Lawsuit: Farmers’ co-op CEO collected millions in unauthorized pay, benefits

A newly filed lawsuit alleges the Landus farmers' cooperative bankrolled this $10 million ocean-front home in Florida for the co-op's former CEO. (Main photo by Getty Images; inset photo via Google Earth)
An agricultural cooperative representing more than 5,500 farmers in Iowa and surrounding states is suing the organization’s former top executives, in part for allegedly routing $280,000 to the mistress of the group’s former CEO.
The lawsuit also claims the farmers’ co-op paid for “a small army of full-time personal assistants to fluff (the CEO’s) pillows, tuck his heated blanket into his bed, and lay out his slippers and robe.”
Landus Cooperative, an agricultural cooperative owned by Midwestern farmers, is suing Matthew Carstens, who served as the group’s president and chief executive officer from 2020 to 2025, and his wife, Shanda, in Polk County District Court.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.
Also named as defendants are Landus’ former executive vice president and general counsel, Stephen Nielsen, and Landus’ former board chairman, Matthew Chambers.
The lawsuit accuses Matthew Carstens of breaching his fiduciary duties to Landus and unlawfully enriching himself and his family at Landus’ expense. It alleges Nielsen and Chambers helped Carstens carry out his scheme and, in the process, deceived the organization’s board of directors.
The defendants are alleged to have intentionally kept the full board of directors from understanding “key facts about Mr. Carstens’ compensation and benefits,” while Carstens and Nielsen directed employees to steer unauthorized payments and benefits to the Carstens.
In addition, Carstens and Nielsen are alleged to have hired full-time employees “to serve the Carstens family in their personal matters,” and of hiring “as a Landus consultant the woman with whom Mr. Carstens was having an affair, paying her $280,000 without evidence of anything more than de minimis services rendered to Landus.”
During his time as president and CEO, Carstens’ base salary allegedly surged from $625,000 to more than $4.4 million per year — an amount that was supplemented with hundreds of thousands of dollars in bonuses.
According to the lawsuit, employment agreements drafted by Nielsen committed Landus to paying $10 million for a house the Carstens used in Florida, plus $3.5 million to build his primary residence in Grimes, Iowa. Those agreements were never shown to, nor approved by, the full board, the lawsuit alleges.
Staff told to fluff cushions, tuck in CEO’s blanket
The lawsuit asserts that Carstens would typically raise an issue in a board meeting, Nielsen would include in the board-meeting minutes a very general description of the issue and discussion, and then Nielsen would order Landus employees to take action far beyond what the board had authorized. In some cases, the lawsuit claims, Nielsen would draft an amendment to Carstens’ employment agreement that would “stretch the board’s discussion or authorization beyond all recognition.”
As an example, the lawsuit cites a March 2024 decision by the board to pay for individuals to help Carstens host Landus-related events at his Iowa home. Carstens then had Landus hire at least four full-time workers to serve his family, in one instance as the family’s personal wellness doctor. The lawsuit states Matthew Carstens’ wife, Shanda, allegedly proposed job titles such as “personal wellness assistant” for those employees to, in her words, “avoid labeling them house manager or personal assistants.”
The Carstens also are alleged to have sent one or more of their personal assistants to their Landus-funded Florida home days in advance of their arrival, to buy groceries and alcohol, also billed to Landus, for trips that were purely personal in nature.
Those workers allegedly cooked for the Carstens, cleaned their home and did yard work. One of the personal assistant’s checklists instructs the staff to place Shanda Carstens’ Ritz crackers and mini-can of ginger ale on the table between the recliners in their bedroom, and to make sure “all cushions are fluffed” in the living room, bar and patio area. Other tasks include: “Place Matt’s robe at the end side of his bed, and his slippers on the floor by the robe… Make sure Matt’s side of the heated blanket is tucked in.”
On one occasion in 2024, the lawsuit claims, the Carstens decided to use the Landus corporate jet to fly their entire family from Iowa to Florida for a week-long celebration of their daughter’s 21st birthday. “No board member was ever made aware of any of these facts at the time,” the lawsuit asserts.
“In mid-2024, as Mr. Carstens continued to cause Landus to pay a small army of full-time personal assistants to fluff Mr. Carstens’ pillows, tuck his heated blanket into his bed, and lay out his slippers and robe, Landus’s financials started to trend downward.“
– Lawsuit filed by Landus Cooperative
As part of that birthday celebration, the lawsuit alleges, one of the personal assistants worked 80 hours in one week. A written list of tasks assigned to that individual, included as an exhibit to the lawsuit, details the time that assistant was to spend preparing meals and cleaning, as well as working until 2 a.m. “bar hopping in St. Pete” – a task that entailed driving the Carstens children and their friends to and from various bars.
Matthew Carstens also caused Landus to pay $904,000 to The Matt & Shanda Carstens Family Foundation for a “performance center” known as “the barn,” to be built on the Carstens family’s residential property, where farmers would receive physical and mental wellness services.
The performance center project was later abandoned after Polk County denied a zoning variance for its construction, but the foundation never returned any of Landus’s money, the lawsuit alleges.
At one point, the lawsuit claims, members of the board’s executive committee asked to see the amendments to Carstens’ employment agreement so they could understand his full compensation, but were told by Nielsen they “did not need to see them.”
Lawsuit: Carstens admitted to affair with consultant
With regard to the consultant with whom Carstens was allegedly having an affair, the lawsuit claims that in March 2025, Carstens admitted to the board that he had an extramarital affair with a woman Landus hired, at his direction, in 2020 to act as an independent contractor.
Under the terms of the hiring agreement, Landus was to pay the woman’s limited liability corporation $33.65 an hour for services that would be detailed in weekly reports to Landus. No such reports were ever provided, the lawsuit claims.
The limited liability corporation was paid a total of $180,000 for 40 hours of work per week from October 2020 through March 2023, plus $100,000 in severance pay. “No one at Landus has been able to confirm that the LLC performed any services of value to Landus beyond a de minimis data-migration effort,” the lawsuit states.
“In mid-2024,” the lawsuit states, “as Mr. Carstens continued to cause Landus to pay a small army of
full-time personal assistants to fluff Mr. Carstens’ pillows, tuck his heated blanket into his bed, and lay out his slippers and robe, Landus’s financials started to trend downward.”
Matthew Carstens’ relationship with Landus began to unravel in late 2024 when financial pressures forced the co-op to lay off 10% of its workforce. Days later, the lawsuit claims, Carstens sought to increase his own compensation, which at the time included $1.7 million in base salary plus up to $300,000 in bonuses, tickets to Iowa State University sporting events, a suite at the Wells Fargo Arena in Des Moines, payments for the $10 million Florida house and the $3.5 million Grimes house, and personal travel on a Landus-owned private plane.
Carstens’ base salary was then increased to $2.4 million per year, and several weeks later, in March 2025, his employment agreement was amended again to provide a total salary of $4.4 million. That agreement also included a $550,000 “fulfillment bonus” if Carstens stayed at Landus through March 8, 2025 — a date that had already passed before that particular amendment was even drafted, the lawsuit asserts.
By that time, the lawsuit states, tensions at Landus were high, particularly because board members were frustrated by a lack of clarity regarding Matthew Carstens’ total compensation. Carstens resigned on April 4, 2025, with Landus agreeing to pay him $1.5 million in return for a release of any claims Carstens might make against Landus.
When Landus entered into that severance agreement, the lawsuit claims, the co-op and its board “did not know the full extent to which Mr. Carstens had used his position as CEO and Landus’s assets for the personal benefit of himself and his family.”
The lawsuit seeks unspecified damages for fraud, unjust enrichment, conversion, breach of fiduciary duty, civil conspiracy and other alleged wrongdoing. The defendants have yet to file a response to the lawsuit and could not be reached for comment Wednesday.
In a written statement that coincided with the filing of the lawsuit, Landus said “pursuing this lawsuit is about living out our ‘Integrity in Action’ core value, which means doing what’s right for our farmer-owners and our employees even when it’s not easy. Our employees are deeply committed to the Landus mission and the farmers we serve. We are building a culture where employees feel safe, equipped and empowered to deliver the very best to our members.”
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
