Opinion: New Colorado governor “would be crazy” to opt out of federal scholarship tax credit
Governor-Elect Phil Weiser isn’t a fan of the new federal scholarship tax credit.
Starting in 2027, the program offers a dollar-for-dollar credit to individuals who donate up to $1,700 — or $3,400 for married couples filing jointly — to scholarship organizations. Those organizations then provide scholarships for everything from private-school tuition to public-school tutoring.
Colorado was among the first states to opt in. In December, Gov. Jared Polis became the first Democrat to do so. Since then, only one other Democratic governor, New York’s Kathy Hochul, has joined via executive action. So far, 32 states have opted in.
It’s easy to see why. If just 1% of Colorado tax filers donate, kids could receive more than $17 million in scholarships, according to Education Reform Now. As Polis puts it, governors “would be crazy not to” opt in.
Well, Weiser must be “Cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs” because that’s what he intends to do. The governor-elect is a “firm no” on the program and even labeled anyone in favor “naive or misleading.”
Call us — me, Polis, Hochul, the 29 other states that have opted in, or the three-fourths of Americans who support the program — whatever you want. Sticks and stones may break our bones, but they can’t hurt a program that will help millions of kids.
Weiser is mostly interested in scoring political points. The tax credit comes from the “One Big, Beautiful Bill,” and the governor-elect has built his identity on suing the pants off the Trump administration. Opposing the president’s signature bill earns cheap applause from partisan goofballs in the political nosebleed seats.
Then, there are the teacher unions. Weiser’s hyperbole about “privatization of public schools” curries favor with executives like Randi Weingarten and Becky Pringle, who have encouraged states to opt out of what they call the “voucher scam.”
Despite his opposition to “school vouchers,” Wesier is, deep down, a fan.
His education plank, which promotes universal preschool, gives him away. Colorado sends money to private — often religious — preschool providers. Last year, nearly 80 faith-based providers received about $9.5 million to serve more than 2,000 families.
Colorado’s universal preschool is, by definition, a voucher program. Change my mind.
Weiser can rest easy, though. He won’t have to reconcile his cognitive dissonance over vouchers because the federal program doesn’t offer them. Vouchers require public funding. Tax-credit scholarships, on the other hand, run on private money, so nary a public coffer gets raided.
Sure, you can cry about the “lost” tax revenue. Tax credits reduce taxpayers’ liability, so the federal government can’t rob more of their income (the horror, the horror).
But those tears are as ridiculous as that logic.
Tax credits aren’t some newfangled phenomenon. Americans claim dozens of them every year, “costing” hundreds of billions in “lost” revenue (again, the horror!).
Also, the federal government is the deadbeat dad of education funding. It pays child support late and still falls short, chipping in only a dime for every dollar spent on public schools. And despite their paltry contributions, the feds have more than tripled their K–12 contribution over the past two decades.
Long story short: Tax-credit scholarships don’t take a cent from public education.
Quite the opposite, actually. States pay nothing to join. Plus, nearly 900,000 Colorado kids, most of them in public schools, are eligible. By comparison, about 71,000 attend private schools, so do the math whenever someone claims this is for only “rich, spoiled private-school kids.”
These scholarships cover far more than tuition: tutoring, books, supplies, special-education assistance, after-school programs, and school sports. Public-school allies — the Colorado Public Schools Foundation, the Denver Public Schools Foundation, and RESCHOOL, to name a few — are already mobilizing to raise money for tutoring, AP test fees, and fifth-day programming for the hundreds of districts on four-day weeks.
Shannon Hancock, chair of the Colorado Public Schools Foundation, said it best: “You can stand on principle and say, ‘We’re not going to do this because this is a voucher scheme,’ but then who benefits?”
I’ll tell you who doesn’t benefit, Shannon: Colorado kids. Opting out won’t kill the program. Coloradans can still claim the credit, but they can’t donate to Colorado organizations. Their money would leave the state and fund scholarships for non-Colorado kids. Don’t politicians like keeping money in their states?
Fortunately, Weiser can’t exit the program on day one. Once a state opts in, federal law prohibits it from reversing course until the following year. When governors resubmit their approved lists of scholarship organizations, he could pocket-veto by not filing the paperwork.
But Weiser should keep an open mind. By this time next year, he’ll need to re-up Colorado’s participation, and if he opts out, he’ll have some splaining to do to the kids and families — those “naive and misleading” ne’er-do-wells — relying on these scholarships.
Jay Stooksberry, of Delta, is a writer and editor and the author of “Oxford Mania: Why the Oxford Comma Is Cultishly Adored and Wildly Overrated.”
The Colorado Sun is a nonpartisan news organization, and the opinions of columnists and editorial writers do not reflect the opinions of the newsroom. Read our ethics policy for more on The Sun’s opinion policy. Learn how to submit a column. Reach the opinion editor at [email protected].
Follow Colorado Sun Opinion on Facebook.
Type of Story: Opinion
Advocates for ideas and draws conclusions based on the author/producer’s interpretation of facts and data.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
