcerated there.
Matthew McLoughlin, a campaign coordinator with the Illinois Network for Pretrial Justice, a coalition working to reduce the number of people incarcerated in jails across the state, said commissioners need more than the once-a-year reports to better understand the conditions in the Cook County Jail. An independent oversight body “would allow for that kind of regular communication,” he told Injustice Watch in an interview.
In 2025, state inspectors found the jail “violated standards for supervision, security, admissions procedures, reporting, sanitation and more,” the Illinois Answers Project reported in September. Inspectors have cited the jail for violations in six of the past nine years, including every year since 2022, the nonprofit newsroom reported.
“Obviously, four years in a row of failed inspections, the accountability is not there,” McLoughlin said.
In an email, Dart’s spokesperson pushed back against the characterization of the sheriff’s office as having “failed” inspections, stressing that inspectors had found the jail to be in compliance with the vast majority of state standards each year.
The jail was previously subject to independent monitoring as part of a series of federal consent decrees, but those ended in 2017. Meanwhile, jails in cities including New York, Los Angeles, Denver, and Philadelphia are currently under some form of oversight aside from regulatory inspections, research shows.
In September, Cook County Commissioner Tara Stamps and four co-sponsors introduced a resolution calling for an “independent review” of the jail, “focusing on the health, safety and wellness of the detainees and conditions of confinement.” The resolution came nearly two years after the board held a hearing on jail deaths following Injustice Watch’s reporting. But Stamps pulled the resolution from a vote in the board’s Health and Hospitals Committee because her colleagues said it could prove to be a legal liability, the Illinois Answers Project reported.
Injustice Watch obtained an analysis of the resolution done by Cathy McNeil Stein, civil actions bureau chief for the Cook County state’s attorney’s office, and sent to county commissioners a day before they were set to vote. Stein said Stamps’ resolution would be “harmful” to the county’s legal position in pending and future litigation, and would increase its “financial jeopardy.”
Even if the resolution passed, Stein wrote, the board could not unilaterally order Dart to open the jail to an independent monitor, as state law says Illinois sheriffs have “final policymaking authority over jails in their counties,” citing state law and a circuit court ruling out of DuPage County.
Stamps told the Illinois Answers Project that she would “retool” and reintroduce the resolution this month, but she had not done so as of publication of this article.
In an op-ed for the Chicago Sun-Times published last week, a group of interfaith clergy called on commissioners to advance Stamps’ resolution. “The public deserves a clear explanation of how delaying an independent review serves the interests of those in custody and the broader community,” they wrote.
Stamps did not respond to requests for comment.
Meanwhile, Dart’s office has also recently come under scrutiny by Tirrell J. Paxton, the county’s independent inspector general.
In September, records show, Paxton issued six recommendations to the sheriff’s office after a review of more than 100 complaints forwarded to the sheriff’s Office of Professional Review by Paxton and his predecessors found that although the office “generally takes appropriate action,” there were “recurring deficiencies in investigative consistency, documentation, and case management.”
Dart’s general counsel, Nicholas Scouffas, fired back at Paxton, saying Paxton “did not possess the requisite information, data, understanding, wherewithal, and authority” to make the recommendations, and that the sheriff’s office rejected all of them.
The county board is now weighing whether to hold a hearing on Paxton’s potential oversight; it has also asked the state’s attorney’s office to provide a legal opinion of the matter.
Jennifer Vollen-Katz, executive director of prison watchdog group John Howard Association of Illinois, which monitored the jail from 1988 to 2011, told Injustice Watch that more oversight of the jail would ultimately reduce the county’s exposure to lawsuits and “can identify the policies and practices that are leading to these kinds of horrific outcomes that are costing people their lives and costing the taxpayers millions of dollars.”
“Sometimes just knowing you’re being watched prevents people from behaving badly,” Vollen-Katz said.
Carlos Ballesteros reports for Injustice Watch, a nonprofit newsroom in Chicago that investigates issues of equity and justice in the court system. To read the full Injustice Watch series, please go here.
Carlos Ballesteros reports for Injustice Watch, a nonprofit newsroom in Chicago that investigates issues of equity and justice in the court system. To read the full Injustice Watch series, please go here.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
