Maryland Matters
18/11/2026 06:53

Baltimore County schools, police sued for AI software ‘bag of chips’ mistake

The Baltimore County Circuit Courts Building in Towson. (Photo by Bryan P. Sears/Maryland Matters)

After an artificial intelligence program mistakenly identified a Baltimore County high school student’s bag of chips as a gun, county police and school officials turned that mistake into a “terrifying” and “life-threatening” encounter for the four teens involved, a new lawsuit says.

The suit was filed in Baltimore County Circuit Court Tuesday, a little more than a year after the confrontation at Kenwood High School. The 31-page complaint claims police officers inflicted pain and suffering on Oct. 20, 2025, on Taki Allen, then 16, and his three friends – Yui-Osa Ogbeide, Devon Thompson Jr.  and Keith Winfield III – all now 18.

The incident began about 6:30 p.m., as the four were talking and waiting outside the school for a ride after football practice. Allen had a bag of Doritos that his coach had given him after practice, a bag that the school’s Omnilert Gun Detection identified as a gun, alerting school officials.

Three officials who received the alert recognized the mistake and canceled the alert within minutes. But the school’s principal, Catherine Smith, “never acknowledged the Alert’s cancelation or took any steps to verify whether the Alert remained active,” the suit says.

Instead, more than 10 minutes after the alert was canceled, she sent a screenshot of video footage of Allen “holding the chip bag” and sent a text message to the school resource officer, who forwarded the screenshot to the police department, prompting “an armed police response.”

The alert went out about 7:05 p.m. By 7:21 p.m., six police cruisers surrounded the teens and officers got out, “many with guns drawn,” according to the complaint. They forced the teens to the ground, cuffed and searched them, according to the suit, which shows a picture of the boys with their arms raised outside the school.

YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.

SUPPORT

After they determined there was no gun, one officer told the students that “AI is not the best,” and another muttered “stupid AI cameras” and “[expletive] Omnilerts,” according to the complaint. “Yet officers relied on the Alert to initiate this painful encounter with the students,” it states.

One of the officers, Corp. Michael Foehrkolb, allegedly told the teens, “Hey, thanks for not running away, that would have been a real problem,” the suit says. It shows a text message from the principal to school staff and administrators that “made light of the incident.”

The text states: “No worries. SRO (school resource officer) had patrol car roll through. It was a bag of chips.” The message included four emojis crying from laughter.

Freya Jamison, an associate counsel with the Lawyers’ Committee’s Criminal Justice Program, said in an interview Tuesday there’s been no public apology from the school’s principal to the teenagers or their families. Jamison said Smith remains at the school.

“We can’t ignore the potential consequences of an armed police encounter, especially with young Black men like Takei, Osa, Devon, and Keith,” Jamison said. “They survived the encounter, but their safety never should have depended on luck.”

“As AI is on the rise around the country, it’s critical that technology companies and public officials are held accountable when they use that technology to violate constitutional rights,” she said. “We simply can’t outsource human judgment to machines, and this case shows exactly why.”

Omnilert spokesperson Blake Mitchell said in an email Tuesday that the company, named as a defendant, “cannot comment on lawsuits.” Baltimore County police and county school officials also declined to comment on pending litigation.

‘Failure’

The complaint notes that Omnilert’s AI weapon detection system was patented in 2022, “barely a year before it was deployed” in Baltimore County Public Schools, which was among “the first of its initial deployments.”

Richard Henry, the Maryland Office of Inspector General of Education, said in December on the “C4 and Bryan Nehman” radio show on WBAL that Omnilert works in Baltimore County schools. Henry attributed the Kenwood High situation to “human error” when looking at video and still images on a cell phone.

“In this case, this occurred in the evening hours, so it was low light,” Henry said on the show. “The student had the bag next to their hip, and they had the way that their hand was situated [with] a couple fingers in, a couple fingers out. That movement was detected, and it was just more or less, this is an alert. It could be a possible threat.”

But the complaint notes that Omnilert’s AI software suffered from false negatives before, including in January 2025 when it failed to detect a shooter’s gun at Antioch High School in Nashville. Two students died, including the shooter, and another was shot in the school’s cafeteria in that incident.

All four teen in the Kenwood High incident remain friends, the complaint says. Allen is still at the school, while Ogbeide, Thompson and Winfield, who graduated earlier this year, plan to visit the school on breaks from college and attend basketball games and other activities.

But with the current AI system in place and without adequate training for police and school staff, there remains concern for all four teenagers’ safety.

“The policies, customs, and training failures that produced this incident also remain in place, putting all four Plaintiffs at ongoing risk of being detained and searched without reasonable articulable suspicion,” the complaint states.

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Maryland Matters.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Maryland, Virginia join other states hoping to land new Space Academy
Maryland Matters
Maryland and Virginia this week joined the competition to be the home of the planned U.S. Space Academy, with…
GAO: Lack of documentation limits ability see if, or how USDA planned for reorganization
Maryland Matters
It’s not clear if or how much the Agriculture Department considered the impact of its sweeping reorganization…
Federal prosecutors drop gun conspiracy charges against Frederick County sheriff
Maryland Matters
Federal prosecutors on Tuesday dropped criminal charges against Frederick County Sheriff Chuck Jenkins (R), w…
more easily set upper payment limits
Maryland Matters
Gov. Wes Moore offered his “public and loud” support for proposed legislation that would allow the state to m…
Sheriffs make plea for restraint, as House, Senate weigh more immigration enforcement limits
Maryland Matters
Sheriffs traveled to Annapolis Wednesday with a message for lawmakers pushing a range of immigration protecti…
Advocates ‘thrilled’ by state decision to cap spending on diabetes drug Jardiance
Maryland Matters
Health care advocates on Wednesday hailed recent steps to limit how much state health plans will pay for a po…