Inspector General in 2020 had concerns about NOPD’s camera-ticket review process
What is this story about?
- The NOPD says city-supplied records present an incomplete narrative.
- FOX 8 converted the data from Arizona time and still found idle time.
- At least 77% of 15 officers’ 6,257.27 overtime hours appear idle.
Why it matters?
- Thousands of overtime hours were paid for reviews the records do not show.
- Drivers do not know what happens to their tickets.
What happens next?
- The NOPD is reviewing the program and its officers.
- Cameras are still recording violations that could become tickets.
- Officer Brandon Coleman faces 350 felony charges linked to payroll fraud and theft.
‘Idle Time’ investigation:
- NOPD news conference: New Orleans police pause red-light camera ticketing pending review after Fox 8 investigation
- Part 1: 15 NOPD officers logged questionable overtime while reviewing camera tickets, investigation finds
- Part 2: NOPD officers reviewed red light camera tickets during paid details, against department policy
- Part 3: Moreno declines to answer NOPD red light camera program questions pending investigation
- Part 4: NOPD disputes red light camera records; FOX 8 review still finds overtime shifts with no logged reviews
NEW ORLEANS (WVUE) - Even after converting vendor timestamps from the Arizona time zone the NOPD says they were recorded in, a FOX 8 analysis still finds at least 15 officers with multiple traffic-camera review shifts that show no recorded review activity and thousands of hours of what appears to be idle time, according to public records.
The NOPD says the vendor logs of red-light reviews supplied by the city through FOX 8’s public records request present an incomplete narrative.
FOX 8’s “Idle Time” investigation found 15 NOPD officers clocked at least a dozen overtime shifts each reviewing traffic-camera tickets. But public records provided by the city show no evidence of review activity during any of those overtime shifts.
The analysis included hundreds of thousands of lines of data obtained through public records requests from the City of New Orleans and provided by Verra Mobility, the company that operates the camera review program. The data included timestamps that indicate when an officer reviews a traffic violation, tracing the actions down to the second.
Time zone check
It was not until last Thursday evening (Nov. 12), after a week of multiple unanswered requests for interviews, that the NOPD reached out. The department indicated the timestamps provided by the City of New Orleans “were recorded in Arizona time,” though the records did not indicate that.
But even after converting the data into Central time, FOX 8’s analysis still found all 15 officers initially named in its investigation still had at least 12 review shifts with no recorded reviews, according to the city’s review records.
Altogether, nearly 45% of every camera review shift logged by those officers showed zero reviews recorded in the public records the city provided.
Thousands of hours of idle time
FOX 8’s analysis found at least 77% of the more than 6,257 hours of overtime the 15 officers were paid to review traffic tickets appear to be idle time. That is when officers clocked red-light review overtime, but timestamp data indicates reviews were not happening. Idle time here means stretches of 30 minutes or more with no logged reviews.
“I don’t see a plausible explanation here,” said Skip Gallagher, an NOPD watchdog who has reviewed police timesheets and pay records for years.
“The pay, in many of those cases, is screaming that somebody should look at those officers and find out what they were doing, when they were doing it, and see who was overseeing what they were doing.”
One user code on nearly every officer’s shifts
FOX 8 reviewed the audit trail of timesheets obtained from the NOPD through public records requests. It found that nearly every officer’s red-light camera shifts were added to timecards by one officer: Senior Police Officer Brandon Coleman.
In August, Louisiana State Police arrested Coleman and booked him with 350 felonies linked to payroll fraud and theft, after it completed its own payroll fraud investigation with the New Orleans Inspector General.
Across 14 officers, Coleman’s employee ID is listed as adding, editing or deleting thousands of overtime shift punches.
The NOPD’s timekeeping audit trail also shows Coleman’s user code marking shift punches “as reviewed” on at least 1,032 red-light camera review shifts. That is at least 83% of the shifts FOX 8 analyzed.
Ronal Serpas, who was the NOPD’s superintendent from 2010-14 and currently consults for police departments across the country, said he believes any internal review should be handled by an outside agency.
“If I came back to New Orleans and I ran into this, I would have to find a way to yank it from outside the police department to somebody I could trust until this got straightened out,” Serpas said. “Because the citizens have to know that their money is being spent well and being supervised.
“I’ve yet to see a department with that much money involved, where they didn’t have at least some fundamental or rudimentary auditing process just to protect the public.”
Inspector General recommendations
In 2020, then-New Orleans Inspector General Derry Harper recommended the NOPD “update its policies for review of citations” and “obtain appropriate data for monitoring officer performance to ensure a thorough review of tickets.”
The NOPD accepted that recommendation. Earlier this year, current Inspector General Ed Michel issued a report following up on Harper’s recommendations. It found: “Although the NOPD updated its policies for review of citations and implemented measures for quality control, the time spent reviewing individual tickets still raised concerns.”
The report notes the NOPD updated its policy to reflect the number of citations considered reasonable to review per hour at “60-80 citations per hour (absent documented technical issues).”
But FOX 8’s analysis of public records shows that in 2025, at least 12 officers recorded reviews of more than 80 citations in an hour, according to timestamps. That includes one officer who reviewed 294 violations in just 60 minutes.
“I don’t think you can turn around and justify all these shifts where it doesn’t appear that they were working in the amount of money that was spent. It certainly doesn’t make sense that, in many cases, they had reviews that are in seconds that they could possibly call a video review in that period of time and then stamp their name on it,” Gallagher said.
Serpas said, “Look, put it this way. Is the Inspector General wrong? Is the State Police wrong? Is the data you presented, which was public records in a public forum that you could release publicly every day of the week because of your rights as a journalist, is that wrong?
“There’s some fire under this smoke. And I think this is a kind of decision a mayor should be making and not the chief, because it’s gone on on their watch.”
Serpas on paying a ticket
The former New Orleans police chief says the data alone is enough to give him pause before settling a potential traffic-camera violation with the city.
“Look, I’ll be honest with you,” Serpas said. “If I got a ticket and I saw this story and I knew my ticket was in that batch of 100 tickets looked at in two minutes? Oh, I’m definitely saying I ain’t paying that ticket. How do I know anybody gave that a serious review? The data says they didn’t. It’s over.”
The NOPD’s response
The NOPD never sat down with FOX 8 before it published its investigation, and it still will not say what documents could be missing that could provide a complete picture of the work officers performed.
The NOPD has said in the past that officers have shared user codes to review and approve their own timecards. After FOX 8’s reporting earlier this year, the department promised it would end that practice.
The NOPD said it suspended issuing traffic-camera tickets while it conducts an internal review of the program and the officers who were paid to review tickets. However, it noted cameras at red lights are still recording violations that could be reviewed and issued as tickets in the future.
As for what that means for drivers who have been issued tickets, the city has yet to offer comment or respond to multiple requests for answers.
See a spelling or grammar error in our story? Click Here to report it. Please include the headline.
Subscribe to the Fox 8 YouTube channel.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
