Chicago animal rights activist is sentenced to jail time after falsely reporting shooting at 'backyard rodeo'
A longtime animal rights activist in Chicago was sentenced to 60 days in jail, 60 hours of community service and a year of probation after being found guilty of hounding dispatchers downstate and making a false report of a shooting with the aim of getting police sent to a “backyard rodeo” where she believes livestock were being mistreated.
North Side resident Jodie Wiederkehr, 57, was sentenced this month by Ogle County Judge Anthony Peska after a jury found her guilty of a felony and a misdemeanor. With "day-for-day" good-behavior credit, the 60-day sentence would translate into 30 days.
Backyard rodeos have been held in rural and semi-rural locales in Illinois in recent years, including some suburban sites.
The rodeos often include an event called “steer tailing,” which involves someone on horseback chasing down a fleeing steer and wrapping a leg around the animal’s tail, with the intent of it tumbling to the ground. Beyond injuries from the fall, the steers sometimes have their tails ripped free in the process, something called “degloving.”
Animal rights activists have been trying to halt the practice, arguing it violates the state’s animal cruelty statute, though some say the wording is too vague to prosecute under. There have been unsuccessful legislative efforts to refine the law to more explicitly bar steer tailing statewide, while some county governments are also taking it on.
Wiederkehr — a member of SHARK, which stands for SHowing Animals Respect and Kindness — said she was remotely monitoring one of the rodeos being held last year in the Rochelle area west of DeKalb, “getting the play-by-play from the field team that was there” monitoring the event via drone.
“There were steers being degloved, overworked, criminally abused,” she said.
She said she called the Ogle County sheriff’s non-emergency number numerous times and, frustrated and angry that nobody was going to be sent, ultimately told a dispatcher there was a shooting in an attempt to force a police response.
There had been no shooting, and Wiederkehr said she regrets saying that, and is embarrassed, but in the moment was “distraught.”
“Two steers and a horse got legs broken at a previous rodeo there,” she said.
She insisted she “didn’t harass” the dispatchers, saying that “each time I called there was a crime happening” that amounted to animal cruelty, but wasn’t taken seriously.
Her attorneys asked for no jail time.
Peska said in court that after reading character letters about Wiederkehr it's clear she's viewed as “a coveted family member, friend, advocate,” according to a transcript.
Even so, he said it’s important to impose a sentence serving as a deterrent.
“I think it's of critical importance to realize we’re not in a county with unlimited resources,” Peska said. “When you call the Ogle County sheriff’s department, they might have two deputies on duty for the entire county,” so a bogus call can take them away from a legitimate emergency.
Wiederkehr argued that, while she made a mistake, the sheriff’s office did not really believe there’d been a shooting, and that she was prosecuted because Ogle County State’s Attorney Mike Rock was angry about Wiederkehr previously criticizing him over a lack of prosecutions involving the rodeos.
Wiederkehr’s lawyers filed court papers portraying this as a “vindictive prosecution.”
The judge rejected that argument, and Rock said it’s not true.
“Our prosecution, in every case, is to pursue justice, and that’s what was done here,” Rock said. “She wasn’t treated worse or better because of who she was . . . she committed a criminal act and we pursued it.”
“I did believe jail was appropriate,” Rock added, noting the statute allowed a prison sentence on the felony of up to three years.
Chris Carraway, one of Wiederkehr’s attorneys, said Peska previously has gone lighter on more serious offenses, including an incident in which a teenager threatened to "shoot up" a school and got 24 months of probation.
Peska wouldn’t let Wiederkehr present a defense based on the argument “that I broke the law to prevent a greater harm,” she said. Nor would the judge let the jury see video of the rodeo in which animals were mistreated, Carraway said.
Rock said “they wanted to turn this into a week-long trial of whether steer tailing is appropriate or not when the issue was whether she made repeated calls and ultimately a false report of a criminal offense.”
An appeal on the sentence, conviction or both is expected.
Under pressure, organizers of the Ogle County rodeo have stopped holding the event.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
