Commentary: Candidate is right that no party is above scrutiny — including his own

South Dakota Democratic nominee for governor Dan Ahlers talks to attendees at the Democratic Party election night gathering in downtown Sioux Falls on Nov. 3, 2026. (Photo by Makenzie Huber/South Dakota Searchlight)
The Sunday night before Election Day, I read a point/counterpoint column from Dan Ahlers, the Democratic candidate for governor, in The Dakota Scout. With an impending blue wave expected to wash over the nation, it was with a certain degree of anticipation that I read Ahlers’ missive. In this new age for Democrats, perhaps Ahlers had something unique to say, a fresh vision for the state and the challenges it faces.
Sadly, no. Ahlers started off with a Democratic oldie but goodie — bemoaning the dangers of one-party rule. “When one party holds power for generation after generation, there is a danger that accountability becomes less of a priority,” Ahlers said, adding later, “No political party should be above scrutiny.”
In this last-ditch attempt to sway voters, Ahlers uses “one-party rule” like it’s a curse word or the name of a crime or the result of a conspiracy. It’s not. One-party rule in South Dakota is the fault of one party — the Democratic Party. You certainly can’t blame Republicans for being the only candidates to show up on the ballot.
Democrats gain seats in South Dakota Legislature for the first time since 2008
For decades, the Democratic Party in South Dakota has been, at best, an afterthought. At worst, it’s a punchline. That played out in the recent election as Democrats lost, again, every statewide office. Democrats hamstrung themselves in statewide races, failing to field candidates for U.S. Senate and state attorney general.
In the Legislature, Democrats will have two members in the 35-member state Senate and 10 in the 70-member state House. There has been some crowing on the part of Democrats, since their showing included the addition of four new representatives in the Sioux Falls area, the best they’ve done in an election since they sent 16 members to Pierre in 2018.
In their post-election afterglow, Democrats are busy strategizing how they can replicate their Sioux Falls gains in the rural areas of the state. That will be a big task. The Democratic Party allowed Republicans to have majorities in both chambers before a single vote was cast. When all the pre-election paperwork had been filed, Republicans were guaranteed 52 seats in the Legislature — 21 in the Senate and 31 in the House.
That’s how this state earned a tradition of one-party rule. It’s tough to have a two-party system when one of the parties doesn’t show up. Ahlers had been the executive director of the Democratic Party in South Dakota. It was his job to oversee the recruitment of candidates for the Legislature. Unfortunately, he fell short by 52 candidates before he decided to recruit himself to run for governor.
Don’t mistake this as an endorsement of the state’s Democrats or their ideas. It is an endorsement of the idea that South Dakota voters and taxpayers deserve a real debate on the issues. Lately the only election debates have been in the Republican Party primaries between candidates who largely agree with each other. Once the general election rolls around, some Republican legislative candidates don’t have anyone to debate, anyone to challenge their ideas, anyone to offer voters a choice in November.
A blue wave drenched the rest of the nation on Election Day. In South Dakota, the outcome resembled something that drips from a leaky faucet. Ahlers was right when he said that no party should be above scrutiny. Take a close look at the Democratic Party in this state and you’ll find it’s the reason why South Dakota has a long tradition of one-party rule.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
