Mayor: 'Policy of being fair' used to reexamine claims against city
HOUSTON, Texas (KTRK) -- After Kimberly Ezike was rear-ended by a Houston police officer in 2024, she said her car was damaged and she was injured, but the city refused to compensate her for it.
13 Investigates first reported Ezike's story last week amid the mayor's promise to re-examine all claims against the City of Houston that had previously been denied over the last few years.
We spoke with Houston Mayor John Whitmire this week about how that review is going and learned, so far, no claims have been reversed.
"Oftentimes people will work with us. Sometimes they won't," Whitmire told 13 Investigates. "Sometimes their cars get damaged in an accident that they brought on themselves, so, you know, it's a balancing act. Be fair with those that have damaged property and be fair to the taxpayers of Houston."
Ezike told police she saw an officer with their lights on behind her, but that she wasn't able to get out of his way. A crash report shows the officer hit her from behind. Her car was pushed into a pole and Ezike said she broke her leg.
The officer received a one-day suspension for his role in the crash, according to records from the City of Houston.
Ezike, who said she was in between homes and living out of her car at the time, submitted a claim to the city for compensation. Her claim was denied a month after she submitted it.
"If I hit one of them, especially from behind, I clearly would be responsible, so they're telling me they're not responsible due to whatever, you know, they are the government or whatever else. But no, that's not excusable because you hurt me," Ezike said.
SEE ALSO: City denies claim of woman HPD crashed into, sells her car for $10
Ezike said concerns about how her case was handled were renewed after a high-profile claim gained attention this fall.
For that case, a University of Houston student's vehicle was sprayed with bullets and damaged in Highland Village in July when police opened fire on a suspect in a case unrelated to the student.
The student filed a claim with the city for reimbursement just like Ezike did, and hers was denied too.
Ultimately, after media attention, the city revisited the UH student's case and gave her a new car, leading Whitmire to announce in September that every claim filed against the city since July 2023 would be reviewed.
SEE ALSO: City of Houston gives new car to UH student whose vehicle was hit by police gunfire
Whitmire's office told us in a statement that the review is ongoing but no claims had been reversed.
13 Investigates asked Whitmire in person this week if the city is using different criteria when re-examining claims for a second time.
"It's a policy of being fair, and you know, that's - it's not so subjective. It's often based on the facts, the incident and what the parties are looking for. Certainly the city has a responsibility," Whitmire said "It's pretty much a change in policy. I think it's been reported, in years past, before I got to City Hall, it was just a clear 'no.' But I'm a much more compassionate mayor."
The mayor acknowledged that he saw 13 Investigates' story about Ezike's claim, but the city has not given any indication that it intends to reverse her claim.
Contact 13 Investigates
Have a tip? A problem to solve? Send a tip below. If you don't have a photo or document to include, just hit 'skip upload' and send the details. (On mobile? You can open our form by tapping here.)
Copyright © 2026 KTRK-TV. All Rights Reserved.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
