Healthcare in America might change after Democratic midterm victory
- Democrats are expected to restore the Affordable Care Act's enhanced subsidies and reverse nearly $1 trillion in Medicaid cuts.
- Even with control of the House and Senate, the road to change is a difficult one, as legislation is still vulnerable to a presidential veto.
- Some experts argue lowering insurance costs is "hiding the ultimate problem": high costs for care.
When new senators and House members take their seats in January, it will have been four years since the Democratic Party controlled both the House and Senate.
The party is energized about the shift in power — and some experts are suggesting the new majority might focus its priorities on healthcare.
“You’ve had overnight a complete changing of the guard,” said Chip Kahn, a visiting senior fellow with the American Enterprise Institute. “... Democrats place healthcare at the top of the list, whereas on the Republican side ... most Republican members would prefer not to focus on healthcare.
“That’s a complete sea change,” he added.
What’s at the top of the list?
Democrats are expected to restore enhanced subsidies under the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare. Enhanced subsidies were created in 2021 in response to the COVID-19 pandemic — they increased tax credits, removed the income cap to make more families eligible and capped premium payments. Subsidies were extended through December 2025 — then expired.
At that time, it was the central dispute of the 43-day government shutdown. A vote was put on the floor in December 2025, and it failed.
Democrats are also expected to reverse nearly $1 trillion in Medicaid cuts enacted under Republican control in July 2025. Supporters describe the provider tax limits as closing a loophole, but critics say that eligible people could lose coverage.
Kahn said the cost of these two changes could very well be hundreds of billions of dollars — even a trillion dollars — depending on what gets passed.
Kahn laid out a hypothetical, stating that even if subsidies were extended for only one or two years, the money would have to come from someone’s pocket. “And so there will be a big question: Is it going to be paid for or not?” he asked.
“And I guess they’d have to either roll back tax cuts or cut other parts of healthcare if they were going to try to pay for it,” he added. “It’s not simply, ‘Well, let’s roll back the Medicaid cuts,’ and there won’t be any budget effect. There’s a budget effect. But I think that the House could go ahead and do that. And I think they would probably try to do it pretty quickly.”
The road to change in healthcare is a difficult one — even with control in the House and Senate, Kahn argued. Though Democrats hold 55 confirmed Senate votes — and, presumably, 56 seats following Alaska’s race — legislation is still vulnerable to a presidential veto.
But a Senate majority doesn’t hold the same weight as a filibuster-proof majority. With only 55 or 56 seats, Democrats are still four or five seats short.
“The question is, even if they could pass a bill ... would Trump even sign such a bill?” Kahn asked.
The ‘ultimate problem’: The cost of care
Paul Pruitt, co-founder of SHARx — a prescription advocacy company — argued that, come January, if Democrats focus their efforts on renewing subsidies and reversing cuts, they’re missing the big picture.
He said lowering insurance costs is “hiding the ultimate problem”: high costs for care.
“At some point, that’s going to keep coming to a head because throwing more money at the problem is just avoiding the issue,” he argued. “And the longer we avoid the issue, the harder it gets to solve.”
Pruitt said that fixing health insurance is not the same as fixing healthcare — he described insurance as merely the “financing vehicle,” and said subsidies result in an escalating cost of care, which then requires more subsidies.
“That’s a vicious, negative feedback loop,” he said.
He also pointed to the consolidation of pharmacies, health insurance companies, pharmacy benefit managers, hospitals and more — arguing “all consolidation does is eliminate competition and drive pricing up.” The healthcare system thrives in the obscurity of its costs, according to Pruitt.
In an effort to mitigate costs, Congress has created transparency laws, but Pruitt argues their enforcement has been laughable. “The penalties are so low. Why bother complying — if anyone even checks at all?” he said.
On the other hand, an April 2025 study from the National Bureau of Economic Research found that Medicaid expansion saves lives at a lower cost than many other federal interventions.
The federal government estimates saving a single life as worth more than $10 million. The study found that Medicaid expansions cost about $5.4 million per life saved — a figure some economists consider remarkably cost-effective.
“Comparing the cost per life-year saved by Medicaid to hundreds of other life-saving interventions, we find that Medicaid tends to be more cost-effective than injury prevention and toxin regulation measures,” the study read.
Using tax records for 37 million low-income, nondisabled adults, the study found that the adoption of Medicaid expansions lowered the overall annual mortality hazard of low-income adults by 2.5%. Expansion also saved an estimated 27,400 lives between 2010 and 2022.
The potential for a compromise — or not
Beyond extending subsidies and reversing Medicaid cuts, some experts, such as Pruitt, are wondering if the recent shift in the Democratic Party toward socialist policies could affect how policies — and what policies — get passed in terms of healthcare.
He argued there isn’t room for a compromise between Republicans and socialist-leaning Democrats.
“To solve the healthcare problem would be counteractive to Medicare for All or socialized medicine ideals,” he said. “So part of the strategy is to break the model.”
Many candidates in the midterm elections ran on “Medicare for All” — including Abdul El-Sayed, D-Mich., Juliana Stratton, D-Ill., and Graham Platner.
“I wouldn’t expect the government to provide any meaningful relief for me as an individual,” Pruitt argued.
Kahn, however, called the argument “noise,” and added: “I don’t take any of that seriously in the near future.”
Though the Democratic Party holds a majority, he isn’t convinced it means anything for socialist-leaning Democrats. “Where did most of those people come from? They weren’t the socialists,” he said. “They were from all those Southern states that elected Democrats. They were from North Carolina. They were from Texas. There was a seat from Alabama.”
According to Kahn, that’s not a debate Americans will see in the next few years.
However, the debate between allowing the market to fix itself and giving the government more control over healthcare is — and Kahn doesn’t predict Congress and Trump are going to sing “Kumbaya” and work perfectly together just yet.
“If you’re juggling who’s in power every two to four years, you’re never going to make much progress either way,” said Pruitt.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
