GAO: Lack of documentation limits ability see if, or how USDA planned for reorganization

The U.S. Department of Agriculture's Jamie L. Whitten Federal Building in Washington, D.C. A new GAO report says it's not clear if or how much USDA considered the impact of its sweeping reorganization plan before embarking on it. (Photo by Preston Keres/USDA)
By Drew Friedman
It’s not clear whether or how much the Agriculture Department considered the impact of its sweeping reorganization plan before embarking on it, a government watchdog says.
For months, USDA officials declined to share information with the Government Accountability Office, despite about half a dozen requests for details about what, if any, analysis the department conducted before announcing the reorganization last summer.
In a report published last week, GAO said the agency’s refusal to turn over information makes it unclear to what extent USDA evaluated how the reorganization would impact services to primary customers, economic factors, workforce attrition, or the protection of taxpayer dollars during the disposal of federal property.
“Because USDA has not shared information about its analysis of the benefits and costs of its decision to reorganize, if it performed such analysis, Congress and the public cannot evaluate how these factors influenced USDA’s decisions and choices,” the report states.
“These were important things that we felt like USDA should have taken a hard look at, and maybe they did, but the point here is that they never provided any documentation stating that they actually did,” said Steve Morris, GAO’s director of natural resources and environment, and author of the report.
“It put us in a position where we couldn’t assess their efforts,” he said. “It really disadvantages Congress, taxpayers and the American public because they have no visibility over any of this stuff.”
Federal unions sue again to block planned USDA reorganization
GAO sent a draft copy of the report to USDA for a response. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins criticized the report, calling it a “politicized review” of the reorganization decision.
“GAO may scrutinize that decision, but it does not get to define the objective through veiled partisan shenanigans meant to maintain the status quo and ignore the realities facing USDA’s mission today,” Rollins wrote in a letter contained in the report.
Rollins argued that GAO’s report only included “select events” surrounding the reorganization, forgoing mention of financial issues at the Forest Service, staffing growth with no “sustainable way to pay for it,” and an underutilization of USDA building space.
“While I have long appreciated the work of the Comptroller General to audit and evaluate use of taxpayer resources, I write with concern that GAO proposes releasing a report that fails to tell the American people and members of Congress the unadulterated story of the department’s reorganization,” Rollins said.
In an unusual move, GAO directly responded to Rollins, saying it “conducted this review in an objective, independent and nonpartisan manner and stand by the accuracy of the facts presented.”
“We were perfectly in our lane to do what we did and to report what we reported,” Morris said. “Despite a lot of opportunities, USDA for whatever reason just failed to provide the documentation that we requested.”
In recent months, other agencies have similarly refused to provide requested information to GAO. White House officials declined to share records about Department of Government Efficiency personnel, limiting transparency on individuals who held DOGE positions and what type of ethics training they received. And the Office of Personnel Management did not provide any requested documents or information, nor did it agree to a meeting, as GAO was assembling a report earlier this year about workforce changes at the agency — again leading to incomplete information.
Morris emphasized that the latest report did not take a position on whether USDA’s reorganization decision was good or bad, but only sought information on USDA’s decision-making process.
“We’re just trying to get to basically the truth of what’s happening here — we didn’t opine on the reorganization itself,” he said. “We asked for information. It wasn’t provided. And as a result, it leaves Congress and the public in the dark here.”
USDA did provide some information to GAO, including raw employee attendance data in D.C.-area buildings and a report on Forest Service financial challenges. But since only raw data was provided, it’s unclear how or if it informed USDA’s reorganization decision, GAO said.
USDA first announced its reorganization plan last summer, including the intent to relocate about 2,600 D.C.-based employees to regional hubs across the country. About 90% of the USDA workforce already works outside the Washington, D.C., area.
At the same time, USDA has been taking steps to shrink its workforce. Between December 2024 and March 2026, staffing dropped 20%, from 91,000 employees to fewer than 73,000.
The workforce reductions were not equal across agencies: The Forest Service saw a staffing loss of about 12%, while the National Institute of Food and Agriculture staffing declined by about 41%, the GAO report shows.
The American Federation of Government Employees has been suing USDA over the reorganization, warning it will cause mass staff attrition. The effort is currently on hold after a federal judge ruled in October that the reorganization likely violates a legislative provision that prohibits USDA from reorganizing without congressional approval.
The judge denied USDA’s latest request to stay the injunction that has been keeping the plans on pause. But he previously acknowledged that the stay order may be short-lived: The provision blocking USDA’s reorganization is part of the current continuing resolution, which expires Dec. 11.
The GAO report also draws on results of USDA’s 2019 reorganization during the first Trump administration. While on a smaller scale, the initial reorganization effort led to significant decreases in staffing, expertise and productivity. The workforce largely recovered over the following two years, but GAO reported that employees who came in were less experienced and less diverse.
GAO previously found that during the 2019 reorganization, USDA did not fully analyze the potential impacts of the move before taking action.
“That serves as a good test case,” Morris said. “When you do these types of things, there are going to be some impacts. And it could be impacts on important things, like the number of folks you have, the skill sets that they have and the work you’re able to generate … There’s precedent there for why you would want to take a look at this.”
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
