Illinois leaders question whether hospital rescue plan was ‘orchestrated’ by troubled owner
GRANITE CITY, Ill. (First Alert 4) - Illinois officials have rejected a request for financial assistance for Gateway Regional Medical Center and Vista Medical Center East, questioning whether a proposed leadership change would truly separate the hospitals from their current owner.
In a Nov. 17 letter, Deputy Gov. Grace Hou, Illinois Department of Healthcare and Family Services Director Lizzy Whitehorn and Illinois Department of Public Health Director Dr. Sameer Vohra said the state could not “responsibly fulfill” the request.
They criticized American Healthcare Systems, which owns the hospitals, and said the proposal lacked a sufficiently detailed plan for sustainable operations.
“Responsibility for the current circumstances rests with the owners and operators of AHS,” the officials wrote.
The state said it remains willing to work toward a credible long-term solution but could not justify additional public investment in the proposal under review.
A representative speaking on behalf of the hospitals’ medical executive committees separately confirmed to First Alert 4 Investigates on Monday that a proposal sought $4.5 million for each hospital, or $9 million total, and included an approximately 45-day transition period.
State questions independence of plan
In the letter, officials said one of two proposed new leaders was a current legal counsel and adviser to American Healthcare Systems. They said that relationship raised concerns about the proposed structure’s independence and whether it was truly physician-led.
The state also said the proposed board structure would not fundamentally change the hospitals’ controlling ownership.
Officials said they had not received a sufficiently detailed plan explaining how additional public money would create a sustainable organization or preserve long-term access to care.
In a separate Nov. 16 letter obtained by First Alert 4 Investigates, the hospitals’ medical executive committees urged state leaders to intervene, warning that both hospitals could close before the holidays without immediate assistance.
The committees proposed moving operational and financial control away from current ownership to an independent structure, with nonprofit operations as an objective.
The committees asked the state to identify a bridge loan, accelerated payment of verified state receivables or another temporary financing mechanism. Their addendum proposed restricted-use accounts, independent financial oversight and a prohibition on transfers to current ownership.
Evelina Sarian, the wife of American Healthcare Solutions owner Mike Sarian, said they are “deeply disappointed by the state’s decision.”
“Our priority is the safety of our patients and the welfare of the medical providers and staff who continue to care for this community under extraordinarily difficult conditions. We will continue to work with the IDPH to pursue every available option to preserve services in Waukegan and Granite City.”
Sarian also said AHS is not owned or funded by private equity, like the state claimed in their letter.
State raises payroll and debt concerns
The state said it had previously provided millions of dollars in advance loans and other support to the hospitals after American Healthcare Systems acquired them in 2023.
Officials alleged AHS did not repay the loans and said the company owed the state nearly $120 million in unpaid taxes and penalties.
The letter also accused AHS of pressuring the state to fund payroll and said the company paid or partially paid employees with available resources when state money was not provided.
State officials alleged employees were asked to accept partial wages or delay depositing checks, and that the owners failed to pay their share of employee health costs.
First Alert 4 has asked for AHS’s response to the state’s latest allegations but have not gotten a response at this time.
First Alert 4 Investigates previously reported that state records showed Gateway and Vista owed more than $120 million in unpaid provider fees and penalties, about $47 million for Gateway and $74 million for Vista. That investigation also found that Illinois approved three $10 million advances after AHS sought help making payroll, with the last payment made in July 2024.
Separately, First Alert 4 Investigates reported on unpaid property taxes at Gateway, as well as unpaid bills and broken vendor contracts. In August, a representative for AHS CEO Mike Sarian said new management had resolved property tax issues, with debts paid or on installment plans; county records at the time continued to show no payments on Gateway’s outstanding property taxes.
Vista faces Medicare termination; Gateway action rescinded
The state said federal officials issued Vista a 15-day termination notice on Nov. 16, with its Medicare provider agreement scheduled to end Dec. 1. First Alert 4 Investigates has obtained that letter from CMS. It outlines federal officials cited deficiencies involving anesthesia services, emergency department coverage and the hospital’s ability to meet financial obligations critical to operations.
Gateway’s Medicare situation is separate.
In a Nov. 13 letter obtained by First Alert 4 Investigates, CMS said it had rescinded its action to terminate Gateway’s Medicare provider agreement after follow-up surveys. CMS said Gateway was in substantial compliance with Medicare participation requirements and was again deemed to meet applicable requirements through Joint Commission accreditation.
Bypass status and closure planning
The state said the hospital bypass status, diverting ambulances, must remain in place for both Gateway Regional and Vista because of concerns about consistently paying physicians and uncertainty over payroll.
Officials also said Gateway and Vista had not submitted contingency plans for a potential closure after an Aug. 5 request from the Illinois Department of Public Health. The state said such plans should address the safe transfer of patients and preservation of medical records and credentialing files. The letter does not say either hospital has been ordered to close.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
