Utah News Dispatch
17/11/2026 19:41

Commentary: Valar’s nuclear/data center paradise will be hell for everyone else

(Illustration by Alex Cochran for Utah News Dispatch)

Americans across the political spectrum (including Utahns) have been remarkably united in opposing data centers. Someone should tell the Carbon County commissioners. They just voted to hang that albatross around the county’s neck.  They also voted to expose their 20,000 residents to more radioactivity. Repercussions will ripple throughout the state.

Reasonable people wouldn’t get on an airplane whose pilot had never flown anything more than a kite. You wouldn’t let someone crack your chest and bypass your coronary arteries who had never finished high school, never went to medical school, never operated on a patient before, but just felt supremely qualified because, “How hard could it be?” But the commissioners were undaunted in turning their county’s future over to someone grossly unqualified, blinded by his own ambitions of becoming a nuclear prima donna, manifesting a complete lack of understanding or concern for the consequences to others. 

Valar Atomics is a 3-year-old company whose founder and CEO, Isaiah Taylor, is a 27-year-old high school drop-out. His previous work experience included teaching himself computer coding and working in an auto-repair shop. He has little formal education in anything, and none in nuclear physics, radiation, or public health. That should not be an indictment of anyone, unless that person insists on imposing his dangerous lack of expertise on everyone else.

Taylor’s company has developed “SMRs,” or “fun size” nuclear reactors. The idea of SMRs (small modular reactors) has been around for decades, its theoretical advantage is they could be mass produced in a factory reducing nuclear’s exorbitant costs. But that’s only true if hundreds, perhaps thousands were built. Other SMR projects failed because they didn’t reduce costs. Currently only two SMRs are operating commercially in the entire world, one in Russia, one in China. There is nowhere near enough real-world experience with SMRs to confirm their safety and viability.

Taylor’s nuclear career should have ended when he claimed that a person could hold one of his spent nuclear fuel rods in his hand for five minutes and not be exposed to any more radiation than from a single CAT scan. Actual experts say that person would be dead within seconds. 

Taylor could be a smart kid despite his lack of education. But raw intelligence itself is no reason to trust someone with policy that could harm the entire state. Elon Musk has plenty of raw intelligence. Big Tech oligarchs — Peter Thiel, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Ellison, Sam Altman, Jeff Bezos, Jensen Huang — are all smart people. But they lack what’s more important: wisdom, judgement, common sense, self-restraint, and a commitment to the common good. What Taylor lacks in these qualities he makes up for in hubris.  

Actual experts calculate Valar’s nuclear powered hyperscale data center megalopolis would wreak environmental and public health havoc on Carbon County in multiple ways. For example, in a study commissioned by Carbon County residents, two experts in atmospheric modeling calculate that the project would raise regional temperatures 5-12 degrees Fahrenheit as far out as 15 miles downwind. That would desiccate local agriculture and ecosystems. Taylor is unperturbed by information like this that throws cold water on his ambitions and his investors’ expectations.

Last week, Valar’s men came to the Carbon County Commission for approval of the first stage of Taylor’s nuclear fantasy — the largest nuclear power complex the world has ever seen, a farm of 456 SMRs using unproven technology, nuclear fuel manufacturing and factory assembly lines, slap dash storage of high-level nuclear waste, natural gas power plants and large hyperscale data centers, even larger than Stratos.

Taylor’s ambitions have been boosted by a state taxpayer paid propaganda campaign dispensing utter nonsense: “nuclear plants emit less radiation than bananas,” “a nuclear plant is safer than a chair,” “nuclear waste storage is safer than your leftovers,” and “nuclear energy is cleaner than a candle.” The deceitful campaign paved over the painful reality that tens of thousands of Utahns have died from “downwinder” cancers, and more will in the future, because of radiation they were promised was safe. If any state should refuse more radiation exposure it should be Utah. The commissioners were warned by experts that the project would launch a steady stream of radioactivity into the county in perpetuity on top of all the other data center environmental disasters. They were warned cancer rates are higher in communities with nuclear plants. They approved it anyway.

Real experts predict Valar’s nuclear/data center paradise will be hell for everyone else. Nuclear gimmicks should not be just the latest stepping stone for Big Tech to take even more control over our lives. And the world’s most dangerous and complex technology should not be toyed with by profiteering amateurs, using Utah as their guinea pig.

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Utah News Dispatch.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall announces she won’t seek a third term
Utah News Dispatch
Utah’s capital city mayor has announced she won’t seek a third term. Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall ann…
Utah legislator won’t get an intern or assigned staff after discrimination inquiry, records say
Utah News Dispatch
Utah's Senate president said Sen. Kathleen Riebe, D-Cottonwood Heights, won’t get her own intern or staff bas…
Utah House Democrats shake up leadership after the blue wave doubled their caucus
Utah News Dispatch
After doubling their caucus size from 14 to 28 legislators during this year’s blue wave election — shattering…
Utah advocates ask Cox to pause Flock cameras on state roads until new law is finalized
Utah News Dispatch
A Utah group advocating for more regulation of automated license plate readers is asking the governor’s offic…
Great Salt Lake-inspired fashion collection hits the runway, raises over $1 million in support
Utah News Dispatch
Imagine a fashion show that transports you to a different place. It immerses you in the sights, sounds and te…
The companies Utah consumers complain about the most
Utah News Dispatch
The following story was reported by The Utah Investigative Journalism Project in partnership with Utah News D…