County employers oppose proposed 24% rate increase for West Virginia public insurance plan

Kanawha County Sheriff Joey Crawford speaks to the West Virginia Public Employees Insurance Agency finance board Tuesday during a hearing about the agency’s proposals for fiscal 2028. (Photo by Lori Kersey/West Virginia Watch)
Representatives of local governments whose employees use West Virginia state health insurance coverage raised concerns Tuesday with a proposal to raise the rates for one plan by 24% in the coming fiscal year.
About 50 people attended a public hearing of the West Virginia Public Employees Insurance Agency finance board at the state Capitol Complex in Charleston, West Virginia, Tuesday evening. The meeting was one of six the board has held around the state this month to hear feedback about its proposals for the 2028 fiscal year, which starts in July 2027.
The finance board has proposed a modest aggregate premium increase of 2% for state workers and employers and a 4% aggregate increase for non-state workers in the gold, silver and bronze high deductible plans.
Medicare and non-Medicare retirees will not have premium increases in fiscal year 2028, according to PEIA’s proposal.
For but for non-state employees who participate in the gold high deductible health plan, the board proposes a 24% increase.
According to the board’s presentation, PEIA actuaries predict the non-state fund expenses will exceed premium revenues by around $10 million, mainly because of the gold high deductible plan’s poor performance.
If the trends continue, PEIA projects the non-state fund will finish 2027 with a reserve of around $20 million, which would be below its 10% minimum statutory reserve and its actuarial reserve requirement of $26.3 million.
PEIA director Brent Wolfingbarger said the plan is projected to finish the year with an “unsustainable” medical loss ratio of 119.4%, meaning the cost of medical claims exceeded premium revenue.
About 5,000 policy holders, amounting to 32% of nonstate employees enrolled in PEIA, are on the gold high deductible plan, he said.
“The poor financial performance of the non-state fund gold high deductible health plan is longstanding and has not improved despite past premium increases and benefit changes,” Wolfingbarger said. “Moreover, the number of both non-state policyholders and non-state members enrolled in the old high deductible plan have almost quadrupled since fiscal year 2021, which has substantially increased the non-state fund’s overall financial exposure.”
He said the 24% increase is necessary to “properly price the plan’s risk” according to its historical performance and to reduce the medical loss ratio.
With high deductible plans, policy holders pay less out of their paychecks in monthly premiums, and pay more out of pocket for medical costs like doctors visits.
Local government employers sometimes contribute to employees’ health savings accounts to offset those out-of-pocket costs, a practice that Wolfingbarger discouraged. Officials said funding the health savings accounts lead to employees going to the doctor more often, which contributes to rising costs and the plan’s poor performance.
Kanawha County Commissioner Natalie Tennant said increasing the rate for the gold high deductible by a “staggering” 24% this year is unfair.
“It’s our county employees who participate in PEIA in that very plan,” she told the finance board. “Yes, some folks were saying, ‘Who has that plan?’ It’s Kanawha County. We’re looking at 24% across county government and our participating independent agencies.”
Including Kanawha County, Kanawha County Metro 911 and the Kanawha County Ambulance Authority, about 600 workers use the gold high deductible plan, county finance director Kim Fleck said.
The plan saves money for the county and for employees, Fleck said. The county has funded the employee health savings accounts for the plans in lieu of offering pay increases, she said.
Tennant said the gold high deductible plan saved the county nearly $1 million. Kanawha County officials disagreed with Wolfingbarger that funding employees’ health savings accounts leads to them going to the doctor more often.
“We’re not encouraging them. We’re trying to just offer something a little extra to the employees because we can’t do things like the raises,” Fleck said.
Tennant asked the board to consider other solutions before implementing the rate increase, or consider implementing it in phases.
Kanawha Sheriff Joey Crawford echoed Tennant’s suggestion to spread out the proposed increase. He said PEIA rate increases make it difficult to recruit and retain deputies.
“They apply, we tell them what their benefit packages are. We tell them what their salaries are, and we sit down and explain to them we want the best and the brightest. We want you to come to work for us. But then I have to go in and say, ‘last year our premium increase was 24%.’ That hurts,” Crawford said.
The PEIA finance board is expected to take up its proposals for 2028 at its December meeting, planned for 1 p.m., Dec. 3
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
