Commentary: NC GOP leaders kneecap state and local government on their way out the door

North Carolina voters passed three constitutional amendments on Nov. 3, 2026 to authorize lawmakers to impose limits on local governments’ power to raise property taxes, cap the state income tax, and require photo ID for all voters — not just those voting in person. (Photo: Clayton Henkel/NC Newsline)
While the magnitude of recent Democratic gains in North Carolina state legislative races ended up being much larger than what even many optimistic partisans had predicted and hoped for, the general trend was not, in the end, surprising.
Ever since primary voters sent veteran Senate Leader Phil Berger packing last March, it’s felt increasingly as if state Republicans have been running on fumes and that change was in the air. Between the strange and inexplicable divisions that prevented large legislative majorities from producing timely state budgets, the whiffs of scandal that have plagued several prominent party members, and the massive and debilitating weight of the chaotic Trump presidency, it was clear that the GOP would be losing seats this fall.
Unfortunately for our state and its future, however, it’s clear that Republican leaders read their impending comeuppance in the tea leaves well. And that fact helps explain one of the most regrettable results of the election: the approval of two destructive amendments to the state constitution on the subject of tax policy.
For more than 15 years, Republican legislative leaders have taken repeated steps to transform what had been a moderately progressive state with decent-to-above-average public services and structures and a much-admired public school system into a threadbare laboratory for what one of their most visible and reactionary national activists once described as “drowning [government] in the bathtub.”
And make no mistake; they made significant headway in this ghoulish endeavor. Thanks to repeated and regressive tax cuts that disproportionately benefitted the super-rich, total state and local government funding as a share of the state’s economy has, quite remarkably, plummeted by more than a third during the GOP reign.
Think about that for a moment. Is it any wonder that our once widely envied public schools, higher education systems, and other middle class support structures are now relegated to the backwaters of national rankings? Or that pressure to rely on regressive fees, sales and excise taxes continue to grow? In comparison, Elon Musk’s destructive DOGE assault from last year looks like child’s play.
Amazingly, however, such widespread carnage and expanded inequality were insufficient to satisfy the ideological bloodlust that infected much of the right-wing establishment. And so it is that this past summer, with the demise of their longtime majorities coming into focus, Republican legislative leaders rammed through the latest in a long run of simplistic tax proposals – in this case, a pair of constitutional amendments — that are designed to lock in actions of the last decade-and-a-half and greatly debilitate future state leaders when it comes to undoing the damage.
The first of the amendments caps the state’s fairest and most progressive tax – the state income tax — at a rate less half of where it stood for wealthy North Carolinians and corporations when the Republicans took control of the legislature in 2011. And while those higher rates have already been flattened and lowered below the new cap via legislation over a period of several years, a constitutional limit establishes a huge roadblock to raising new revenue in a way that would require the rich and big corporations to pay something closer to their fair share.
The second amendment seeks to inflict similar impacts on local government – the place to which so many responsibilities have fallen as state government structures have crumbled – by empowering the General Assembly to meddle with and limit local property tax rates.
And while numerous fiscal policy experts repeatedly explained and warned of the long-term folly of both proposals – especially in an era in which natural disasters like Hurricane Helene continue to multiply and federal aid of all kinds has been slashed – the notion that voters would reject either amendment absent any kind of well-funded opposition or real explanation on the ballot of the state’s actual fiscal plight was never a serious possibility.
Indeed, given this backdrop, the fact that both passed by only 3-2 margins is a rather surprising outcome.
So, what happens now? Can and will Democratic leaders find a path to a place where they can commence rebuilding North Carolina’s battered state government?
The guess here is that for now, even if they somehow were to obtain control of the state Senate by eking out a win on the closely contested race in Robeson County, Democrats will, like their colleagues in Washington, have to focus in the near term on staunching the bleeding.
This will mean, for the foreseeable future, working to shift some current funding priorities by, for instance, winding down the state’s costly, discriminatory, unaccountable and destructive school voucher program, and working to build the kind of public awareness that, in the long run, might allow future legislatures to revive and restore a progressive state income tax.
In other words, Republicans have succeeded in kneecapping state and local government on their way out of power. And, for now, the best Democrats can do is try and fashion a fiscal splint that will give both institutions the chance to gradually heal.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
