New Jersey Monitor
16/11/2026 17:22

NJ challenges $11M verdict against cop who arrested stroke victim for drunk driving

A New Jersey state trooper whose roadside blunder left a motorist permanently disabled just made a mistake and should get immunity, the state says. (Photo by Dana DiFilippo / New Jersey Monitor)

New Jersey went to court Monday to ask a state appellate panel to vacate an $11.3 million jury verdict against a rookie state trooper whose mishandling of a minor car accident left a Jersey City woman permanently disabled.

The state’s attorneys argued that a trial judge got it wrong when he refused to give Trooper Jennifer Albuja immunity for failing to recognize that Cheryl Rhines hit a guardrail on her way to work in 2017 because she had a stroke — not because she was driving drunk, as Albuja wrongly deduced.

Cops make mistakes, and Albuja reasonably and sincerely suspected Rhines’ disorientation, slurred speech, and inability to stand suggested inebriation and warranted arrest, attorney Michael T.G. Long argued.

Long asked the three-judge panel to vacate the January 2025 verdict and grant immunity to Albuja, who’d graduated from the police academy the year before she responded to the call for motorist aid on Route 78.

But Dennis M. Donnelly, Rhines’ attorney, urged the panel to uphold the verdict, saying Albuja’s deliberate indifference, negligence, and failure to follow police training defeat any immunity claim.

Albuja acknowledged she had been trained on stroke symptoms while in the police academy and ignored the classic signs of a stroke that Rhines exhibited, including noticeable, one-sided facial drooping, difficulty speaking, and loss of control of her right leg and arm, Donnelly said. Dashcam footage showed Rhines repeatedly requested help and told Albuja: “I think I’m having a heart attack,” according to court briefs.

The trooper instead hauled Rhines to the state police’s Somerville barracks and shackled her to a bench in a holding cell there, delaying medical care for hours, Donnelly said. The delay led to a brain bleed and left Rhines unable to communicate and in need of lifelong caretaking, he added.

Officers also learn at the academy that even people suspected of crimes or those who get arrested are entitled to medical treatment, Donnelly added. Besides getting quicker stroke care, taking Rhines to the hospital 10 minutes away would have proved or disproved Albuja’s suspicions of intoxication, he said.

Donnelly told the judges that an emergency room physician who testified at trial said: “Every day of the week, I’m an emergency room doctor, and police bring in people and ask me, are they drunk or are they sick?”

That argument seemed persuasive to Judge Jack Sabatino, one of the judges on the panel.

“If the concern of the officer was the preservation of evidence because of the dissipation of blood alcohol in the body, if the plaintiff had gotten immediate attention at a hospital, they could have done a blood draw, right? That would be probably the most reliable and most efficient way to preserve the evidence. Taking her to the hospital did not foreclose the preservation of evidence, right?” Sabatino asked the state’s attorney.

“It did not, Your Honor,” Long acknowledged.

Donnelly urged the panel to uphold the jury’s verdict, warning a new trial risked higher damages. The jury initially announced a $19.1 million verdict but reduced it, recognizing that Albuja did not cause Rhines’ stroke and attributing just 60% of her injury to the trooper’s conduct.

Long asked the judges to toss the verdict, order a new trial, or reduce damages.

If they decide a new trial is warranted, he said, they should require more thorough jury instructions about immunity as well as the differences between pain and suffering and emotional distress. Jurors had awarded Rhines $3 million for pain and suffering, and another $3.6 million for emotional distress. If they uphold the verdict, they should either reduce those damages or order a new trial just on damages, Long said.

“They need to be advised to not duplicate for the same harm twice,” Long said. “That’s a very uncontroversial statement in the law. And then here, it’s just so obvious that pain and suffering and emotional distress have a tendency in the human mind to sound similar and overlap.”

Monday’s arguments at the Richard J. Hughes Justice Complex in Trenton were the second time the state tried to overturn the verdict. The trial judge rejected the state’s bid for a new trial or reduction in damages in April 2025. It’s unclear how soon the appellate panel will issue a ruling.

The case has the potential to reshape whether police officers who err on the job get held accountable in New Jersey.

Cops here and around the country accused of brutality or blunders have long relied on immunity, a controversial legal doctrine social justice advocates have tried to restrict or abolish, to dodge civil or criminal liability.

Immunity is meant to empower officers to act decisively without worrying a mistake will incite a lawsuit — as long as they act in good faith and follow the law.

“We’re trying to take into account the confusing and often complicated situations that police officers and often public employees generally find themselves in, but police officers specifically, where signs can point multiple different ways and a determination has to be made on what the officer sees, saw, and believed,” Long said.

Immunity also protects taxpayers from unpredictable, crushing verdicts, Albuja’s attorneys had further argued in court briefs.

But critics contend it has allowed inept and violent cops to trample people’s civil rights with impunity, depriving victims of accountability.

GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.

SUBSCRIBE
📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: New Jersey Monitor.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Assembly panel approves changes to NJ rulemaking process
New Jersey Monitor
Changes hailed by business groups would increase public comment periods. Detractors warned the changes would …
Lax oversight of reporting masks misuse of opioid settlement funds in NJ, critics say
New Jersey Monitor
Opioid settlement funds are meant to directly help those harmed by addiction. Without state action, towns wil…
she had remained in the position unlawfully
New Jersey Monitor
President Donald Trump suffered another loss Monday in his ongoing fight to make his former personal lawyer t…
growing scrutiny after three people died
New Jersey Monitor
Democratic lawmakers met in a Morristown church Tuesday to repeat calls to shut down Newark immigration jail …
introduced her first budget
New Jersey Monitor
Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s first budget has drawn cautious optimism from New Jersey’s business community despite a…
NJ distributes $20M for legal aid for immigrants facing deportation, detention
New Jersey Monitor
State officials distributed more than $20 million to support legal help for immigrants facing deportation, mo…