Thousands of WV tax deeds could be set aside due to alleged process server forgeries

An investigation found that potentially thousands of deeds for tax delinquent properties sold by the state Auditor’s Office were fraudulently notarized. (Photo by Amelia Ferrell Knisely/West Virginia Watch)
Potentially thousands of deeds for tax delinquent properties sold by the state Auditor’s Office were found to be fraudulently notarized, an investigation by the Secretary of State’s Office found.
And some people were found to not have been served at all, the investigation showed. This could open the door to deeds being contested and set aside in court.
“There are a lot of ramifications for a process server, whether it be in litigation, serving a copy of someone’s complaint, or serving a copy of the notice of the tax sale at a property,” said state Sen. Ryan Weld, an attorney who deals in property law.
The issues with the process server don’t relate to the federal indictments against Auditor Mark Hunt announced Monday by prosecutors. But it is another in a series of issues brought to light about the Auditor’s Office, which have included hiring a state senator for contract work, irregularities in tax sales and a potential conflict of interest with a used car lot.
Over the summer, Falcon Express — a process server that has worked for the Auditor’s Office to serve interested parties in properties up for tax sale — alerted the Secretary of State’s Office that one of its subcontractors was using a notary who did not appear to exist.
The number of documents, issued between 2022 to 2026, could be in the thousands, according to a report filed in the investigation. That means those with an interest in a property gone to tax sale could potentially have been robbed of the chance to pay the back taxes if they hadn’t been served at all, or those buying a tax sale property could have their ownership contested even if they did all the right things.
Property owners who may have been improperly served could have the tax delinquent deed set aside, according to West Virginia state code.
During a tax delinquent property sale, a buyer of the property must conduct a title search to find any property owners or any entity with a lien on it. For instance, a piece of property could be split between the five children of a deceased person and all would need to be served.
The results of the title search are then given to the state Auditor’s Office, who in turns uses their contracted process server to contact everyone with legal claims to the property to let them know about the sale.
Any tenant renting a property up for tax sale would also have to be served. Weld said this could potentially give them the opportunity to buy it themselves — and improperly serving them could jeopardize that.
“If you have a kind of a slumlord as your landlord, someone who isn’t really taking care of the property, doesn’t really care what happens, and they’re not paying the property taxes, you could be robbed of the place that you live at because you never even knew,” he said. “You can’t do anything about something you don’t know about.”
Madyln Alqutub, a spokesperson for the Auditor’s Office, confirmed that Falcon Express is still being used by the office, stating issues with a subcontractor were “identified and addressed.”
“Our office is presently in litigation and is unable to make further comments regarding this matter,” she wrote in a statement.
The notary stamps in question appeared on sworn affidavits that stated the server had made contact with the interested party and given them the legal documents.
An investigator with the Secretary of State’s Office — which is in charge of keeping a list of authorized notaries — traveled to the Eastern Panhandle to find the notary listed in affidavits verifying papers were served.
During the course of the investigation, the Secretary of State’s Office obtained a forged notary stamp. The investigator also confirmed that an additional 30 documents that appeared to have been notarized by a registered notary were not signed by the person whose signature appeared on them.
The investigation also found multiple instances where a person who was supposed to have been served was not, according to the report.
The subcontractor died shortly after the investigation culminated in a search warrant at their house.
The Secretary of State’s Office closed the case as non-prosecutable due to the subcontractor’s death. The office forwarded the findings to the state’s Auditor Office, according to David Cook, the Secretary of State’s general counsel.
Alqutub, a spokesperson for the Auditor’s Office, said the office never heard from the Secretary of State about the findings.
Falcon Express was initially hired during the latter half of then-auditor, now Attorney General JB McCuskey’s administration.
Kallie Moore, a spokesperson for McCuskey, said the Auditor’s Office had no issue with the processor at that time. Falcon Express declined to comment.
The Auditor’s Office has paid a little more than $1 million since 2020 to Falcon Express for serving papers, according to West Virginia Checkbook, an online database of state account transactions.
About $35,000 has been paid since the investigation concluded.
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
