Opinion: As Kansas hunters fan out to search for deer, how should we value our vanishing wilderness?

A young buck searches for a snack at dusk on June 21, 2025, on a hill south of Lawrence, Kansas. (Photo by Sherman Smith/Kansas Reflector)
As the Kansas deer hunting season unfolds, I have been thinking about the increasingly common practice of feeding and baiting deer among Kansas hunters. It diminishes the value of hunting and frays the already tenuous link between Kansans and wild things.
My reflections upon this issue began not with deer but with a much larger prairie ungulate: the American Bison.
Frontier Park on the outskirts of Hays is home to what is charitably called the Hays Bison Herd. The herd is just a few animals, remnants of a species that once roamed the plains in the tens of millions.
I often take my dog for walks around the fenced field that contains these great furry beasts. When we approach the fence, one of the bison will usually stop chewing grass to share a long stare with my dog. I imagine them silently discussing their experiences of domestication.
The drive home is melancholic as I think about the prairie that used to be, when bison roamed free and native grasses and wildflowers danced uninterrupted across the plains.
The alterations to the American prairie over the last century are best observed from above. Looking down from the window of a plane, one can see a lattice of roads separating farms and ranches, as if a great net had been drawn up from beneath the soil and laid to rest upon the earth.
In this new, parceled-out prairie, Kansans have little access to wild places. Those rare spots that have not been turned into crop fields lie hidden behind fences and property lines while publicly accessible areas of “preserved prairie” are often hours away by car.
In an ideal world, reduced access to wilderness would be treated as a public health crisis. Spending too much time surrounded by the fingerprints of our own species can, strangely, make us feel less human. Getting outside and outside of ourselves makes us humbler beings.
For many Kansans, deer hunting offers an opportunity to do just that. Hunting requires the hunter to step outside themselves and imagine the mind of the animal they are pursuing.
A Kansas hunter may stalk in the furrows of a plowed field or sit within earshot of cars passing on a country road and yet still experience some of the benefits of immersion in the wild because they are engaging with something that is wild. For hunters and non-hunters alike, a skunk ambling over a country road or a deer leaping over a fence are reminders that wild things still exist and resist our domination of the landscape.
White-tailed deer are wily and elusive creatures. A hunter may spend many frosty autumn mornings catching only an occasional glimpse of one as it vanishes into a cornfield.
Yet the difficulty and frustration of deer hunting can compel a hunter to turn to feeding and baiting.
On the surface, the practice makes sense. White-tailed deer in Kansas are already supplementing their natural diet of forbs and grasses with fallen corn and other agricultural leftovers. Establishing feed sites makes deer movements more predictable. Therefore the creatures becomes easier to spot and kill. Feeding also provides more calories to the deer, which yields more meat for the freezer and a more impressive set of antlers for the mantelpiece. But is this all that a hunter is pursuing?
Feeding and baiting improves the chances of killing a deer and the likelihood that it will be a more impressive specimen. But, over time, it diminishes what is most valuable about hunting: engaging with something wild and outside of our control.
Consider the following advice from Tractor Supply Co. on deer feeding:
“The best way to attract wild game to your land is to provide a steady and nutritious supply of wild game or deer feed throughout the seasons. This will ‘train’ whitetail deer and other big game to visit your property often, giving you the chance you’ve been waiting for.”
“Wild game feed” and “wild game training” are obvious contradictions. The more control we exert over a wild animal, the less wild it becomes.
Steven Rinella, host of the popular hunting show “MeatEater,” once said he values the idea of deer more than the deer itself. The value of a deer may be measured in the size of antlers and the quality of its meat, but the value of the deer lies in its separateness from us. That distance is worth preserving.
This is to say nothing of the ethics of shooting a deer over a feeding pile. President Theodore Roosevelt once said that this type of hunting can “only be justified on the plea of hunger.”
What about the deer themselves? While it may seem like they are getting a free lunch, concentrating deer around feeding sites disrupts their natural patterns of movement and brings them into unnatural proximity. This can increase the spread of diseases such as Chronic Wasting Disease. Kansas wildlife biologists recently estimated that “somewhere between 33% and 48% of 2.5-year-old bucks in northwest Kansas counties now have the disease.”
As more deer congregate on farms and in other areas where feed is provided, hunters who would otherwise abstain from baiting can find their access to deer diminished. The result is a kind of arms race, where even hunters who would prefer not to bait may feel compelled to do so to compete with those who do.
Whether it is fields of corn, family dogs, cows or the caged bison on the edge of town, there is no shortage of examples of human control over animals and land in Kansas.
What we are desperately short of is wild places and wild things.
The prairie is unlikely to be restored to its wild past, but if Kansas were to join the 27 other states that have outlawed intentional deer feeding, it would help to ensure a healthier population of deer on the plains while preserving the idea that something wild remains out there amongst the crops and crisscrossing roads.
Sam Foglesong is a scholar of African Studies and a writer who lives in Hays. Through its opinion section, Kansas Reflector works to amplify the voices of people who are affected by public policies or excluded from public debate. Find information, including how to submit your own commentary, here.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
