Action News 5 Memphis — News
17/11/2026 17:59

State audit: Nearly 60% of required Tennessee Highway Patrol evidence checks were missed or flawed from 2023 to 2025

What This Story Is About

  • The Tennessee Highway Patrol either didn’t conduct or incorrectly conducted more than half the evidence reviews required over a two year period, according to a new state audit report.

Why It Matters

  • Evidence reviews are a key part of the law enforcement process. In making sure evidence is stored and cared for correctly, agencies reduce the risk of missing out on key convictions.

What Happens Next

  • The report included a statement from THP management which said the policing agency would be updating its evidence review protocol.

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (WVLT) - From 2023 to 2025, more than half of the the Tennessee Highway Patrol’s evidence reviews were done incorrectly or not done at all, according to a review from the state.

The information comes from a recently released audit report from the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office, which evaluated the 126 evidence reviews the THP was required to do over the two year period. The report said 40 of those reviews weren’t performed at all; another 34 were done incorrectly.

The report said 40 of those reviews weren’t performed at all; another 34 were done incorrectly.

It means the state policing agency only performed 41% of the reviews correctly. The comptroller report broke down what specific issues their auditors saw:

“More specifically, for the improperly performed reviews, we found that 24 reviews did not include proof that the reviewer examined the related case files; 4 reviews did not explain discrepancies noted; 4 reviews were missing required information, such as case numbers, evidence type, whether the reviewer located the evidence, and who performed the evidence review; 1 review was performed by someone without authority to do so; and 1 review was not completed within the required timeframe,” the report said.

The crux of the issue stems from the THP manual’s instruction on conducting evidence reviews, according to the report. The comptroller’s office said the manual isn’t especially clear; requirements for reviews are spread throughout different sections of the manual rather than getting a dedicated section. The review also said THP management told auditors staff wasn’t clear who was responsible for conducting the reviews.

The review found another problem with THP’s evidence review procedure. The comptroller’s office found evidence custodians were going untrained or under-trained.

“Through discussions with evidence custodians, we also learned that some relied on personal experience, job shadowing, on-the-job training, and consultation with other custodians to learn their responsibilities,” the report said. “Some custodians reported that they did not receive structured instruction or written guidance for certain responsibilities, including vehicle storage lot procedures.”

It’s the responsibility of THP district captains to make sure the reviews are done — and done correctly. The report included a statement from THP management which said the policing agency would be updating its evidence review protocol.

“We concur with the findings and are in the process of refining our evidence custodian processes and training, which include updates to the Evidence Manual,” THP management said. “The revised Evidence Manual will establish updated standards, procedures, responsibilities, and formal training requirements. It is being developed in coordination with current Evidence Custodians and the Research, Planning, and Development Division. This will create clear expectations and practical guidance for performing the duties. The manual will also set up a district level review process. District Captains will verify that all evidence audits, inventories, and required reviews are fully completed, with documented findings and sign-offs.”

Evidence reviews are a key part of the law enforcement process. In making sure evidence is stored and cared for correctly, agencies reduce the risk of missing out on key convictions.

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Action News 5 Memphis — News.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

First Alert: 70s Return; Weekend Cold Front Brings Cooler Temperatures
Action News 5 Memphis — News
Warmer temperatures will continue to develop over the next few days, but there is a cold looming this weekend
Convicted felon faces charges after major gun, drug bust in Bartlett
Action News 5 Memphis — News
A man is facing multiple drug and firearm charges after a search warrant at a Bartlett home led to a substant…
Indictment accuses 2 Memphis caregivers of TennCare fraud
Action News 5 Memphis — News
Two Memphis caregivers are facing felony charges in connection with a state TennCare fraud investigation.
THE BREAKDOWN: Trans-Niño Index
Action News 5 Memphis — News
What is the difference between a Central Pacific and Eastern Pacific Event?
MPD recognizes 1,500 D.A.R.E. program graduates
Action News 5 Memphis — News
The Memphis Police Department spent time Tuesday celebrating more than one thousand students who completed th…
Take a tour of Oxford’s first St. Jude Dream Home
Action News 5 Memphis — News
Take a tour of Oxford’s first St. Jude Dream Home, featuring nature-inspired design, colorful spaces and comm…