Commentary: ‘More voices, better choices’ could counter extremism in both parties, Oregon election shows

A person drops off their ballot at a drop box location near the Multnomah County Election Office in Portland, Oregon, on Tuesday, Nov. 3, 2026. (Photo by Jordan Gale/Oregon Capital Chronicle)
For more than a decade, election reformers in Oregon, myself included, have been trying to reverse the increasing polarization that has overtaken our two-party system. And it looked like we had the people on our side. Partisanship had become a dirty word for a majority of Oregonians, who regularly told pollsters they favored having more choices in our elections in order to rein in the extremes of two-party politics.
Then we witnessed the most partisan outcomes in the most binary election this century, not only nationally but in Oregon as well. And I cheered the results.
What does this election tell us about the strategies that will work best for electoral reform here in Oregon? Should we be focusing on more choices…or more voices?
The case for more choices seems wrong-headed now, at least in our general elections. That’s when we need fewer and better choices to provide clarity for the voters and consensus for our governing institutions.
But to get to that place of better choices, we need more voices in our primary elections.
I’ll offer a few examples from other states before getting into some unique particulars in Oregon.
There was a new kind of partisanship in elections this year, buoyed by the rejection of the most extreme demonstration of unbridled power, cruelty and corruption by one party in our lifetimes.
Candidates with a “D” next to their names benefited less from their party’s agenda and more from the fact that that they were the only alternative to the scarlet “R.” This was a healthy development, especially since the winning Democrats represented a wider spectrum of political views for their party but shared the common purpose of repudiating the extremes of Trumpism.
Voters saw this as a binary election. Where they were offered the “more choices” model with ranked choice voting, as in the races for senators and governors in Maine and Alaska, the top initial vote getters prevailed no matter which party crowded the ballot with other candidates. The results would not have been different in a simple D vs. R matchup.
Results in Oregon tell the same story, with new lessons to be learned about closed party primaries and nonpartisan elections.
Minor parties were largely irrelevant in Oregon’s general election races. And, unlike the gubernatorial race in 2022, no small “i” independent candidate appeared on the ballot in any race for a partisan state office. We did see multiple examples of candidates with “Democrat, Working Families, Independent” on their ballot line and one with “Independent, Republican.” But those minor party endorsements didn’t seem to matter. Results in most cases reflected the margins in major party registrations.
In several of the Democratic Party’s primaries for the Legislature, however, progressive candidates shifted the party farther left in blue districts. And, it was telling that they did so with the backing of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), which is not a registered political party. The DSA has chosen to compete for influence within the Democrats’ closed party primaries rather than within the broader electorate.
Lesson learned: In partisan elections, the only viable path to electing candidates runs through the major parties, not around them.
But there was a different dynamic in nonpartisan races, where candidates far to the left of their voters gained tactical advantage in elections without party labels.
In deep-blue Portland, the DSA-aligned candidates have been more open to debating the need to reverse “late-stage capitalism” and defund the police, since it takes only 25%+1 to win or retain a seat on the nonpartisan City Council. But in nonpartisan races for the Washington County Commission, the City of Hillsboro and the City of McMinnville, winning candidates aligned with the DSA downplayed or ignored the organization’s ideological policies and focused instead on local issues like data centers.
That can be smart tactical politics. But when candidates owe allegiance to an organization’s platform, like that of the national DSA, the outcomes of their elections can begin to mimic the worst practices that plague our established parties today — hidden agendas, special interest vetoes and inflexible governance.
Both the Democratic and Republican parties in Oregon have been defending a system that has shut out the largest group of voters in the state — those who reject affiliation with any party.
These “nonaffiliated” voters overwhelmingly sided with the Democrats in this election. But that won’t always be the case. And as long as partisan primaries remain closed, they will allow non-party political organizations, whether DSA on the left or MAGA-aligned groups on the right, to gain outsized influence in their nomination processes and push them further to extremes.
This year’s elections make clear that enabling nonaffiliated voters to vote in our major party primaries has become the only viable path forward for electoral reform. Nonpartisan primaries or “jungle primaries” (where all candidates compete on a single ballot) won’t help to cure what ails our system of governance and may even make things worse.
The more participation from voters at the front end of our electoral system, the more the major parties will advance candidates to our general elections who will appeal to a broader electorate. And the more the major parties learn to win elections and govern with agendas that reflect majority opinions, the more we can begin to reverse the polarization of a hollowed-out, two-party system.
Giving non-affiliated voters a say in our major party primaries is the last “straw man” standing among the many ideas that election reformers have debated over the past decade. It’s time to give it new life.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
