Dismissed Bennington County murder case heads back to court


The prosecution and defense are taking different views of a recent Vermont Supreme Court decision in a Bennington County murder case.
The state’s highest court, in a decision issued Friday, called on Judge Kerry McDonald-Cady to consider specific factors laid out in case law before deciding whether to dismiss a murder charge against Deven Moffitt, 36, formerly of Bennington, with prejudice, meaning it could not be refiled by the prosecution.
The judge had sided with Moffitt’s attorney more than a year ago in dismissing the charge with prejudice, prompting the appeal.
Moffitt was charged in 2022 with second-degree murder in the 2019 death of his former girlfriend, Jessica Hildenbrandt, 43, of Ballston Spa, New York. Her remains, according to police, were found near an abandoned gravel pit in Searsburg.
“We conclude that the court had authority to impose a sanction up to and including dismissal with prejudice, but that it should have considered the Sauve factors before permanently ending the prosecution,” Justice Nancy Waples wrote in the Vermont Supreme Court’s unanimous ruling.
Those factors, from the 1995 case State v. Sauve, include the seriousness of the charged offense, the evidence of guilt and the existence of any misconduct in the investigation and prosecution.
“We appreciate the opportunity to continue the pursuit of justice for Jessica and her family,” Bennington County State’s Attorney Erica Marthage said in a statement Friday.
Vermont Defender General Matthew Valerio, whose office represented Moffitt in the appeal, said in an interview Monday that he didn’t expect the outcome of the case to change.
“It seems like a good one for the defense,” Valerio said of the high court’s ruling. “The court could write a more detailed opinion that includes the Sauve factors and come to the exact same result. So, it wasn’t the result that was wrong.”
The Vermont Supreme Court decision is the latest legal twist in the case that had been working its way through the court system for several years and included prosecutorial missteps along the way.
In the case, there was an initial DNA match using a database linking the remains found in Searsburg to Hildenbrandt, according to court records.
However, when additional testing to confirm the identity of the remains was not completed by the start of a scheduled trial in early 2025, the prosecution asked for delay to allow for expedited testing.
McDonald-Cady, the judge, ruled that the delay was not reasonable as the state already had enough time leading up to the trial to do that testing, with the original case filed against Moffitt in 2022.
The prosecution then moved to dismiss the case without prejudice, allowing it to be refiled at a later time. Moffitt’s lawyer in turn filed a motion to dismiss the case with prejudice, meaning it could not be filed again.
The judge agreed to dismiss the case with prejudice, concluding that the prosecution was improperly attempting to grant itself the continuance that the court had denied.
The prosecution appealed that ruling to the Vermont Supreme Court leading to Friday’s decision.
Moffitt is currently in federal custody. He had been sentenced in June 2025 to 12½ years in prison following his convictions on federal drug and firearms charges.
Read the story on VTDigger here: Dismissed Bennington County murder case heads back to court.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
