A never-built Nevada city could cost taxpayers hundreds of millions following judge’s ruling
Nevada taxpayers could owe hundreds of millions of dollars to the developers of an unbuilt Southern Nevada city following a judge’s ruling in a high-profile water rights case.
A monthslong, precedent-setting trial in Clark County will proceed to its next phase, where a jury will decide how much the state must pay the developers known as Coyote Springs Investment for “an unconstitutional taking” of their water rights.
“Based on a totality of the evidence, the actions (and inactions) and repeated course of conduct by the State Engineer caused the unconstitutional taking experienced by CSI,” wrote Judge Mark Denton, who is retiring from the bench at the end of this year and will not oversee the trial’s next hearings.
Attorneys are seeking $600 million in damages, plus interest and attorneys fees, said Mark Hutchison, the developers’ attorney.
Hutchison, who also served as the state’s Republican lieutenant governor from 2015 to 2019, said in a Wednesday interview that he was pleased with the ruling. He said he anticipates the next phase of the trial to wrap up in the early part of next year.
“It’s about accountability of the state engineer’s office and the way in which they interacted with my client over many, many years that resulted in the taking of their private property,” Hutchison said. “My message to taxpayers is that this is the way that the United States Constitution is structured to hold government accountable.”
Experts have said the case is a first-of-its-kind test of whether water rights can be considered property under a clause in the Nevada Constitution that says the government cannot take property without compensation in return.
The Nevada attorney general’s office was reviewing the ruling Wednesday evening and had no further comment, said spokesman John Sadler, and the state engineer did not reply to an emailed inquiry.
‘Essentially taken away’
Throughout the course of about three months, Denton heard the testimony of several former Nevada state engineers, the Southern Nevada Water Authority, independent experts as well as the developers and their employees.
Judge-elect Adam Ganz will replace Denton in his department, but it is not yet clear which judge will see the case through.
Coyote Springs was initially the idea of lobbyist Harvey Whittemore, who bought the land it was planned for in 1998 for $23 million. Today, the Seeno family of California developers are the sole owners.
It was planned to be twice the size of Summerlin, with golf courses, hotel-casinos and other amenities. Not one home stands there today, though watering a golf course has helped the developers hold onto their water rights for years.
Denton wrote in his filing that the state misled developers.
In 1997, the state engineer ruled that at least 18,000 acre-feet of water was available for use in the area.
But the state engineer later took extra steps to combine water basins that are scientifically connected into one — the Lower White River Flow System — and impose a cap on how much total water could be pumped in a much bigger “superbasin”: only 8,000 acre-feet. The area is home to the endangered Moapa dace, a tiny fish native to the Muddy River.
The Nevada Supreme Court affirmed the state engineer’s authority to combine basins in a 2024 decision. Denton wrote that the state engineer’s order “was unprecedented and thus unforeseeable.”
Denton did not challenge the state engineer’s ability to regulate water; however, the ruling may open the door for future lawsuits where water rights holders allege regulation crossed the line and resulted in a taking of private property without compensation.
Denton wrote that, over many years, the state encouraged the developers to spend money by approving time extensions that allowed them to retain their water rights while they pursued their development plans.
“CSI’s right to use its water was essentially taken away and given to others to use ahead of the permit holder to which the right was originally granted,” Denton wrote.
Contact Alan Halaly at [email protected]. Follow @AlanHalaly on X.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
