Maine Morning Star
17/11/2026 16:22

Task force proposes plan to expand Wabanaki Nations’ access to federal laws

The Penobscot Council meets in the administration building on the Indian Island Reservation. (Photo by Emma Davis/ Maine Morning Star)

A state task force recommended on Tuesday that the next Legislature ensure that federal laws that benefit other tribes also benefit the Wabanaki Nations. 

While essentially reiterating an earlier suggestion from a 2019 task force, the proposal addresses concerns about potential legal challenges that have stymied adoption since. 

Earlier this year, lawmakers created the latest task force after a far more ambitious aim to fully restore sovereignty to the Wabanaki Nations was walked back following opposition from Gov. Janet Mills.

The Penobscot Nation, Passamaquoddy Tribe, Houlton Band of Maliseet Indians and Mi’kmaq Nation — collectively known as the Wabanaki Nations — are treated differently than other federally recognized tribes, more akin to municipalities than sovereign nations because of a 1980 land settlement agreement. 

Among several implications, the settlement agreement, known as the Maine Implementing Act, has prevented the Wabanaki Nations from benefitting from federal laws passed after 1980 that interfere with state law, unless they are specifically mentioned in the law. 

During her two terms, Mills blocked sweeping overhauls of the settlement agreement and legislation to provide Wabanaki access to all federal beneficial laws, instead opting to usher through piecemeal reforms. But the Democratic governor terms out this year, and Gov.-elect Hannah Pingree, also a Democrat, has vowed to support the full restoration of tribal sovereignty. 

Ahead of a new administration and Legislature in January, the task force made up of lawmakers and tribal leaders met to specifically address how the state should tackle changing the part of the agreement involving federal laws, gathering public feedback and discussing various approaches throughout the fall. 

Sen. Rachel Talbot Ross (D-Cumberland), one of the chairs of the working group, said the process has left her “very excited about the possibilities for government-to-government relations that are built on mutual respect and, I will say, human dignity.” 

The task force unanimously voted to recommend that the 133rd Legislature ensure all federal beneficial laws apply to each of the Wabanaki Nations, regardless of when they were enacted. Their recommendation is also that state laws that interfere with the implementation of existing or future beneficial federal laws not apply to the Wabanaki Nations and their citizens.

Back in 2019, the Human Rights and Indigenous Peoples Clinic at Suffolk Law School identified 151 federal laws enacted since 1980 that may not be applicable to the Wabanaki Nations. 

Nicole Friederichs, who directs the clinic and teaches federal Indian law, expanded that research with her students for the latest task force. Friederichs said they found 23 more federal laws enacted since 2019 that may not be applicable, bringing the total to 174. 

Additionally, the group recommended that the state establish a conflict resolution mechanism to resolve any potential legal disputes that could arise with the enactment of such laws, which was a key concern raised by Mills when she vetoed legislation to restore the Tribes’ access to federal laws in 2023. 

“I fear it would result in years, if not decades, of new, painful litigation that would exacerbate our government-to-government relationship and only further divide the state,” Mills wrote in her veto message at the time. 

Per the task force’s recommendation, when a federal law could have a disruptive and harmful effect on the state outside of Wabanaki Nation lands, the Tribes and the state would be required to confer on implementation to avoid or minimize such potential effects. For example, the group agreed the state and its departments should be authorized to enter into cooperative agreements with the Wabanaki Nations to deliver government services and to avoid disputes on issues of mutual interest. 

“The intention is for this to be a sovereign-to-sovereign relationship and discussion between the state and the Wabanaki nations,” said Corey Hinton, attorney for the Passamaquoddy Tribe. 

This mechanism would expand upon the existing framework in the Tribal-State Collaboration Act of 2022, which established a consultation process between state agencies and tribes regarding agency programs, rules and services that uniquely affect the tribes. Maine also has the inter-governmental Maine Indian Tribal-State Commission, which was created by the 1980 settlement act.

Task force discussions underscored several concerns with the current framework.  

“It’s the state’s language,” Talbot Ross said of the collaboration act. “If you read it, it does have, my word, a fairly inequitable agreement. Moving forward, it’s not as comprehensive, as strong as some of the other states that have dedicated offices.”

As part of the task force’s work, members reviewed the collaboration entities used in other states. They range from none, to commissions that act as liaisons, to specific departments and offices. Talbot Ross proposed a separate office in 2024. While the plan initially passed the legislature, it was placed on the appropriations table and lawmakers opted not to fund it. 

“Perhaps in the 133rd, a whole new collaboration vehicle will be developed,” said Rep. Amy Kuhn (D-Falmouth), the task force’s other chair. 

In addition to the suggestions for legislative action, the task force also recommended that should the state pass a law giving the Wabanaki Nations access to federal beneficial laws, a joint communication would be sent to U.S. Congress informing the federal body of the change.

YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.

SUPPORT
📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Maine Morning Star.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Recount confirms Republican Clement flipped Lewiston House seat
Maine Morning Star
Republican Kerryl Lee Clement was officially declared the winner of House District 96, defeating Democrat Luk…
Maine Transportation Commissioner Doughty to retire at the end of the month
Maine Morning Star
Commissioner of the Maine Department of Transportation Dale Doughty is retiring Nov. 28 after three decades i…
$56 million from that landmark settlement
Maine Morning Star
Maine Attorney General Aaron Frey announced on Wednesday that he, along with the attorneys general of 50 othe…
Revived efforts for Maine voters to elect constitutional officers founder
Maine Morning Star
Renewed efforts by some lawmakers for the state to adopt a system where voters elect the state’s constitution…
counter Trump’s mass deportation agenda
Maine Morning Star
Maine enacted several new laws during the latest legislative session that aim to counter President Donald Tru…
is finalizing recommendations
Maine Morning Star
As the Maine Data Center Advisory Council begins drafting recommendations for the upcoming Legislature to reg…