Outgoing Corporation Commissioners vote to OK Tucson rate hike

The Arizona Corporation Commission voted on Nov. 17 to approve a 10% rate hike to the customers of Tucson Electric Power. (Photo by Dana DiFilippo/New Jersey Monitor)
Tucson residents will see their annual energy costs increase by nearly $200, after the Arizona Corporation Commission greenlit a rate increase request from Tucson Electric Power.
Following an eight hour long meeting on Nov. 17, the Republican-majority commission voted 4-1 to approve a 10% rate increase for the company, which provides services for more than 450,000 Tucsonans. The increase is set to go into effect in December and is estimated to result in $13 more a month for the average TEP customer. The electric company originally pushed for a 14% increase, which it said was necessary to continue providing services and recoup the cost of a $1.7 billion investment in electrical infrastructure.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.
The commission’s approval drew backlash from Democratic leaders and activists alike. Attorney General Kris Mayes issued a statement decrying the decision, calling it a “bad deal” for ratepayers and lambasting commissioners for putting shareholders above Tucsonans.
“Every Arizonan should know the ACC decided to make it easier for TEP’s investors to earn a profit instead of siding with ratepayers struggling to make ends meet,” she wrote.
Mayes’ office made multiple recommendations to the commission last month that would have taken a stricter approach to how TEP uses the money raised from Tucsonans. The commission rejected many of those suggestions during the Nov. 17 meeting, but agreed to require the electric company to include notices on customer bills explaining how the rate increase will affect future costs based on seasonal energy use; to adopt a policy promising not to disconnect customers during very warm or very cold periods; and to create a report analyzing costs when large load customers like data centers are connected to ensure that Tucsonans aren’t footing their energy bills.
Chris Harto, the manager of energy policy at Consumer Reports, an advocacy group that helped mobilize local opposition to the rate increase request, said that the commission isn’t protecting or responding to the needs of Arizonans.
“The current Commission is not sufficiently responsive to the needs of the public on affordability, and will leave hard working Tucson area residents paying a lot more to keep their lights on and AC running,” Harto said, in a written statement. “There is much more that Arizona utilities and the Commission can and should be doing to prioritize low-cost solutions to keep electric rates affordable for Arizonans.”
Harto was particularly critical of the commission’s approval of an expedited funding plan and a last-minute move to let the electric company charge customers a fee based on the inflation-adjusted value of infrastructure that has already been built. Generally, companies charge customers for the original infrastructure costs, not their current value.
“Imagine if your mortgage company was allowed to add extra fees to your home loan every year based on how much the value of your home had increased,” Harto said. “That’s essentially what the Commission is now allowing TEP to do.”
Along with that new cost for consumers, the commission also OK’d the company’s annual rate adjustment mechanism — a plan under which TEP will seek annual rate increases instead of undergoing a formal hearing process every few years. The commission will still need to vote on yearly requests and sometimes those rates will remain the same as the previous year, but the goal is to shorten the time between rate increases. The last time TEP sought a higher rate was in 2022. That case ultimately netted the electric company a 9.5% increase the next year.
The electric company has touted the plan, known as ARAM, as the best way to incrementally raise costs for ratepayers and reduce sticker shock, but critics argue the expedited process only makes it easier for TEP to charge more while at the same time avoiding much of the public input.
Two of the commission members who voted to increase energy costs for Tucsonans, Chair Nick Myers and Commissioner Kevin Thompson, were voted out by Arizonans in the Nov. 3 midterm election. And the Democrats who will replace them, Jonathon Hill and Clara Pratte, may help foil TEP’s future rate increase requests.
The pair will be in the minority on the commission’s board, but Republican Lea Márquez Peterson, who alone voted against the rate increase on Nov. 17, is considered a swing vote. Peterson’s opposition was largely due to the ARAM plan, which she said left insufficient time for the commission and others to review rate increase requests.
Hill said that he was discouraged that the commissioners didn’t take into account the financial impact on Tucsonans. Both Hill and Pratte campaigned on a promise to address the affordability crisis that was top of mind for voters, a strategy that helped deliver the party wins up and down the ballot. Hill added that he believes the commission’s approval of TEP’s rate increase likely forecasts how it will decide the fate of an upcoming case. Next month, the commission will consider whether to grant a rate increase request from Arizona Public Service, which is requesting a 14% hike that could lead to a monthly increase of $20 for the company’s 1.4 million customers.
While Hill and Pratte won’t be sworn into office until next year, the two will get a chance to weigh in on the yearly rate increase requests from TEP under its ARAM plan and any future requests from APS. Hill said that he will consider those requests with an eye towards what is best for Arizonans.
“I would look very hard at the justifications for further increasing rates from either TEP or APS after such a long large one-time increase and really want to make sure that Arizona customers are truly getting a fair deal,” he said.
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
