What can Washington lawmakers do about record-breaking lawsuit payouts?

The state Capitol in Olympia, Washington on Aug. 10, 2026. (Photo by Jerry Cornfield/Washington State Standard)
When Washington lawmakers return to Olympia in January they’ll consider a variety of ways to address ballooning legal payouts hamstringing the budgets of the state and local governments.
One option: transformative changes to the state’s legal system, such as capping skyrocketing damage payouts or limiting public liability. Conversely, attorneys who bring the cases and other advocates want to focus on reducing the harm that leads to these cases.
After months of work by a state panel to come up with solutions, all ideas are ready for lawmakers to ponder — but competing voices appear no closer to consensus than when the Legislature finished its work for 2026 in March, and created the committee.
“It really is upon us to decide, given the menu of options, where we want to go,” said state Sen. Manka Dhingra, a Democrat from Redmond and chair of the Law and Justice Committee.
Everyone agrees on one thing: Action is needed.
“We need significant changes, and it has to happen now,” said Derek Young, executive director of the Washington State Association of Counties. “I just refuse to believe that this Legislature is going to allow their governments to fail.”
The claims leading to the fiscal crisis run the gamut from bungled child welfare cases to discrimination. Many involve childhood sexual abuse, especially in the foster care system. Governments have been found liable for failing to protect those children, and the cases often stem from decades-old conduct.
Court decisions over the past decade have opened up the state to more claims. At the same time, verdicts handed down from juries are growing. This spring, for example, a Pierce County jury ordered the state and a day care center to pay $130 million for the death of a toddler.
Last fiscal year, the state spent over $537 million resolving claims, a record-breaking annual figure that has jumped by hundreds of millions of dollars in the past few years. Beyond that, the state spent more than $90 million to defend the cases, including fees for insurance along with in-house and outside defense attorneys to handle litigation.
This year’s costs are greater, so far. Through the first third of the fiscal year, from July through October, the state has spent $196 million on lawsuit payouts, and $41 million more on legal fees and insurance, for total costs of nearly $238 million, according to the state Department of Enterprise Services. The trend puts the state on pace for payouts nearing $600 million this fiscal year, which would set another record.
Counties and school districts have similarly seen increases in payouts or insurance costs — money that would otherwise go toward typical public services such as police and fire departments, or education.
“I don’t know that the stakes could possibly be higher,” Young said.
Rhea Yo, executive director of Legal Counsel for Youth and Children, is one of the advocates pushing governments to limit the traumatic episodes that lead to eye-popping verdicts in court.
“It’s not lost on me that when money is provided into these judgments, that the state has less money to provide and counties have less money to provide direct services, which then can potentially create more harm,” said “I understand the math of that. It is really a very difficult problem to solve.”
The Legislature this year spent $1 billion to shore up the state’s liability account, given the skyrocketing payouts and more on the way. But another massive infusion is likely needed. Lawmakers failed to pass proposed legislation earlier this year. It would have required arbitration to speed up cases; a red flag for trial lawyers, who opposed the idea at every step. Tyna Ek, general counsel for the Washington Schools Risk Management Pool, fears attorneys “will fight any recommendation that will in any way mitigate costs.”
After the bill stalled, the state spent $50,000 to set up the panel to study the issue and provide recommendations, all within a few months.
“This is a conversation that can’t be researched within like two months,” said Riddhi Mukhopadhyay, executive director of the Sexual Violence Law Center. “I understand what the purpose of the report was. I don’t know if it really accomplished what the initial hope was.”
Cost reduction
Most states have a cap on damage awards for cases against state or local governments. Washington does not.
Most members of the state’s committee, namely the government representatives, believe the Legislature should impose a damage cap, but they don’t specify a specific amount. A limit, they contend, would still allow plaintiffs to recover damages while preserving systemic fairness.
“Limiting non-economic damages would still allow claimants to be compensated. It would allow them to be more evenly compensated,” Ek said. “And it wouldn’t bankrupt the public resources.”
The argument will be a tough sell in the Democrat-controlled state Legislature.
“I personally struggle a lot with a cap on damages to survivors,” Dhingra said. “I don’t think you can put a dollar figure on the type of abuse.”

Another issue for governments is a wonky legal concept called joint and several liability, which allows plaintiffs to bring their case against any party that is at fault, no matter how small their role in alleged misconduct.
For example, if a drunk driver goes the wrong way on the freeway and kills another motorist, the state could be held liable because a “do not enter” sign wasn’t lit properly or placed in the right spot. In that scenario, the state, seen as a defendant with deep pockets, could be saddled with the entire penalty, even if its actual portion of the liability was small and the drunk driver was the real culprit.
Washington ranks as an outlier in such cases. Governments face expansive liability and no limit on damages that can be collected from them, according to the majority report from the committee.
“It effectively makes government the insurer for the misconduct of other people, so we don’t think that this is really all that difficult of an equation,” said Young, of the counties’ association. “This is the crazy part. If we were struggling with something that nobody else had figured out, I could understand. The thing is, we’re the only state with this problem.
Most of the state panel recommends prohibiting defendants such as the state from being held liable for the full amount of damages unless their responsibility for the harm rises above a certain threshold, such as 25%.
“I think there is appetite to take a look at the joint and several liability rules and where we may be able to make some changes,” Dhingra said. “I am agnostic on the details of it, but I do think there are some practical things we can do in that arena, so that you are being responsible on who needs to pay how much.”
Speaking of legalese, another difficult hurdle is sovereign immunity: the idea that a government cannot be sued without giving its consent. The state waives its immunity. Committee members recommend changing that, but it’s another idea sure to generate opposition from trial lawyers.
Some panel members call for a fund to compensate certain victims with set amounts, limiting legal liability for claims involving historic child sexual abuse allegations, for example. Opponents fear that would pit survivors of abuse against each other for access to limited funds.
Harm reduction
Attorneys who bring cases and allied advocates felt outnumbered on the committee, they said, contending that their attempts to focus on limiting harm were given short shrift.
They say the ideas brought by government affiliates would simply reduce access to justice for people harmed by public entities, rather than address root causes that could lower costs over time. So they brought forward their own suggestions.
“The primary focus is how do we make sure the judgments are lower,” Yo said. “The primary focus was not how do we make sure that we are not perpetuating this problem so that we’re dealing with this 10 years down the line.”
“It will save the state money in many different ways if they prevent the harm to begin with,” Yo added.
The biggest goal for harm-reduction advocates: finding ways for the state to limit trauma from government misconduct, such as record-high deaths in the child welfare system and overcrowding in youth prisons. Ideas include trauma-informed training for staff and volunteers, plus better staffing and lower caseloads for employees with the Department of Children, Youth and Families, the epicenter for Washington’s increased liability. Adversaries say that will cost more money, not less.
One recommendation calls for risk pools, which allow local governments to jointly manage their liability, to require participants follow prevention measures and review significant claims to ensure mistakes don’t recur.
On the court side, trial attorneys and advocates want to expand an early resolution program within the state attorney general’s office, with the idea of reaching quicker settlements and lowering litigation costs.
Along the same lines, the committee’s minority hopes to limit the attorney general’s use of private law firms to defend the state in cases — a driver of rapidly increasing defense costs. A separate notion would require risk management decisions to be examined so governments don’t go to trial and get stuck with hefty verdicts that could have been avoided with lower-cost settlements.
State senators will be pushing legislation next year to protect survivors in K-12 schools by ensuring that employees and volunteers who commit misconduct can’t get other jobs in education, Dhingra said, comparing the idea to police accountability laws. Again, the goal is reducing harm, and thus lawsuits. A proposal aimed at college campuses seeks to ensure sexual assault survivors have access to resources.
Another policy would restrict companies that aggregate leads to sell to law firms that bring cases.
Dhingra is hoping Gov. Bob Ferguson, the former three-term attorney general, will “lean in” to the thorny debate. She says she’s “really optimistic we will move the needle on this.”
A spokesperson for Ferguson said he is reviewing the recommendations. The 105-day legislative session begins Jan. 11.
“In order for the Legislature to fix the problem,” Ek said, “it’s going to take a lot of political will and courage.”
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
