Two of Alaska’s legislative races are within five votes after ranked choice tabulations

Rep. Kevin McCabe, R-Big Lake, talks with Sen. Bill Wielechowski, D-Anchorage (right) during a joint session of the state House and Senate on Tuesday, May 7, 2024. At left is Rep. Zack Fields, D-Anchorage. (Photo by James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
One Republican member of the Alaska House of Representatives is losing his re-election bid by three votes, and another is winning by four after the Alaska Division of Elections conducted ranked choice runoff calculations Wednesday.
According to Wednesday’s preliminary results, independents have won 7 of the 40 seats in the state House, Democrats have won 17 and Republicans won 16.
The state-level results appear to reflect the “blue tsunami” of Democratic-leaning outcomes in elections nationwide this month.
Two years ago, Republicans won 21 seats in the state House, and the swing means the House will remain controlled by an emboldened coalition majority of Republicans, Democrats and independents.
The races will be certified Nov. 25, and recounts are possible afterward.
The two tight elections — both in the Matanuska-Susitna Borough — were among a handful of close races decided by Wednesday’s ranked choice tabulation.
In Alaska, all candidates for a particular office run together. The top four vote-getters in the August primary advance to the November general election, and voters are asked to rank the candidates in order of preference.
If one candidate gets at least 50% of the first-choice votes, they win. If none reach that threshold, the lowest finisher is eliminated, and votes for them go to their voters’ second choices. The eliminations continue until only two candidates are left, and the person with the most votes wins.
In the state Senate, where 10 of 20 seats were on the November ballot, Republicans still hold 11 seats, Democrats hold nine, and there is one independent — Sen.-elect Bryce Edgmon, I-Dillingham, whose election was confirmed by Wednesday’s tabulation. Edgmon replaces longtime Democratic Sen. Lyman Hoffman of Dillingham.
The Senate will be governed by an 11-person coalition majority, a smaller version of the coalition that has controlled it since 2023.
All of the state’s closest legislative elections were in the Matanuska-Susitna Borough, where Democratic voters played an influential role in races with multiple Republicans.
In House District 30, which covers the western Mat-Su and the Denali Borough, Republican candidate Doug Massie is leading Republican Rep. Kevin McCabe by three votes.
McCabe led Massie in first-choice votes, but voters who backed Democratic candidate Sandra Loomis strongly favored Massie once Loomis was eliminated: Almost a fifth of her votes transferred to Massie, giving him a narrow lead.
Next door, in the eastern Mat-Su’s House District 29, Republican Rep. Garret Nelson leads Republican challenger Steve Menard by four votes.
Nelson led Menard by fewer than 50 first-choice votes, but unlike in House District 30, the few Democratic-leaning voters who ranked at least one of the Republicans split evenly between them, allowing Nelson to preserve his advantage.
A similar pattern happened in House District 28, covering Wasilla. Republican Rep. Elexie Moore trailed Republican challenger Stephen Wright in first-choice votes but finished ahead of Democratic candidate Kit Kennedy. When Kennedy was eliminated, most of her supporters chose to rank neither Republican. A small plurality preferred Moore, but not enough to erase Wright’s advantage. He recorded a 46-vote win as of Wednesday night.
In Alaska, the state will pay for a recount if the margin is 20 or fewer votes, or less than 0.5% of the total of the votes for the two closest candidates. The recount must be requested by a candidate or 10 qualified voters in the area covered by the election.
McCabe said by text message that he intends to request a recount. It was not immediately clear whether Menard would do so.
Among the Mat-Su’s closely contested state Senate seats, Republican Sen. George Rauscher — appointed by Gov. Mike Dunleavy to replace Sen. Shelley Hughes, R-Palmer, after her resignation to run for governor — won election on his own merits in a ranked choice runoff.
Dunleavy also appointed Sen. Cathy Tilton, R-Wasilla, to replace Republican Sen. Mike Shower after he resigned to run for lieutenant governor. Tilton lost a ranked choice runoff to fellow Republican Ryan Berry by 467 votes.
Unlike in the close state House races, the elimination of Republican candidate Zane Vrvilo was enough to give Berry the edge; the subsequent elimination of Democratic candidate Pat Chesbro increased Berry’s lead via transfer votes.
Elsewhere in the state:
- Sen.-elect Louise Stutes, R-Kodiak, was elected to replace Sen. Gary Stevens, R-Kodiak, in a three-way ranked choice runoff. Stutes had 49.9% of the first-choice votes, just barely short of the margin needed to avoid the runoff against two other Republicans.
- Independent Brent Johnson defeated Republican Rep. Sarah Vance, R-Homer in a head-to-head race that was unresolved until Wednesday because of late-counted absentee ballots. Of 10,128 votes, Johnson defeated Vance by 59 according to the preliminary total.
- In Anchorage, Republican Rep. Julie Coulombe defeated Democratic challenger Danni Hall by 131 votes out of 8,499 cast in House District 11. Democrats had spent heavily to boost Hall’s campaign.
- Also in Anchorage, Democratic candidate Denny Wells confirmed his victory over Republican Rep. Mia Costello, winning in House District 15 by 669 votes in uncertified results Wednesday.
- In Eagle River, Republican Rep. Jamie Allard won re-election in a four-way ranked choice runoff election that saw her leading in first-choice votes.
- For the other Eagle River state House district, former Republican Rep. Ken McCarty won the election to replace retiring Republican Rep. Dan Saddler by defeating moderate Republican challenger Gina Wall. Though there were only two candidates, ranked choice tabulation was still used because neither had more than 50% of the vote, there were more than 100 write-in votes, and McCarty was leading Wall by just 19 first-choice ballots. The tabulation confirmed McCarty’s victory.
- Rep. DeLena Johnson, R-Palmer, won re-election after a three-way ranked choice tabulation. She had led in first-choice votes.
- North Pole Republican Rep. Mike Prax was re-elected after a three-way ranked choice runoff in House District 33. Republican challenger Barbara Haney was eliminated first, and Prax defeated independent Pepper McFarland in the final matchup.
- Democratic candidate Evelynn Trefon won the race to replace Edgmon in House District 37. She had 58.8% in the final tabulation, ahead of Republican candidate Brenda Wilson.
- In House District 38, incumbent Democratic Rep. Nellie Unangiq Jimmie was re-elected after a ranked choice runoff. She had 58.2% in the final tabulation, ahead of second-place finisher and former Democratic Rep. CJ McCormick.
- Democratic incumbent Rep. Neal Foster, who had 49% of the first choice votes in House District 39, won in ranked choice tabulation. Independent candidate Tyler Ivanoff was second.
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
