Environmental groups petition EPA to lower nitrate standard from 10mg/L to 1 mg/L

Environmental groups are petitioning EPA to lower its safe drinking water standard for nitrate. (Photo by Cami Koons/Iowa Capital Dispatch)
A group of environmental groups has submitted a petition to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency urging it to revise and significantly lower the current safe drinking water standard for nitrate.
EPA established a maximum contaminant level of 10 milligrams per liter for nitrate contamination in drinking water in 1975, then officially implemented the level in 1991. Petitioners argue that in the more than 30 years since the limit was set, dozens of epidemiological studies have demonstrated a link between lower levels of nitrate exposure and certain types of cancer, thyroid disease and adverse birth outcomes, yet the EPA has not changed the standard.
Petitioners, which include Food & Water Watch, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Union of Concerned Scientists, Environmental Working Group, Natural Resources Defense Council and other groups, are asking the EPA to revise the limit to 1 mg/L.
In the petition, which is more than 50 pages in length, environmental groups are presenting findings from more than 30 peer-reviewed human health studies, along with a benefit-cost analysis they commissioned to show that “there are serious risks to human health from nitrate levels well below the current standard” and that the public health benefits of lowering the standard to 1 mg/L “substantially exceed” the costs.
“Nitrates in drinking water are causing a public health crisis across the country,” the petition says. “The current crisis is not a surprise. Elected officials and regulators at the federal, state, and local levels have systematically ignored or failed to respond to the causes of this pollution for decades, leading to widespread drinking water contamination.”
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.
The petition directs the EPA to address nitrate pollution “at the source” with stricter regulations to stop the “overapplication” of manure and commercial fertilizers and the “irresponsible management” of waste from confined animal feeding operations, or CAFOs. It also notes areas where the EPA could direct existing funding to support drinking water treatment facilities and protection projects.
Tyler Lobdell, a senior staff attorney with Food & Water Watch, spoke about the petition at a Monday news conference and said it laid out a “roadmap” for the EPA to “protect public health and begin holding industrial agriculture accountable for this problem.”
“On behalf of our millions of members, and on behalf of communities from coast to coast, we’re here to demand that EPA protect our water at the tap and at the source,” Lobdell said.
A spokesperson for the EPA said in a statement Monday it would review the petition and that the agency is “committed to ensuring all Americans have access to clean drinking water.”
The agency also noted that it is required by the Safe Drinking Water Act to review drinking water regulations every six years. As part of its most recent review in 2024, the statement from the EPA said, the agency had “determined that the nitrate rule was not a candidate for revision at the time.” This determination was based on a “robust evaluation” of available studies and data on nitrate contamination.
“As EPA begins its evaluation for the next Six-Year Review, the agency will deploy gold-standard science and consider newly available recent studies to inform its decision making,” the EPA statement said.
In a separate but related matter, Food & Water Watch is suing the EPA for failing to comply with their Freedom of Information Act request for reports and communications surrounding a “scuttled” assessment from the agency on the human-health impact of the oral consumption of nitrate and nitrite.
What is nitrate contamination?
The petition says nitrate is a “prevalent contaminant” in both ground and surface water sources and that contamination is “most likely where vulnerable surface or groundwaters meet intensive agricultural practices on the landscape.”
An analysis from petitioners of data from the National Water Quality Monitoring Council found that from January 2015 through August 2026, the states with the highest mean levels of nitrate in surface waters, listed in descending order, were: Iowa, Minnesota, Delaware, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, California, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Utah.
Iowa had 274 monitoring sites with an average nitrate level of 4.22 mg/L per site, while Minnesota, the next highest on the list, had 806 monitoring sites and an average nitrate level of 3.60 mg/L.
Anne Schechinger, senior director of agriculture and climate research at the Environmental Working Group, said Monday that while nitrate “mainly” gets into water from commercial fertilizer and manure application in agricultural settings, even large cities like Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Phoenix and Las Vegas have elevated levels of nitrate in their drinking water.
According to Schechinger and data in the petition, there are around 120 million people in the U.S. with drinking water sources at or above the 1 mg/L standard proposed by the petitioners.
Permitting overhaul advances in US Senate with tepid bipartisan support
“Science has advanced since the EPA set the 10 mg/L (limit) more than three decades ago, so we now know that even low levels of nitrate exposure in drinking water can increase the risk of health harms in people,” Schechinger said in the news conference Monday.
That figure doesn’t include people sourcing their water from private wells, which are not subject to EPA standards or regular testing.
The petitioners’ analysis of groundwater nitrate levels from federal water quality data found Colorado, Montana, Washington, Arizona, Delaware, Nevada, Wisconsin, New Mexico, Iowa and California had the highest mean values of nitrate in groundwater. Colorado, at the top of the list, had a mean groundwater nitrate concentration of 7.89 mg/L according to the petition.
Utilities already struggle to meet current standard
Utilities with source waters that are high in nitrate concentrations either need nitrate removal systems or to blend water from multiple sources to meet safe drinking water standards.
In Iowa, nitrate contamination is a prominent issue and even became a key policy point among candidates in the recent election. Despite a massive nitrate removal system in Des Moines, the city’s regional water authority, Central Iowa Water Works, has had to issue lawn watering bans the past two summers to lower demand on the system and keep nitrate levels below the EPA’s limit of 10 mg/L.
The city’s treatment facility sources water from the Des Moines and Raccoon rivers, but nitrate concentrations well above 10 mg/L in the rivers made it difficult for the system to meet high water demand in the summer and safe drinking water standards.
Nitrate levels haven’t exceeded the EPA limits in Des Moines, but the “finished” water leaving the treatment facilities regularly has nitrate levels above 5 mg/L, according to data from Des Moines Water Works.
Tami Madsen, the executive director of Central Iowa Water Works, said the regional water authority was reviewing the petition from environmental groups and needed “time to evaluate” the motion before it could comment.
“Our focus remains on providing safe drinking water to the one in five Iowans we serve and protecting the sources our communities rely on,” Madsen said in an email.
At the EPA’s current limit of 10 mg/L, nitrate contamination violations are the most common health-based standard violated by public water supply systems in Iowa and many smaller communities can’t afford to implement a nitrate removal system.
Petitioners said that addressing the issue “at the source,” by adding regulations and limitations on fertilizer application and livestock systems, would “lower the compliance cost” for public water systems.
Nancy Stoner, a senior attorney with the Environmental Law & Policy Center, said that public health benefits would be 3.9 times as great as projected costs, over the next 50 years, of lowering the nitrate standard to 1 mg/L.
Swimmers weren’t warned about nearly 30 high E. coli tests at beaches this summer
According to the benefit-cost analysis included in the petition, the annualized cost of meeting the recommended threshold breaks down to about $53 per household per year for people in large water systems.
“Everyone should be able to drink the tap water anywhere in the U.S. safely, and that’s what the Safe Drinking Water Act requires,” Stoner said.
The petition said the benefit-cost ratio is an underestimation because the analysis only looked at the effect lowering the standard would have on three health outcomes: colorectal cancer, ovarian cancer and very low birth weight.
EPA’s 10 mg/L standard was based largely on studies of nitrate contamination and blue baby syndrome or methemoglobinemia, a potentially fatal condition where an infant is unable to properly carry oxygen in their blood.
Stacy Woods, the research director for the Union of Concerned Scientists, said the research in the petition provides “substantial evidence that the current standard does not adequately protect against serious health effects” including ovarian cancer, colorectal cancer, thyroid disease, low birth weight and birth defects.
“We joined this petition because we know that the current standard for drinking water is insufficient to protect public health,” Woods said. “… The EPA must update the nitrate drinking water standard to reflect today’s science and protect public health.”
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
