CommonWealth Beacon
18/11/2026 10:40

Steward’s collapse left patients and health care workers exposed. Massachusetts must ensure accountability for those who were in charge.

IMAGINE A FIREFIGHTER entering a burning building. The structure is failing, the exits are compromised, and people are trapped inside. She knows the risks. She enters anyway.

Now imagine that, after the fire is extinguished, she discovers the building’s owner neglected its safety obligations and failed to maintain adequate insurance. Yet somehow, she is left responsible for the damages.

She did not start the fire. She should not be left with the bill.

This is the predicament facing health care workers who remained at Steward Health Care hospitals as the company’s financial empire collapsed around them.

Physicians, nurses, physician assistants, and other professionals continued caring for patients amid staffing shortages, dwindling resources, and mounting uncertainty. They were encouraged to stay, reassured that their malpractice insurance remained intact, and praised for their commitment.

Then Steward filed for bankruptcy in May 2024.

What followed exposed the difference between having insurance and having insurance that can actually pay a claim.

Steward relied on TRACO, a captive malpractice insurer domiciled in Panama. Its financial arrangements reportedly relied heavily on obligations between affiliated companies rather than independently available reserves.

The Boston Globe reported that there were 517 pending or settled but unpaid malpractice claims, with estimated resolution costs approaching $200 million. TRACO reportedly had only about $3.5 million in available cash.

As Steward’s hospitals deteriorated, clinicians faced greater exposure to liability and diminishing financial protection against it.

Today, patients face uncertainty over compensation while health care workers confront lawsuits, legal expenses, and the possibility of personal financial ruin. Massachusetts intervened to preserve hospital services. Yet many patients and health care workers remain exposed to the financial consequences of Steward’s collapse.

Neither group created this crisis. Both deserve protection.

That principle inspired the formation of PROTECT: Patients and Providers for Reform, Oversight, Transparency, Equity, and Clinical Trust, a coalition advocating greater health care accountability.

Steward exposed systemic failures that extend far beyond one corporation. Massachusetts now has an opportunity to address them.

First, establish a Steward Recovery Fund. Massachusetts responded to a malpractice insurance crisis in 1975 by creating a mechanism to preserve coverage. A temporary fund could now compensate valid claims while protecting health care workers from financial ruin.

The Commonwealth should retain the right to recover those expenditures from Steward, TRACO, affiliated corporations, and, where legally justified, the personal assets of responsible executives. Public intervention must not become private absolution.

Second, strengthen malpractice insurance oversight. Hospitals should not promise insurance backed by inaccessible offshore assets or unsecured obligations between related companies. Massachusetts should require appropriately regulated coverage, independently verified reserves, and enforceable financial protections.

Insurance that disappears precisely when it is needed is not much use to anyone.

Third, pursue executive accountability. The attorney general should investigate potential civil and criminal violations and bring proceedings wherever the evidence warrants. If charges are not justified, the public deserves a comprehensive explanation.

Fourth, investigate predatory malpractice insurance practices. Clinicians who were assured they had adequate coverage should not face exorbitant replacement or tail insurance costs because their employer failed to honor its obligations. Improper charges should be recoverable, with appropriate penalties helping finance the recovery fund.

Fifth, modernize malpractice accountability. Our malpractice system must evaluate the totality of circumstances leading to patient harm, not simply the actions of the last clinician involved.

Hospitals are powerful institutions that control staffing, scheduling, resources, and the conditions under which care is delivered. Liability should follow control.

Malpractice tribunals should be able to examine institutional failures alongside individual negligence. Massachusetts should also reconsider its $100,000 charitable liability cap, which can limit compensation from qualifying health care institutions.

Equally important, reforms promoting independence in clinical decision-making should ensure health care teams can exercise professional judgment without unnecessary administrative restrictions or corporate interference.

Finally, strengthen whistleblower and worker protections. Health care workers are often the first to recognize unsafe conditions, yet speaking out can jeopardize their livelihoods. Massachusetts should strengthen retaliation protections through meaningful penalties, a private right of action, and recovery of attorneys’ fees.

The Legislature must also eliminate special Wage Act exemptions that shield charitable health care institutions from accountability. A withheld paycheck can become a powerful instrument of control, silencing the employees best positioned to expose wrongdoing. Charitable status should never excuse financial coercion or diminish workers’ rights.

These reforms do not excuse individual medical negligence. Patients deserve justice when they are harmed. But responsibility must follow the evidence, including into executive offices and corporate boardrooms.

Steward’s collapse was not merely a failure of hospital management. It exposed weaknesses in how Massachusetts regulates health care institutions, financial risk, and corporate accountability. Those weaknesses matter as hospitals confront continued consolidation, financial pressures, and uncertainty over looming Medicaid cuts.

Without reform, Steward may prove less an exception than a preview. Massachusetts demonstrated that it could act decisively when hospitals faced collapse. The question now is whether that commitment extends to the patients and health care workers left behind.

We cannot celebrate the professionals who stayed, praise their sacrifice, and then leave them financially responsible for arrangements they neither designed nor controlled.

A firefighter who accepts the danger of entering a burning building should not have to assume the financial consequences of its owner’s negligence. Neither should the health care workers who stayed at Steward.

They didn’t start the fire. They shouldn’t be left with the bill.

Duncan Daviau, a physician assistant and emergency medicine clinician, is a health care advocate writing on behalf of PROTECT (Patients and Providers for Reform, Oversight, Transparency, Equity, and Clinical Trust).

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: CommonWealth Beacon.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Healey: Legislature should pass housing policy rejected by voters
CommonWealth Beacon
Question 7 aimed to ease the state's chronic housing crisis and increase the availability of potentially smal…
Lower your expectations: House majority leader does not think Legislature will finish every bill stuck in negotiations
CommonWealth Beacon
Any bills that do not reach Gov. Maura Healey’s desk before the legislative term ends on January 5, 2027, wil…
Mass. advocates pledge to fight new HUD rule on immigrant households
CommonWealth Beacon
MASSACHUSETTS TENANT AND immigrant advocates are criticizing the Trump administration’s new rule requiring re…
Parent leaders hold our communities together. It’s time the state built a pathway to support them.
CommonWealth Beacon
Parent leaders need a pathway that connects their leadership to college and careers, and a direct line from t…
State energy and environment secretary leaving Healey administration
CommonWealth Beacon
The transition comes as energy costs are a top concern for residents, the state is struggling to maintain mom…
Gateway Cities and the market-rate housing debate
CommonWealth Beacon
This week on The Codcast, CommonWealth Beacon reporter Hallie Claflin is joined by Aaron Vega, president and …