Before federal indictments, State Auditor left WV education leader in dark about schools’ money

Inside a classroom in Bridgeview Elementary in South Charleston, West Virginia. (Lexi Browning | West Virginia Watch)
Amid intense scrutiny of State Auditor Mark Hunt’s actions, the state education department can’t get clear answers — or even a response — about how the Auditor’s Office is handling delinquent property taxes owed to schools.
Over the last decade, a school fund dedicated to staff development — like helping teachers improve their instructional skills — has received on average $520,000 in surplus funds from delinquent property sales across the state. The process is outlined in state code.
Hunt was indicted this week by a federal grand jury on allegations he was involved in a property stealing scheme within his state office. Prior to federal indictments, Hunt’s office had faced scrutiny for hiring a state senator for contract work, an Auditor’s Office employee testing lobbying rules, irregularities in tax sales and a potential conflict of interest with a used car lot.
In April, West Virginia Department of Education staff met with the Auditor Office’s staff to discuss education officials’ concern about money legally owed to the school fund.
But State Schools Superintendent Michele Blatt still had numerous questions and concerns.
She sent a letter to Hunt in July laying out several issues. Among Blatt’s requests, she asked for itemized checks and dates of surplus property funds that were ripe to be transmitted to the school fund.
Hunt’s response: a ghosting.
“ … At this time, there has been no response to those questions, nor the letter dated July 9, 2026,” Christy Day, education department communicators director, said on Nov 16.
On Wednesday, a spokesperson for the Auditor’s Office said in an email, “We are still formulating our response to Superintendent Blatt’s July 9 letter.”
“As it happens, our office recently received WVDE’s annual request to credit this year’s surplus proceeds to the General School Fund, totaling $506,875.10. Those funds have been transferred,” wrote Madlyn Alqutub, a multimedia specialist for the Auditor’s Office.
There are calls from Gov. Patrick Morrisey and House Speaker Roger Hanshaw for Hunt to resign or he will face swift impeachment proceedings.
Hunt said he is innocent of what’s alleged in the federal indictments.
In the wake of the federal charges, other issues — like the one raised by education officials — have come to light, casting a shadow of doubt over Hunt’s ongoing tenure as auditor.
‘The law clearly says where the money is to go’
Funding for public schools has been enshrined in the state Constitution since 1872 in an effort to provide a fair and free school system for West Virginia children.
Counties have surplus funds after paying delinquent taxes, and other costs, and if no rightful property owner comes forward to collect the money.
County sheriffs had been required to put the funds in the General School Fund, but in 2022, lawmakers transferred many delinquent land duties to the state auditor. Before the 2022 reforms, a since repealed statute directed surplus from sheriff-run tax sales to be split among local taxing bodies.
That surplus money from delinquent property sales is one of a few funding sources for educators’ professional development, as dictated by the Legislature.

House Education Chairman Joe Statler explained that professional development is important as lawmakers try to address education reform, including implementing new ways of teaching reading.
“Things are changing rapidly in the education world, and if our educators are going to be brought up to date on the new technologies and everything, that’s expensive,” said Statler, R-Monongalia.
Hunt sent a memo in April to all county commissions — and copied the state superintendent — saying that, after lawmakers’ 2022 tax sale reform, it was his interpretation that unclaimed surplus from tax sales belong in the state’s school fund. He said counties that had improperly spent surplus funds prior to 2022 should pay those amounts to the auditor for the school fund.
Blatt wrote in her July letter that she was “unaware of any discussions or deliberations that led up to” Hunt’s decision to contact county commissions.
State code dictates that the school fund is administered by the state superintendent of schools, Blatt noted. She wanted to know what steps Hunt’s office had taken to ensure proper surplus amounts were deposited into the school fund.
“Clearly, it is my fiduciary duty to ensure the integrity of and the proper management of that fund for the benefit of public education constituents that the people have established that Fund to benefit,” Blatt wrote.
Hunt, a Republican, began his tenure as state auditor in 2025. His office has continued depositing surplus funds from delinquent property sales into the General School Fund, according to a document shared by the state department of education.
The state’s payment tracker showed that $445,377.95 in surplus funds collected during fiscal year 2026 were deposited into the Strategic Staff Development Fund within school funding. In the 2024 fiscal year, that number amounted to $255,837.72.
But the education department has no clear answers about whether they’ve received the total amount they are owed or how Hunt has handled the funds.
With public school funding woes top of mind, Statler said that lawmakers need to take a closer look at the situation.
“The law clearly says where the money is to go, and the full amount needs to go into that area or have an accounting of it,” he said when reached by phone Wednesday.
House sidelines auditor’s bill to change school funding
Earlier this year, the Senate unanimously passed a bill — backed by the auditor’s office — that could have changed the process for selling property with delinquent tax liens.
The measure, Senate Bill 651, was sponsored by Senate President Randy Smith, R-Preston, and other Republican senators.
Among the proposed changes to the state Auditor’s Office, it would have altered the distribution of surplus proceeds from tax sales so that, if the former owner didn’t claim the surplus within two years, 90% would be deposited into the general school fund versus the current 100%. The auditor would keep the other 10% for the land operating fund.
“Certainly, the general school fund will be entitled to the tax dollars,” Auditor’s Office attorney Frederic Caudill told the House Judiciary Committee in March. “But we believe the surplus is a different species, and that the Legislature can do with that money as it pleases, as long as property owners who have lost their property have an opportunity to get that surplus back.”
Kelli Talbott, general counsel for the education department, told lawmakers in that same meeting that she believed the bill to be unconstitutional.

“We believe the Constitution requires all monies to come to the school fund,” Talbott said.
The House Judiciary Committee voted down the bill, with members unclear about the constitutionality of the measure.
“At the end, our committee was left with more questions than answers, and the bill failed. At both the time and in hindsight that was the right outcome,” House Judiciary Chairman JB Akers, R-Kanawha, said on Tuesday.
Caudill was indicted Monday in the property stealing scheme alongside Hunt and others. All five defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law.
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
