The Colorado Sun
18/11/2026 08:00

Colorado must address repeated abuse of foster children in response to federal review

Colorado children removed from abusive homes are more likely than the national average to be abused or neglected a second time — after they’ve gone into foster care. 

The state scored below-average on treatment of children in foster homes, one of the reasons Colorado in December must submit a performance improvement plan to the federal government. 

A federal review found about 12 instances of abuse or neglect per 100,000 days in the Colorado foster care system in 2023, higher than the national rate of about 9. More than one-third of the victims were younger than 5, and about one-quarter of the victims were teenagers. 

The findings of the federal Children’s Bureau come as Colorado deals with a handful of high-profile cases of child abuse in foster homes. Child advocates said the federal findings, along with recent cases of abuse in foster homes in the state, show Colorado must do better at screening foster families, which is the responsibility of county child welfare departments and private child placement agencies contracted to find homes.

Among the most egregious recent cases is that of a Castle Rock man who was able to become a foster parent in Colorado despite having previously been accused of abusing children in Canada. Brian J. Zielke is facing 15 felony charges of sexual exploitation of a minor and two felony counts of attempting to influence a public servant after he took in Colorado foster children. 

In another case, Colorado Springs police in September said they are looking for additional victims after arresting a foster parent accused of sexually assaulting two boys in his care. Police said an investigation revealed that Enrique “Rico” Houghton, 35, was a foster parent to numerous children over the past five years. 

And in another El Paso County case, former foster parent Jason Allen Johns, 42, was charged with abusing a foster child and, in the course of that investigation, the sheriff’s office said it uncovered abuse allegations spanning more than a decade.

The federal review of Colorado policies noted that the state was not meeting standards for criminal background checks. While Colorado has policies in place to ensure background checks for foster and adoptive parents, it does not have “consistent statewide compliance,” federal officials wrote. 

The review also dinged the state for not working effectively with the foster parent licensing and recruitment agencies who help place kids who need homes. Federal officials said the state would do better at placing children in permanent homes if it had better processes for working with those agencies, which include Raise the Future, AdoptUSKids and Wednesday’s Child. 

Child advocates are calling on the state child welfare division to strengthen oversight of out-of-home placements. That includes the Office of Respondent Parents’ Counsel, which was created by legislation in 2016 to represent biological parents who cannot afford attorneys as they try to maintain their parental rights. 

The office’s attorneys said the recent cases of abuse in foster care emphasize the need for stronger oversight and more transparency. The office is often at odds with state and county child welfare officials seeking to remove children from abusive homes because its goal is to minimize “unnecessary family separation whenever safely possible.” 

“When children are removed from their families, the state has a responsibility to ensure that placements are not just safe but that concerns about abuse or neglect in care receive rigorous scrutiny and immediate response,” said Ashlee Arcilla, the office’s deputy director. 

Colorado in recent years has reduced the number of children who are removed from their biological parents, in part by investing more on in-home parenting training and helping parents with stressors like affording childcare. The “maltreatment rate,” which tracks repeated abuse within one year, declined to 12.7% of kids in child welfare cases in 2024 from 13.8% in 2022. The national rate is 9.7%.

El Paso and Denver counties combined accounted for almost half of cases in which Colorado children were abused twice within a year, the review found. The counties are two of the largest in the state. 

State child fatality, near-fatality reviews reveal gaps

Colorado’s child fatality review team, which looks into egregious injuries and deaths of children statewide, found that 59% of the cases that were substantiated last year involved families who had current or past involvement with the child welfare system. That was 54 out of 91 incidents. 

While the state keeps a public list of incidents, it does not release names of children who died or the county where they lived. Details of the cases are released only after a final outcome in the court system, which often takes years. 

In one report from a 2020 near-death of an infant, the review team said a 4 month old went to the hospital with seizures and a brain bleed that doctors said was not caused by an accident or a fall. The baby, born to parents who were homeless and were living off food discarded in trash bins, went to the home of foster parents in El Paso County soon after her birth. 

The foster parents described their discipline for older adopted children in their home as timeouts, spankings and using hot sauce as a punishment for lying, according to the review. The review team pointed to El Paso County’s “inability to provide services to the foster parents” because the parents had a pending court case involving their adopted children.

The foster parents lost their license after the allegations of “severe, near-fatal” abuse of the infant were substantiated by caseworkers.

Another state review, also in 2020 in El Paso County, said a 16-year-old boy tried to take his own life by overdosing on psychiatric medications while his foster mother was in the shower. An investigation led to a finding that the foster parents, who had been told about the teen’s mental health history, did not provide enough supervision. 

The boy had nine siblings and had been living in a vehicle when he was removed from his mother, the review said. After the suicide attempt in the foster home, the teen was intubated at a hospital. The child placement agency that screened the foster home, which was not identified in the review, reported the home to the state licensing office and said it “would put the foster home on hold for any new placements.” 

About two months before the suicide attempt, the foster parents — who lived in the same apartment complex as the teen’s mother — invited the mother for a visit, the review said. “The youth became upset and had to be placed on a mental health hold after making threats to harm himself,” the review said. 

The only recommendation from the state child fatality review team to come out of the incident was that Colorado should try harder to recruit more foster homes that are appropriate for LGBTQ children. The teen, who was identified as gender fluid, had been “targeted” by his biological mother because of his gender identity, the review said.

A focus on foster home recruitment

State child welfare officials, who are on a December deadline to give the federal government a performance improvement plan, said the Colorado Department of Human Services has already taken action to reduce abuse in foster care. 

Out of 30,000 allegations per year, there are 98-138 per year that are substantiated as child maltreatment in foster care, the department said. Those numbers have declined in part because the state has prioritized “kinship” placements, which are foster homes that are relatives, friends or neighbors, state officials said. 

The state has also expanded the capacity of therapeutic foster homes, which are licensed to provide care for children and teens with more severe health or behavioral issues. 

In a draft of its performance improvement plan, Colorado says it will focus on increasing support for families who have been involved with child welfare and had their cases closed. The state also is joining a federal pilot program called “A Home for Every Child” focused on foster home recruitment. 

Eight children on average enter foster care per day in Colorado, with about 3,500 kids living in foster families, the human services department said. About 2,500 of those are kinship placements. The state is short on foster homes, which makes it difficult for kids to stay in their school or even their county.

The federal review, called the Child and Family Services Review, evaluates every state on 36 measures. Federal officials came to Colorado in July and released their findings in September, triggering Colorado to work on its performance improvement plan. Colorado is one of many states required to submit performance improvement plans. 

“We welcome these reviews as an opportunity to continually improve our child welfare system,” the Colorado Department of Human Services said via email after declining an interview request from The Colorado Sun. 

The state did not answer a specific question about how a foster parent with abuse allegations in Canada was allowed to take in foster kids in Colorado.

Instead, human services officials said all foster parent applicants “must certify that their information is accurate, and knowingly providing false statements can result in perjury charges.” Applicants are required to include five years of address history and if they have lived outside of Colorado, must submit to child abuse registry checks in those states. Colorado does not require international background checks.  

The federal review from the Children’s Bureau, part of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, also found deficiencies with response time in Colorado when there are allegations of abuse or neglect in general, not just in foster care. In 85% of cases reviewed, counties responded to reports of abuse within the timeframe allowed under state law, which ranges from eight hours to five days depending on the severity of the accusation. The federal standard is 95%.

Colorado also struggles with placing foster children in stable homes that prevent them from frequent moves. The state met standards just 35% of the time. “Safety concerns in the home or foster parents no longer being able to continue caring for the child drove most unplanned moves,” the review said. 

Colorado did better than the national average, however, on finding permanent homes, including adoption or reunification with parents, within 12 months of entering the foster care system. Colorado achieved this 52% of the time compared to the national average of 35%.

Type of Story: News

Based on facts, either observed and verified directly by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: The Colorado Sun.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

BLM considers opening more than 100 miles of trails from Parachute to Eagle to e-bikes
The Colorado Sun
The agency's draft environmental assessment examines two expansion options, including one that would open 187…
Former Colorado state climatologist Nolan Doesken remembered as towering, kindly leader
The Colorado Sun
Former state climatologist, revered by colleagues and thousands of volunteer weather nerds, dies at 74 after …
Colorado grants $2.7M to show idea of capturing carbon isn’t dead yet
The Colorado Sun
Brooklyn-based Vycarb is working with Colorado companies to sequester emissions in water, creating a stable b…
Littwin: Will Dems actually go bold and vote for Van Hollen to replace Schumer as Senate leader?
The Colorado Sun
Columnist Mike Littwin writes that he wonders if Democrats will actually go bold and select Chris Van Hollen …
For Thomas Jefferson descendants Sal Pace and Shannon LaNier, it’s time to build bridges
The Colorado Sun
Thomas Jefferson descendants Sal Pace and Shannon LaNier will speak at the Colorado History Museum on Wednesd…
Wolf Creek Ski Area snowcat drivers traded slope grooming for flood cleanup on Wolf Creek Pass
The Colorado Sun
The ski area's heavy equipment crews joined CDOT to clear mud, rocks and debris from U.S. 160 after historic …