Barre police officer resigns following misconduct investigation


This story by Gina Tron was first published in The Bridge on Nov. 16, 2026.
BARRE — Barre Officer Matthew Frey has resigned following allegations that he had a sexual relationship with a woman he arrested while her criminal case was pending.
Barre City Manager Patrick Cushing told The Bridge that Frey resigned on Nov. 13. He said the city has “completed the administrative portion of the investigation.”
The allegations against him stem from a May arrest in which Frey and another officer responded to a car crash in Barre City. The woman was charged with reckless or gross negligent operation of a motor vehicle, cruelty to a child and resisting arrest.
According to a letter issued Oct. 23 by Orange County State’s Attorney Colin Seaman, Frey began a relationship with the woman while her criminal charges were pending, primarily exchanging messages through Snapchat and requesting and receiving partially nude photographs.
On Sept. 13, Seaman wrote, Frey allegedly went to the woman’s home, asked her to keep the meeting secret and had a sexual encounter with her. The woman filed a complaint with law enforcement on Oct. 1, saying she felt coerced. Frey was placed on paid administrative leave on Oct. 5.
Seaman subsequently issued a Brady-Giglio letter, stating that his office had reason to believe Frey had engaged in conduct raising substantial questions about his credibility as a witness and his conduct as a law enforcement officer. Such letters alert defense attorneys to information that could undermine an officer’s credibility as a witness in criminal proceedings.
The letter had significant consequences for pending cases in Washington County. On Oct. 27, Washington County State’s Attorney Michelle Donnelly said that her office had dismissed approximately 50 criminal cases involving Frey, with potentially more to come, VTDigger reported. Donnelly said she would no longer accept cases involving the officer because of the credibility concerns.
In an earlier review, Donnelly stated that approximately 90 active criminal and family court cases involved Frey and were being evaluated to determine whether they could proceed without his testimony. She also dismissed the original criminal case against the woman Frey had arrested.
Vermont State Police investigated the allegations and referred the matter to Seaman’s office for review to avoid a potential conflict of interest. Prosecutors declined to bring criminal charges against Frey.
Read the story on VTDigger here: Barre police officer resigns following misconduct investigation.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
