North Dakota Monitor
17/11/2026 20:45

Audit: Millions in Ag Department grants went to ineligible recipients; commissioner disagrees

Agriculture Commissioner Doug Goehring listens during a meeting of the North Dakota Industrial Commission on Oct. 30, 2026. (Photo by Jacob Orledge/North Dakota Monitor)

Millions of dollars issued under a North Dakota bioscience grant program went to ineligible recipients, according to an audit released Tuesday.

Agriculture Commissioner Doug Goehring, whose department manages the grant program, said the money was properly granted and that he disagrees with the audit’s interpretation and a related press release. State Auditor Josh Gallion said he stands by the audit report and that his team did excellent work. 

North Dakota Republican State Auditor Josh Gallion addresses the Legislative Audit and Fiscal Review Committee on Sept. 22, 2026. (Photo by Jack Dura/North Dakota Monitor)

The audit of the North Dakota Department of Agriculture looked at the Bioscience Innovation Grant Program during the 2023-25 budget cycle. The program is for boosting bioscience technology and jobs in North Dakota. The 2019 Legislature created the grant program, which received increased funding in 2021 and 2023 but was not funded in 2025, according to the audit.

In the 2023-25 period, the grant committee made 39 grants totaling $10.9 million. The recipients used $8.4 million. The remaining $2.5 million went back to the state government’s main operating account, the general fund.

Initially, the audit sampled nine grant recipients regarding eligibility requirements and found six couldn’t show they met a requirement of annual sales below $2.5 million, the report said. One recipient was awarded $1.1 million despite never opening an intended Fargo location. Another was paid nearly $100,000 of its $240,000 grant before it established its North Dakota location. Another recipient was granted $125,000 for a purpose that wasn’t in state law, according to the audit.

Those findings prompted the audit team to look at the physical locations of all 34 grants that got payments. The audit found nine more recipients didn’t have locations in North Dakota, the audit said.

The grants included more than $2.5 million to businesses with no physical location in the state, the audit found.

State law doesn’t say anything about having a “bona fide” presence in North Dakota, but does require the businesses to be registered with the secretary of state, “and they were,” Goehring said.

The law mentions bioscience businesses “operating in the state,” the audit said.

The grant committee encouraged companies to establish a presence and bring their company to the state, Goehring  said. Many companies developed relationships in the state, set up labs and did testing in North Dakota, he said.

The Ag Department “did not require grant applicants to submit information to validate eligibility requirements were met,” the audit said.

North Dakota Veterans Home audit questions meal prep in wake of choking death

Goehring said his department was “dinged” for not having a checklist or a more formal process in place, but did verify all the information. A third-party contractor, the Bioscience Association of North Dakota, was supposed to do all the front-end work and report to the ag department, Goehring said. One agency staffer did help administer the program, he added.

He also said his agency inherited the program from the state Commerce Department and he sought to have more clarification in the law about responsibilities, duties and accountability, but lacked support in the Legislature and the industry.

The Ag Department canceled one grant award and reached a settlement agreement that cost the state about $82,000, the audit said.

Goehring said his agency did recoup money from a company that left the state before it completed all of its work and was sold to someone else.

“We followed the law and we reimbursed for work that was done, for devices that were developed, for programs, for software, for the work that was accomplished in the medical field, and where we had one issue, we recovered that money,” Goehring said. 

The longtime agriculture commissioner said he will appear in front of the Legislature’s audit review committee to answer questions about the audit. 

The state auditor said, “Our focus is making sure that we’re looking at these grants, these programs to make sure that we are complying with statutes, that we are making sure that funds are distributed in accordance with the laws, the rules, the policies.”

The audit also found some site visits and performance reviews weren’t done. 

In its audit response, the Ag Department said it agrees with recommendations of ensuring grant applicants meet the eligibility requirements before receiving the money, evaluating whether recovery of any money is necessary and clearly defining the grant requirements.

The Ag Department also said it has put formal eligibility verification procedures in place and added monitoring controls to the grant administration process, and is reviewing past grants to see if any recovery actions are necessary.

Sen. Terry Wanzek, R-Jamestown, who introduced the 2019 bill creating the grant program, said the audit creates questions and officials need to learn more. 

“I’m not ready to be judgmental yet. I want to hear more about what happened,” Wanzek said. 

The Legislative Audit and Fiscal Review Committee meets Nov. 30.

Reach North Dakota Monitor reporter Jack Dura at [email protected].

YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.

SUPPORT

GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.

SUBSCRIBE
📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: North Dakota Monitor.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

North Dakota students try on legislative roles, tackle AI
North Dakota Monitor
North Dakota students brainstormed answers to AI and technology use this week, hoping state lawmakers will ta…
North Dakota’s rural health money allocated but details not yet public
North Dakota Monitor
The $199 million North Dakota received for the first year of a massive federal rural health care grant has be…
Burleigh County ballot mistake would not have changed results, election official says
North Dakota Monitor
A ballot mixup at Burleigh County polling location on Election Day would not have changed any election result…
Fossil dig pit could add another learning experience on North Dakota Capitol grounds
North Dakota Monitor
A fossil dig pit on the Capitol grounds in Bismarck may soon stimulate young minds about the science of paleo…
Poll: North Dakotans want state data center regulations
North Dakota Monitor
North Dakotans want oversight from the state government to regulate data centers, but are split about whether…
New leaders elected for North Dakota Legislature’s Democrats
North Dakota Monitor
Two North Dakota lawmakers from the same Fargo-area district will lead the Legislature’s outnumbered Democrat…