Alabama Reflector
18/11/2026 07:59

Commentary: Alabama’s school prayer amendment nudged us one step further down a slippery slope

Bible on a school desk in a classroom.

A Bible on a school desk in a classroom. Alabama voters earlier this month approved a constitutional amendment requiring local boards of education to adopt policies on student-led prayer. (Getty Images)

Nearly 1 million Alabamians voted ‘yes’ to Amendment 3 on Nov. 3. Those in favor of student-led prayer in school outnumbered those opposed by a 25-point margin.

For comparison, Tommy Tuberville beat Doug Jones in the governor’s race by only four points, meaning a sizable percentage of voters said yes to the Democratic gubernatorial candidate, flipped their ballots over, and also said yes to the Republican-coded question of school prayer.   

Given voters’ strong support for Amendment 3, it may seem like a fool’s errand to argue why it was a bad idea. But I’m going to do it anyway, because the debate over church and state runs all the way back to our nation’s founding. 

GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.

SUBSCRIBE

The newly passed statewide constitutional amendment will require local boards of education to adopt two policies for K-12 public schools: One mandates the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance at the beginning of each school day; the other authorizes student-initiated and student-led prayer.

Functionally, the amendment appears to be meaningless. Students already recite the Pledge every day, and student-led prayer has been enshrined in state code since 1993. Amendment 3 seems designed simply to show off legislators’ patriotism and burden local governments with a few extra lines of useless policy. The waste of time it took to get it passed is already a strike against it. Lawmakers should be focused on substantive issues, not grandstanding.

But the bigger problem is that it further smudges the already blurry line between Christianity and public education in Alabama. 

Many schools actively promote a cornucopia of Christian clubs and gatherings, from First Priority and Bible studies to Fellowship of Christian Athletes and See You at the Pole. While those gatherings are voluntary, students in grades 5–12 will soon face mandatory religious displays. When they return from winter break in January, they will find freshly minted copies of the Ten Commandments hanging in their history classrooms and common spaces, as required by a new state law.

If parents decide that’s not enough, and they’d rather send their children to religious schools instead of public ones, the CHOOSE Act ensures that they can use taxpayer funds to help pay their tuition.

When students feel moved to discuss their religious beliefs among their peers, the First Amendment protects their right to do so. But when schools dedicate resources to promoting Christian groups, then up the ante with clearly unconstitutional nonsense like the Ten Commandments law, the result is an educational environment that inappropriately elevates and exalts Christianity.  

Some parents would argue that all of this is good and necessary, that too many families today have lost their moral compass and need to be steered toward the guiding light of Jesus in whatever way you can reach them, up to and including through official school channels.

James Madison would heartily disagree. The founding father and author of the Bill of Rights would say that fudging the separation between church and state does not lead to each uplifting the other. Instead, both suffer. 

In 1785, he wrote: “The preservation of a free Government requires not merely, that the metes and bounds which separate each department of power be invariably maintained; but more especially that neither of them be suffered to overleap the great Barrier which defends the rights of the people.” The rulers who breach that barrier, he wrote, are tyrants, and the people they govern are slaves. 

The founding father and author of the Bill of Rights would say that fudging the separation between church and state does not lead to each uplifting the other. Instead, both suffer.

If that sounds a touch dramatic, consider where Madison was coming from. Just across the Atlantic, Europe’s messy history was littered with centuries of deadly inquisitions and religious expulsions, fruitless Crusades and craven bishops—all the result of politics entwined with religion. He wanted none of that.

So when Madison wrote the Bill of Rights, he included the Establishment Clause and Free Exercise Clause right at the top of the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Practice your faith to your heart’s content, he said, but don’t impose it on others.

That should have settled the matter, but the issue has come before the U.S. Supreme Court again and again. Litigants have poked and prodded at the First Amendment from various angles, testing its limits.  

In the landmark 1962 case Engel v. Vitale, as the country grappled with the Cold War and tried to distinguish itself from the Soviets through displays of Christian patriotism, the Supreme Court considered a New York law that had established a specific nondenominational prayer that public-school teachers could lead in their classrooms. 

The court struck down the law. Writing for the majority, Justice Hugo Black (formerly a senator from Alabama) summed up and reinforced Madison’s thinking beautifully. He said that first and foremost, the Establishment Clause “rested on the belief that a union of government and religion tends to destroy government and to degrade religion.” 

It may seem like an impossible leap to get from where we are today to some apocalyptic future where government has been destroyed and religion degraded. But consider our governor-elect: Tuberville has been hell-bent on persecuting law-abiding Muslim Americans, and he recently blasted Christian pastors for being insufficiently political. Imagine if the First Amendment weren’t around to keep him on a leash. Suddenly it’s not such a leap at all. 

There is a place for faith in public schools, just as there’s a place for it in every public space. The faithful are called to live out their beliefs not just in prayer, but in every word and deed. Kindness, generosity, mercy, honesty: All of these can be expressions of faith. And the First Amendment protects our right to frame those virtues in specifically religious language. It’s OK to talk about Jesus.

We just can’t co-opt the power of the state to do it. It violates both our country’s founding principles and the sanctity of faith.

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Alabama Reflector.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Weapons remain leading cause of non-medical deaths for Alabama children in 2025
Alabama Reflector
Weapons were the leading cause of “non-medical, unexpected or unexplained” deaths in 2025 for children under …
North Baldwin voters send Danielle Duggar to Montgomery
Alabama Reflector
A new Republican representative from Baldwin County hopes to use her experience as a legislative analyst and …
Black Belt food insecurity higher than state average, says analysis
Alabama Reflector
The Black Belt suffers from higher rates of food insecurity than Alabama averages, according to an analysis f…
At portrait ceremony, Kay Ivey reflects on 10 years in office
Alabama Reflector
Gov. Kay Ivey reflected on her historic tenure as a portrait and bronze bust were unveiled on the Capitol Com…
Montgomery’s Jackson Hospital emerges from bankruptcy, gets $40 million state loan
Alabama Reflector
Gov. Kay Ivey on Thursday approved a $40 million loan to a troubled Montgomery hospital. The transfer to Jack…
Commentary: Tommy Tuberville, back on the attack
Alabama Reflector
I’d like to give our incoming governor the benefit of the doubt. Really, I would. In most cases, officials de…