The number of unaffiliated county clerks in Colorado is on the rise
Eleven of Colorado’s elected county clerks next year will have no political party affiliation as a surge of unaffiliated clerks claimed victory in this month’s election, more than doubling the ranks of unaffiliated clerks since the 2022 election.
In 2022, five unaffiliated county clerk candidates ran for election, according to campaign finance filings. Four of them won. This month, all 11 unaffiliated candidates on the ballot won. Only one had an opponent.
In total, 12 of the 64 counties in Colorado will have clerks who are unaffiliated next year.
In a state where voters with no political affiliation outnumber Democrats and Republicans, more county clerks aligned with no political party are overseeing elections, marriage licenses, motor vehicle registrations and the filing of recording documents.
The upsurge comes as state and national elections have become more politicized over the past decade. While the newly elected clerks — who ran on the belief that they should be selected on the basis of their qualifications, not political party — may not have aimed to push back against political pressure, their election may signal voters’ interest in protecting the state’s election process from partisan influence.
Becky Close, the former Gypsum town clerk, was appointed to be the Eagle County clerk in 2025 after applying to fill a vacancy created when clerk Regina O’Brien, a Democrat, resigned. Close ran as an unaffiliated candidate this year to stay on as clerk and won.
“I do feel that an increase in unaffiliated clerks creates a leadership dynamic that is more representative of the people electing us to office,” Close said.
The Broomfield city and county clerk, Crystal Clemens, is also unaffiliated, but was appointed, as all clerks are under Broomfield’s charter.
Turnover could be a factor in the rise to power of clerks with no political party affiliation. Three of the unaffiliated clerks elected this month for the first time were previously appointed to fill vacancies. In Colorado and other Western states, many clerks have left their positions early amid increased pressure and harassment following unproven claims of election fraud after the 2020 presidential election.
Most of Colorado’s 64 counties have eliminated term limits for clerks, which has allowed clerks to serve for many terms. When they’re replaced now, it could be more likely that unaffiliated candidates are selected simply because they are being pulled from a larger pool of unaffiliated voters, said Routt County Clerk Jenny Thomas, one of the unaffiliated clerks elected this year.
Unaffiliated candidates must petition onto ballot
While municipal elections in Colorado are nonpartisan, elections for county officials are generally partisan, though there may be some exceptions for counties that have home rule, said Landon Mascareñaz, executive director of Courageous Colorado, which describes itself as a “cross-partisan movement” aimed at improving elections and democracy.
But in meetings the group has held around the state, many voters have questioned why it’s necessary to have local officials aligned with a political party, he said.
“Colorado has one of the most polarized legislatures in the country and as that continues to accelerate I think people are trying to find their own path outside the two-party structure,” he said.
Running as an unaffiliated is more work, though.
Unaffiliated candidates have to collect signatures to get on the ballot, whereas candidates affiliated with a political party can make the ballot through the caucus and assembly process. Additionally, unaffiliated candidates don’t have a party contributing money or other help to their campaigns.
La Plata County Clerk and Recorder Tiffany Lee switched to unaffiliated from Republican in 2020, mainly in response to growing political division in the country.
She thought about making the leap for several years. Lee said she was upset when some good incumbent candidates for other offices lost their positions in 2018 because of partisanship.
“I truly believe that we need to not have parties be such the driving force in our decision making,” said Lee.
She also doesn’t think party affiliation plays a role in county-level administrative jobs, as it does in positions that create laws, regulations or policies. However, she firmly believes clerks should be elected, not appointed.
The unaffiliated clerks who will be in office in 2027 include all four of those who won in 2022 — Thomas, Lee, Ladonna Jaramillo in San Juan County and Erica Vigil in Huerfano County.
Two other incumbents who were reelected ran as unaffiliated candidates after previously running as party candidates.
Madene “Beth” Zilla was elected as a Republican clerk in Phillips County before running unaffiliated this year, according to campaign finance records. Bent County’s Lynda Moss ran as an unaffiliated candidate after first being elected as a Democrat in 2018. She became unaffiliated last year, she said.
Besides Close, the Eagle County clerk, there were two other unaffiliated incumbents who ran for the first time after being appointed to their positions — Kurt Dilsaver in Sedgwick County and Damon Todd in Ouray County.
Incoming unaffiliated Dolores County Clerk Shilo Schultz is a newcomer. In Clear Creek County, the unaffiliated candidate, Ursula “Uchi” Cruzalegui, won a tight race against Democrat Lisa Manifold.
Thomas, who will serve as the president of the Colorado County Clerks Association next year, has always been unaffiliated. She worked for about a decade in the Routt County clerk’s office before being appointed in 2022 to replace former clerk Kim Bonner, who retired. (Bonner served four terms as a Democrat but became unaffiliated ahead of the 2020 election partly to boost confidence in the election system amid the contentious presidential election.)
Thomas said she’s never been a “political kind of gal” and thinks most problems can be solved by borrowing from a range of political views.
“I just think that the answer to most things and problems are somewhere in the middle,” said Thomas, who noted that members of the clerks association are used to collaborating regardless of party affiliation.
After winning another term, Lee said she now wants to explore possible legislation to make it easier for unaffiliated candidates to run. She wants to learn how other states, like Oregon, have opened up the political process more to them.
“We need to start now really digging in,” she said.
Type of Story: Analysis
Based on factual reporting, although it incorporates the expertise of the journalist and may offer interpretations and conclusions.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
