Records: Bexar County DA dismisses 45-year-old cold case murder due to insufficient evidence
A near half-century old cold case murder in Universal City that was believed to have been solved was turned down by the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office on Monday.
According to court records, the district attorney’s office dismissed the case involving capital murder defendant Kelly Lee Brower, 68, due to insufficient evidence. He was arrested in Arizona on Aug. 19 on a $1 million bond and Texas Rangers believed he was connected to the death of Yolanda Herrera.
On Monday, Brower was released from the Bexar County Adult Detention Center after being extradited from Arizona in August.
KSAT reached out to the DA’s office for comment about the dismissal and are waiting to hear back.
Background
According to Brower’s arrest affidavit, DNA from a discarded beer can and a hospital bedside confession helped Texas Rangers investigate the 45-year-old cold case murder.
Investigators submitted decades-old DNA evidence to Othram Laboratories, which used sequencing to determine that the suspect was likely the son of Brower’s mother and father. DPS did not find any other children of his parents living in Texas.
In October 2025, Cottonwood police collected a discarded Coors Light beer can from outside Brower’s residence on a trash run.
Testing showed the DNA on the can matched DNA recovered from Herrera’s right-hand fingernail clippings collected during her 1981 autopsy. Analysts determined the probability of a random, unrelated individual sharing that DNA profile was at least 1 in 31 billion in the U.S. population.
On Aug. 13, 2026, Texas Rangers interviewed Brower at the Cottonwood Police Department. Brower denied knowing Herrera and refused to voluntarily provide a DNA sample. Investigators then executed a search warrant for his DNA.
As Brower left the police department, the affidavit states he paused and asked investigators, “How long?” — an apparent reference to how long the DNA results would take to return.
Five days later, on Aug. 18, rangers conducted a second interview with Brower at a hospital in Cottonwood, where he was being treated. According to the affidavit, Brower stated that his “higher self” said “I did do it” when asked about Herrera’s murder.
He also said his “higher self” told him “that I killed her” and acknowledged having sex with Herrera. When shown a photograph of Herrera and asked directly whether he killed and had sex with her, Brower replied, “yeah.” When asked whether he used his hands, he replied, “yes.” Brower also told investigators, “I’m sorry for what I did.”
Investigators noted that public records placed Brower at an address on Winn Avenue in Universal City — less than one mile from where Herrera’s body was found. His son was born in Bexar County in June 1980, placing Brower in the area around the time of the killing.
The affidavit states that the bar where Herrera was last seen, Brower’s associated Universal City address, and the location where her body was found were all within a 0.75-mile radius of one another.
Herrera, 23, was last seen in the early morning hours of Saturday, April 11, 1981, leaving Johnny’s Inn, a bar in Schertz. She was last seen walking away from the establishment.
Two days later, on Monday, April 13, 1981, her nude body was discovered in a field near the 500 block of East Aviation Boulevard in Universal City.
An autopsy determined her cause of death was homicide due to multiple blunt force trauma injuries to her head and body.
More of this story on KSAT:
- DNA from discarded beer can cracked 1981 Universal City cold case, affidavit states
- ‘Now we can rest’: Family remembers Yolanda Herrera nearly 45 years after her murder
- UCPD: Man confessed to 1981 Universal City cold case murder after DNA matches
- Man arrested for 1981 Universal City cold case murder, police say
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
