Michigan Court of Appeals affirms unconstitutionality of abortion limitations

A sign at the Michigan Pride rally in Lansing on June 26, 2022. (Photo by Laina G. Stebbins/Michigan Advance)
In a ruling issued Tuesday, a panel of judges on the Michigan Court of Appeals unanimously ruled that limitations on abortion procedures within Michigan’s public health code are unconstitutional, a decision that was celebrated by reproductive rights advocates.
The specific mandated limitations in question are a 24-hour mandatory waiting period, uniform informed consent requirements, a physician participation mandate and mandatory screening for coercion.
The suit, which was first heard in the Court of Claims, was brought by the Northland Family Planning Center, alleged that these provisions in the law “unconstitutionally burdened the right to abortion without serving the limited compelling purpose of protecting the health of an individual seeking care, that each provision was inconsistent with accepted clinical standards of practice and evidence-based medicine, that the provisions imposed requirements that intruded on the autonomous decision making of patients, and that the provisions discriminated in the protection and enforcement of the right to reproductive freedom.”
In the decision from the Court of Claims, which was issued in May 2025, the court decided that the mandatory 24-hour waiting period, the uniform mandatory consent requirement and the physician mandate were unconstitutional and issued a permanent injunction enjoining enforcement of those provisions.
Planned Parenthood of Michigan to close three clinics after funding cuts
However, the lower court did not rule that the mandatory screening for coercion was unconstitutional, arguing that it is neutral on the face of the law. The Court of Appeals, on the other hand, ruled that because the statute prohibits only coercion to abort, not coercion to become pregnant or continue a pregnancy, it “risks operating in a manner that discriminates against individuals who seek to exercise the full range of reproductive choices guaranteed by our Constitution.”
The decision goes on to say that the Court of Claims did not fully interrogate the question at hand, “namely, whether the law, as applied, impermissibly discriminates in the enforcement of reproductive rights by creating a disparate impact on those who do not wish to continue a pregnancy, or who are coerced to become pregnant. The absence of such analysis renders the lower court’s decision incomplete with respect to the constitutional issues presented.”
As such the court remanded the decision to the Court of Claims, which “must determine whether the statutory framework, both in its language and in its application, comports with the constitutional mandate of equal protection in the enforcement of the right to reproductive freedom” and must complete “a searching examination not only of the statutory text, but also of the real-world consequences of its enforcement.”
Reproductive rights advocates, including Planned Parenthood of Michigan President and CEO Paula Thornton Greear, welcomed the decision.
“Michigan voters decided that decisions about pregnancy belong to the person who is pregnant, and this ruling holds the state to that,” Thornton Greear said in a press release issued Wednesday. “These laws had nothing to do with patient health, because they delayed care, forced people to read state-written material no clinician would hand a patient for any other kind of care, and limited who could provide that care — and now the courts have said so twice.”
Thornton Greear also encouraged the incoming Democratic-controlled Legislature, which will convene in January, to update the laws in statute, instead of relying on court decisions to prevent the enforcement of the limitations — a priority that she has previously called on legislators to take up in the new legislative session.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
