KSL.com Salt Lake City — News
16/11/2026 12:27

So, you submitted a public comment to a government agency. Is anyone listening?

  • More than 1.5 million Americans commented on the USDA's proposal to rescind the 2001 Roadless Rule.
  • The Interior Department says it weighs comment content over tallies, addressing substantive points.
  • Public input in a small Utah town led the Bureau of Land Management to reroute a power line.

Over the past two years, Americans submitted more than 1.5 million comments to the Department of Agriculture on its proposal to rescind the 2001 Roadless Rule. An overwhelming majority opposed repealing the U.S. Forest Service policy, which protects more than 44 million acres of undeveloped land across 38 states.

But as early as June 2025, Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins told a gathering of Western states governors that “the U.S. Department of Agriculture is rescinding the 2001 Roadless Rule.” She made the Trump administration’s intentions clear.

Due to hard-fought procedural and environmental law, however, government agencies must follow certain protocols before such policy or rule changes can be made. Among those is soliciting and considering public comments, which the Forest Service did through portals managed by the General Services Administration.

Though the response was unequivocal in both the 2025 and 2026 public comment periods, the USDA still announced in August that the Forest Service filed a plan to rescind the Roadless Rule. Decision makers are currently reviewing the second period’s comments, but there’s no indication that they would reverse course.

A trail sign on the White Pine Lake Trail in Little Cottonwood Canyon on Thursday, Aug. 27, 2026. The White Pine Trail is located in the Wasatch-Cache National Forest and is protected under the Roadless Rule. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has proposed a formal rule to rescind the Roadless Rule, which would lift federal protections against road building and logging across nearly 45 to 59 million acres of national forest lands. | Laura Seitz, Deseret News

Such actions raise questions about how much impact public input has on government decisions. Perhaps first and foremost among them is: Does anyone actually read those millions of comments?

If so, how do the agencies collect and catalogue the comments? Are they treated as votes for a particular outcome? Does sheer volume influence decisions or is the substance of a comment more important? How do they fit in among all other considerations and findings?

Do decision makers care about them at all? And maybe most pressing: If public comments can be duly ignored, do they even matter?

Informing government decisions

Aspen trees line the White Pine Lake Trail in Little Cottonwood Canyon on Thursday, Aug. 27, 2026. The White Pine Trail is located in the Wasatch-Cache National Forest and is protected under the Roadless Rule. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has proposed a formal rule to rescind the Roadless Rule, which would lift federal protections against road building and logging across nearly 45 to 59 million acres of national forest lands. | Laura Seitz, Deseret News

The short answer, from the agencies themselves and the political groups actively leveraging public comment periods, is that, of course, public comments matter. Not just for the immediate consideration of a particular rule, but also for the long life that debates over public land management tend to have.

As for whether or not anyone is listening, the agencies do some form of review of all comments and then they respond to those deemed substantial, though that determination of substance is not necessarily related to scale and is subjective to the administration.

“There’s no standard way of treating these issues,” John Leshy, the solicitor for the Interior Department during Bill Clinton’s presidency and the creation of the Roadless Rule, wrote in an email to Deseret News.

“It’s up to the agency and the administration involved how to categorize them and how much to consider them and how much weight to give them.”

Which is to say that the review that happens after comments are submitted is a mired-in-the-details process that’s often far less clear than the public’s response, particularly when that response is emphatic. When asked, both the U.S. Forest Service and the Interior Department wrote that comments “inform” the agency’s decision making.

“At the Department of the Interior, we welcome public input to help identify issues, analyze impacts and shape alternatives,” according to an Interior spokesperson. “This public input informs our decision-making.”

The Forest Service wrote that “public comments can help refine proposed activities and impact analyses, and inform the administrative record associated with a decision.”

A ‘mushy’ process

Hikers walk down the White Pine Lake Trail in Little Cottonwood Canyon on Thursday, Aug. 27, 2026. The White Pine Trail is located in the Wasatch-Cache National Forest and is protected under the Roadless Rule. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has proposed a formal rule to rescind the Roadless Rule, which would lift federal protections against road building and logging across nearly 45 to 59 million acres of national forest lands. | Laura Seitz, Deseret News

Even so, the longer answers to the above questions don’t provide a complete explanation. The word “inform” does not mean the same thing as “include,” and, as Leshy suggested, there’s an interpretive element attached to the way agencies consider and respond to public comments.

But in learning more about the process, it becomes clear — and understandable — how the public can be nearly unanimous in its approval or disapproval of a rule, yet the decision can go against its wishes.

That is happening quite frequently in the Trump administration, evidenced not only by the USDA’s formal filing of a proposal to rescind the Roadless Rule, but by several other rule changes as well.

The Bureau of Land Management rescinded the Public Lands Rule in March despite 95% public disapproval. The Forest Service filed a notice of intent to revise the Travel Management Rule though 99% of folks oppose fewer restrictions on motorized vehicle use. The BLM rolled back oil and gas leasing regulations amid 99.5% of comments against it.

For some of the larger rule changes, conservation groups help facilitate input through multimedia campaigns to inform their members and the public about what’s happening and, subsequently, how to comment. In some instances, those entities have software integrations that allow visitors to their websites to post comments directly to the government docket.

But as a tangible example of the democratic process in action — despite mixed outcomes — public comments do create a medley of positive use. Leshy wrote that while the process is “mushy,” public comments are vital for democracy.

“It is important to note that comments and signatures can influence policy — there’s just no formula or firm guidelines as to when and how much. Engagement and participation in such public processes are important and should be encouraged,” Leshy wrote.

“Such engagement may have influence not solely on the recipient agency and administration, but also on elected public officials... And that influence can last well past the decisions that are being made on the issues involved.”

Substance over scale

Deseret News spoke with a former Forest Service and National Park Service official who spent nearly four decades working on National Environmental Policy Act reviews — which require multiple rounds of public comment periods — impacting millions of acres of public land across the West and Alaska. Though retired, the official requested anonymity for fear of repercussions from the current administration.

The official said that the first thing folks need to know is that the commenting process is not the same thing as the voting process.

The official said that, yes, those top line numbers — that 70% or 99% oppose or support a proposal — are generally known internally, but are not part of final consideration. That gets lost in the hyperbole surrounding news headlines once assessments of comment periods are released.

It is the substance of the comments, rather, that are most important. Which was a sentiment reiterated by the Interior spokesperson in an email response to the Deseret News’ questions.

“The department considers the content of each public comment that it receives rather than simply tallying the number of comments that express support or opposition to a proposed action,” according to the spokesperson. “All substantive comments — defined as those that question or support the environmental analysis that provide a reasoned basis, present new information or propose new alternatives — are evaluated and addressed as part of the decision-making process.”

Inside the public comment process

The former Forest Service official described the decision-making process once the public comment period closes as reading, sorting and then determining which ideas are worthy of solutions in the final recommendations.

The comments are read first. From the former official’s experience, that task is often contracted outside the federal agencies. With current tech capabilities, that person also suggested that there’s a move to use artificial intelligence for the first pass. When asked directly, the Forest Service and the Interior did not respond to questions about the use of AI in assessing public comments.

After the contractor studies the comments, an interdisciplinary team inside the agency reads through the findings and the relevant statements. Those people review and separate the comments according to whether they present an actual issue or merely an opinion.

Government agencies do not have any legal obligation to address opinions, but they do have to consider the relevant issues presented.

Also, in the former official’s experience, the vast majority of the issues public comments reveal are ones the agencies have already worked out or considered when writing or updating policies. Occasionally, new ideas do pop up, however, and that is what agencies are often hoping to encounter in the comments.

“When it comes to the folks who are reviewing all these letters on the other side, really what they’re trying to learn — among other things — is like, ‘We just need to know all the angles of this issue. What did we miss?’” said Josh Hicks, a director of conservation campaigns for the Wilderness Society who worked on the effort to gather commenters for the repeal of the Roadless Rule.

Across the hundreds, thousands or — in rare cases — millions of comments received, similar tranches of issues are often revealed. They are considered individually. In the case of the Roadless Rule, opponents noted that since 80% of wildfires are sparked adjacent to roads, it does not make sense to build more roads in areas without them if a stated reason to repeal the rule is to help prevent wildfire.

After all the tranches of issues are identified, the agency determines what to do about each. Of those that are “unresolved” by the current rule or proposed new rule, the agency has a few options: it can dismiss those that aren’t relevant, respond to the most pressing by changing the various alternatives it suggests or to change the final analysis.

“When taking comments on a draft environmental impact statement or an environmental assessment, we may respond to comments by modifying alternatives, revising analyses, correcting information, or explaining why changes to the proposed action or analysis are not warranted,” wrote the Interior spokesperson. “Such responses are included in the environmental review and decision-making process (e.g., in the final environmental impact statement).”

Once each issue is considered and conclusions drawn by a team of informed public officials, the analysis is then presented to whomever is making the final decision.

The way the process is supposed to work, the former official said, is that the specialists reviewing all the comments, assessments and scientific reviews are supposed to be objective in their assessment, and to detail to the decision maker the consequences of the proposal and alternatives.

Then the person responsible to make the final call — often a high-ranking, though not the top executive, of the USDA or Interior — can be fully informed when their subjectivity is required. It is at this point, in theory — not necessarily months prior — when a record of decision is determined.

What counts, what doesn’t

There’s also some nuance — or confusion — about how public comments are counted and included.

In particular, there can be a difference between the number of comments posted on the government comment platform — regulations.gov — and those tracked by the conservation and legal nonprofits that mobilize efforts to submit public comments.

The recent comment period regarding coal production in the Powder River Basin is an example. A conservation group submitted more than 20,000 comments, but the BLM only posted around 6,000 at the time the period ended.

The Roadless Rule is another example. A consortium of hundreds of conservation and legal groups tracked more than a million comments that their members had submitted, which they either did directly or through portals their organizations have built into their websites. Once the comment period ended, the Forest Service posted 370,238 comments to the docket (today, more than 600,000 are available to review).

It is from that smaller number that the metric of 99% of comments opposing the change is derived, which — according to Hicks and other members of the consortium — suggests there’s an even greater margin that disagrees with a proposal.

The subtleties in these examples are many. Are comments submitted en masse considered individually? In a hypothetical, if 300,000 people all submitted the same letter auto-populated by a conservation group, does the Forest Service consider it a single comment?

The answers may be purely subject to how the data is collected, reviewed and considered.

Regulations.gov, which is the website managed by the Governmental Services Administration where public comments can be made, does hand over all the information it receives to the respective agencies.

The GSA just administers the comment collection, but one conservation group noticed two oddities on regulations.gov’s portal during the Roadless Rule public comment periods.

The software integration built between regulations.gov and the nonprofit’s website allowing its members to directly make comments stopped connecting. Comments could be uploaded seamlessly but afterward they required a dedicated upload. Many other organizations also lost their integration.

Also, the portal includes a field allowing commenters to detail the number of people associated with a comment. For one of the Roadless Rule comment periods, that field was removed from the form.

When asked several times over a few weeks for a response, the GSA did not respond to requests for comment on those changes.

Regardless, the Forest Service, BLM and the Interior all stressed that volume was a lesser concern than what the comments included. Like the Forest Service and the Interior, a BLM spokesperson told Deseret News that, “We prioritize the quality of comments over the volume of submissions.”

How public input influenced an outcome

Despite some comments seemingly falling on deaf ears — or not reaching the threshold to be considered “substantial” — all is not lost for those participating in those decisions.

Hicks, the director of conservation campaigns for the Wilderness Society, pointed out how the scale and consistency of public input has the ability to influence politicians, subsequent decisions in Congress and future agency leaders and generate greater civic engagement.

“There’s a lot of reasons to engage in these decision-making processes, even when you think it’s a dead end, and the administration might take an action where they’re just going to ignore you,” Hicks said.

“If the federal government just made decisions without taking any sort of public comment, that looks like a totally different model of government — where the federal government just takes action and steamrolls the public over and over again. And here, at least we have the opportunity to weigh in.”

Weighing in, too, doesn’t always land on deaf ears. Not only do the comment period numbers and percentages stay relevant decades after rules are created, they can also move the needle.

Last December, the BLM finalized a record of decision for the Cross-Tie 500-kV Transmission Project. It approved a high-voltage electrical power line that will run for more than a hundred miles from central Utah to east-central Nevada.

Residents of Leamington, a small town in Millard County, Utah, were worried about the impact the transmission lines would have on their views and the effect on an adjacent wilderness area.

Those comments led the BLM to suggest an alternative decision — referred to as “preferred alternative A” — in the final environmental impact statement it published in September 2024.

The suggestion lengthened the total distance the lines would travel, but it “replace(d) a portion of the Proposed Action in southeastern Juab County and northeastern Millard County, Utah, which would minimize potential effects to private landowners and their viewsheds in the area near Leamington, Utah, and would minimize potential effects to the Sevier River and agricultural property.”

Come December 2025, the BLM submitted its record of decision. It chose preferred alternative A.

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: KSL.com Salt Lake City — News.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

How this Spanish artist made her colorful Avenues home worth touring, even after her death
KSL.com Salt Lake City — News
The daughter of a late Salt Lake City artist hopes to preserve her mother's vibrant and art-filled home by st…
Teen hospitalized after stabbing at Ogden Preparatory Academy
KSL.com Salt Lake City — News
A teenage boy is in the hospital after being stabbed by a fellow student at school Monday afternoon.
Mix up the menu with a few fun Thanksgiving traditions that go beyond the food
KSL.com Salt Lake City — News
Kate Mulford said every family should have at least one Thanksgiving tradition beyond what's on your plate.
Driver accused of critically injuring man in Spanish Fork crosswalk is charged
KSL.com Salt Lake City — News
A woman who police say hit a man in a crosswalk in Spanish Fork but continued to drive has been charged.
The Utah Checkdown podcast: Arizona recap | Utah makes a statement in the desert & Dampier adds to Heisman lore
KSL.com Salt Lake City — News
Host Josh Furlong breaks down a wild weekend in Tucson, Arizona, as the undefeated Utah Utes (10-0) overcame …
3 people dead after small plane crash in Grand Canyon
KSL.com Salt Lake City — News
The National Park Service discovered wreckage of a plane crash with no survivors in the Grand Canyon Monday m…