For Thomas Jefferson descendants Sal Pace and Shannon LaNier, it’s time to build bridges
It can be a tricky business, untangling family ties.
Sal Pace, a 49-year-old white man, has made his mark as a Colorado politician, policymaker and, currently, transportation official poised to launch a new stage of passenger rail service along the Front Range. Shannon LaNier, a 47-year-old Black man, has built a successful career as an actor, TV personality, influencer and motivational speaker working out of New York City.
What they share in common adds a complex twist to the nation’s bedrock narrative. It shines an unforgiving light on racial injustice and has triggered conflict similar in some ways to the family discord too common in a country so politically divided.
In other words, it holds a mirror to America.
The reflection staring back: Thomas Jefferson. Founding Father. Primary author of the Declaration of Independence. Third president of the United States. Eloquent advocate for liberty. Slave owner.
With Sally Hemings — a woman he legally owned during a decadeslong relationship — Jefferson fathered another branch of the family tree that, nearly two and a half centuries later, still has only begun to fully claim its place in history. Pace and LaNier are trying to move the discussion toward reconciliation.
Pace (fifth-great grandson of Jefferson and his wife, Martha Wayles Jefferson) and LaNier (sixth-great grandson of Jefferson and Hemings) will appear together for two conversations, at 1 and 7 p.m. Wednesday, as part of History Colorado’s Rosenberry Lecture Series at the Colorado History Museum in downtown Denver.
The event will be moderated by Derek Everett, a member of the history departments at both Colorado State University and Metropolitan State University of Denver. (Individual tickets are $15 for nonmembers and $10 for members.)
For both Pace and LaNier, the discussion continues a dialogue between the family branches at a time when it seems more important than ever.
“As a country, we’re facing lots of division and conflict,” Pace says. “I think there’s another path forward, which is acknowledging our history. That can mean at times celebrating it. It can mean at times acknowledging the bad parts of our history, too. We’re all in it together, and if we can’t work together, we’re not going to find a common future.”
Jefferson and Hemings had six children, with four living to adulthood. Rumors that Jefferson had fathered children with her date back to 1802, though they were largely dismissed by historians and white descendants over the years, often by attributing Hemings’ children to Jefferson’s nephews. But DNA evidence emerged in 1998 that supported the claims.
Those were bolstered this year by a Smithsonian DNA study detailed in Richard Kurin’s book “History By a Hair” — based on an inquiry launched by strands of hair found in Jefferson’s Bible.
“We’re going to be talking about our families, the duality of having these two families, what it means to go through the process of forgiveness, of reconciliation, of healing,” LaNier says. “Every family has issues. Every family has spats and disputes. So, what do you do after that happens? We can use our stories as an example to help guide them.”

From division, a move toward reconciliation
By LaNier’s recollection, his initial meeting with Pace nearly 25 years ago did not end on the best of terms. There were questions around including the Hemings descendants in the Monticello Association, an organization with strict membership eligibility that exists to preserve and protect Jefferson’s legacy. It also maintains the private graveyard at Monticello, the 5,000-acre estate and plantation that has been a focal point of the conflict between the two sides of the family.
After the 1998 DNA study brought the Hemings descendants further into the conversation, Pace voted with the 67-5 majority in 2002 to deny them membership in the association. It was a decision that made him increasingly uncomfortable over the years — and one he would eventually regret.
“Part of it is ego or arrogance,” Pace says of his vote, “and an attitude of trying to protect an ancestor’s legacy and not acknowledging facts or truth.”
The public dispute grew heated.

It was just a family, a family in turmoil, a family in conversations, a family in discussions of how to move forward. And it did not go well that first meeting.
— Shannon LaNier, descendant of Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings
“There was a lot of conflict between the sides of the family, and the press didn’t help that,” LaNier recalls. “They helped make it into sort of a Black-white ‘Jerry Springer Show’ when it was not. It was just a family, a family in turmoil, a family in conversations, a family in discussions of how to move forward. And it did not go well that first meeting.”
After the vote, Pace rarely mentioned his relationship to Jefferson and quit attending the annual Monticello Association meetings — until last year, when he returned hoping for an opportunity to correct his misstep. The issue “had been sitting heavy on me for a couple decades,” he notes. But it was during the Black Lives Matter protests in 2020 that he decided that he needed to face his earlier mistakes and work toward inclusion.
At last year’s meeting of the Monticello Association, he recounts, one of the younger members broached the idea of inviting the Hemings descendants to this year’s meeting, as the nation celebrated the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.
At his table, Pace recalls, some of the old guard Southerners still howled in protest. Calling on his political instincts to avoid what promised to be a nasty fight, he stood and suggested that the topic was too big to tackle in the time available, and that a committee could better hash out the issue. In the months that followed, he headed a reconciliation committee that reached out to the Hemings side of the family.
Remembering that he’d met LaNier years earlier, when despite the tension he had seemed so positive, Pace contacted him. They began meeting virtually and then twice in person — on July 4 in New York with their families and a few weeks later at a gathering of descendants from both Jefferson lines in Washington, D.C.
“It’s been nice to get to know each other,” LaNier says, “and it’s been a journey. Still, we have far to go, but we are starting to meet. We’re starting to hang out more. Starting to get to know each other as family more.”
Pace got in touch with History Colorado about putting together an event, and the timing worked nicely with the organization’s lecture series recognizing the 150th/250th anniversaries of Colorado statehood and the nation. Asked to recommend a Hemings descendant to participate, Pace didn’t hesitate to suggest LaNier.
While the appearance at History Colorado is a standalone event, LaNier says he hopes it grows into something that can bring unity and healing to a national audience.
“We’ve had so much divisiveness and hate spewed across the country recently, in the last two years, that I think people are hungry for that type of conversation,” he says. “And I think that we could be used as a catalyst to help.”

Dealing with a blue blood backstory
Pace, who grew up in Connecticut, describes himself as “the result of two parents from different sides of the tracks.” His father came from immigrant stock, factory workers and migrants. His mother, Mary Coolidge — distant cousin to the 30th U.S. president — came from prominent East Coast lineage. “Her genealogy is just sort of unbelievable,” he says, noting that it also includes a link to the 17th-century Native American historical figure Pocahontas.
But once, amid grade school classroom discussion, he nonchalantly mentioned his ancestry — that he was directly descended from Pocahontas through her marriage to a tobacco farmer named John Rolfe. When one of his classmates started to laugh, Pace began to realize why his mom seldom mentioned her lineage in public.

It occurred to me that either people didn’t believe me, or they thought I was arrogant, or whatever. So, at a young age, I quit talking about any of my mom’s lineage or genealogy or heritage.
— Sal Pace, descendant of Thomas Jefferson and Martha Wayles Jefferson
“It occurred to me that either people didn’t believe me, or they thought I was arrogant, or whatever,” he says. “So, at a young age, I quit talking about any of my mom’s lineage or genealogy or heritage.”
He headed West after high school, enrolling at Fort Lewis College in Durango. He earned his undergraduate degree in political science, a logical enough prelude to a career in politics and public service. But Pace pauses when he considers why he chose a school so far from home — where he never spoke of his ancestry.
“I’m still trying to unpack it myself,” he says, “but I was in part trying to run away from my blue blood lineage.”
He went to Louisiana State University to pursue his master’s degree. In the process, he studied the third U.S. president because “I’ve always felt a special connection to Thomas Jefferson. For sure.”
Pace returned to Colorado and launched himself into a career in Democratic politics that began with work as a congressional staffer for U.S. Rep. John Salazar, segued to roles as a state representative for a house district extending southwest from Pueblo and, after that, Pueblo County commissioner. Now, he serves as general manager of the Front Range Passenger Rail District. While Pace believes the heritage of civic mindedness on his mother’s side helped drive him professionally, he says he avoided mixing his family history and his politics.
“When my mom would come visit me in Colorado all through my political career, I never introduced her as Mary Coolidge,” Pace says, “because I just wanted to avoid the perception of elitism.”
His mother died earlier this year, prompting him to think more deeply about acknowledging his ancestry.
“It’s important to know where you come from,” he says, “because it helps shape who you are. And that’s one of the most insidious things about the white Jefferson descendants denying the rightful heritage of the Black Thomas Jefferson descendants.”

A family “as complicated as this country”
LaNier also has known for as long as he can remember that he’s related to Jefferson. And early on, it was simply cool to have presidential lineage — until that time in second grade when, like Pace, he shared his heritage with his entire class. He recalls the teacher admonishing him to stop telling lies, while his classmates laughed.
For years afterward, he was reluctant to share the information.
As a teenager, his understanding of Jefferson shifted as he learned more about the history of slavery and its impact on the African-American community. Suddenly, Jefferson loomed as something more, and less, than the primary author of the Declaration of Independence. It was one thing to be related to a president. But quite another to be the Black descendant of a slave owner.
“So the perspective changed as I educated myself and understood the complexities of this whole dynamic,” LaNier explains. “It has been a roller coaster ride of sorts for me and my levels of understanding — what I knew about him, and what I know now about him. It’s as complicated as this country.”
That understanding shifted, from pride and excitement to disappointment and anger. He saw Jefferson as the embodiment of contradiction: a man “who wrote those words that ‘all men are created equal,’ but did nothing to live those words.”
Eventually, he recognized the need to make peace with Jefferson’s conflicting truths. But LaNier also realized that while he’s unable to change events of the 18th century, he’s not powerless.
“What I can do is make sure that people know who he really was, and the contradictions that he lived in his life,” he says. “Regardless of what has happened in his past and in history, we can’t change that. But we can move forward. And what we do with those words make a difference. And so we are trying to live out ‘all men are created equal’ in real time today, when it counts.”
In 2020, LaNier agreed to sit for a portrait that appeared in Smithsonian Magazine. Photographer Drew Gardner had been juxtaposing portraits of European historical figures with their descendants, and soon turned his attention to America. He paired Jefferson with LaNier.
LaNier admits that initially he was hesitant to participate “because you never know what someone’s going to do with something.” Asked to don a white wig for the session, he flatly declined, as he thought that would turn the project into a caricature or something lighthearted. Ultimately, he was surprised and thrilled at the outcome.
Years earlier, when he was just 19 years old, LaNier had teamed with photographer Jane Feldman to document oral accounts of the Hemings branch of the family. He calls that project “life changing” for the opportunity it gave him to meet and interact with other descendants. In July, LaNier and Feldman appeared together at an exhibit at the Norman Rockwell Museum in Stockbridge, Massachusetts, for a discussion about reconciling challenging histories.
For Pace, there are still Monticello Association policies that need to be changed, and he feels the need to be a leader in that effort, “a necessary step for correcting the past wrongs.”
Part of that is the still-festering question of who’s allowed to be buried at Monticello. LaNier says that while he would not choose that as his final resting place, the issue still matters. As descendants, the Hemings side of the family should have the right.
“Hopefully, one day we will get to a place where everyone can be buried together,” he says. “As hard as it is for people to live with each other, you would think it’d be easier to be around each other in death, when you don’t even have to talk with each other.”
Type of Story: News
Based on facts, either observed and verified directly by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
