Analysis: Don’t blame Adin Hill for Golden Knights bad loss to Dallas
The life of deadline writing is a chaotic one.
You could have a story written, ready to go at the buzzer, only for that team to somehow lose the game when leading by two with two minutes remaining.
That initial space was going to talk about how Adin Hill was the best player for the Vegas Golden Knights against the Dallas Stars on Tuesday. For 58 minutes, the goaltender was, in fact, that.
That should also be the case after the dust settled following Tuesday’s bizarre 4-3 overtime loss to Dallas, one where Hill went from being nine minutes away from a shutout, to being on the hook for a loss that he didn’t deserve.
“He’s been playing great all year,” defenesman Brayden McNabb said. “An unfortunate one we couldn’t do anything about, but he’s been rock solid and been good with the puck, making all the saves he needs to.”
Hill, now 7-2-2 on the season made 18 saves Tuesday. Some were big. Some were imperative in keeping Dallas off the scoreboard. He has looked nothing like last year’s version. So far, through, 11 starts, he’s been everything the Knights have needed.
First the save, followed by the play from Karlsson to prevent the wrap-around. https://t.co/b7FROudH9D
— Danny Webster (@DannyWebster21) November 18, 2026
Which is why social media is a wild place after the Knights lose, with fans blaming Hill for the two goals in the final 1:18 of regulation.
“I wouldn’t say we sneaked two points out of here. We were in a bad spot at the end,” Stars coach Glen Gulutzan said. “I thought they were a little better than us, and when you get two 6-on-5 goals, you got to be thankful.”
There was nothing that could have been done. McNabb said they could have done a better job in front of the net, but it was two fortuitous bounces that went Dallas’ way. On a night where goals were hard to come by, that’s what the Stars needed.
Some even criticized Hill’s try for the goalie goal with two minutes remaining — with the Knights leading by two goals.
Goaltenders have been going for goalie goals with a multi-goal lead since cavemen found fire. Because there was enough faith in the team defense from the first 58 minutes that gave Hill the chance to go for it.
Putting the blame on Hill when he was the one that put the Knights in position to win in the first place is a knee-jerk reaction that is mired in those who looked only at the box score.
If there’s blame to go around, you could put it on not finishing the job with the empty net. How Jack Eichel’s pass to a wide-open Mitch Marner on a 3-on-1 was well off the mark.
How the top line was ineffective for another game with the exception of Brett Howden’s goal that made it 3-1 in the third.
How the power play went 0-for-5 on a night where the top unit generated next to nothing dangerously.
There’s plenty of blame to go around, especially collective blame for what’s been the worst 48-hour stretch for the Knights in recent memory. They somehow one-upped the abysmal loss Sunday to the Vancouver Canucks with one that was well within their reach.
Just don’t point fingers at the goaltender.
“I see it as we played 58 minutes of real good hockey and didn’t finish the job,” coach Ryan Craig said. “They put pucks to the net, but we had opportunities to end the game or get the puck out in those situations, and we didn’t finish.”
Contact Danny Webster at [email protected]. Follow @DannyWebster21 on X.
Up next
Who: Stars at Golden Knights
When: 7 p.m. Thursday
Where: T-Mobile Arena
TV: ESPN+/Hulu
Radio: KVGS 107.9 FM
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
