Federal unions sue again to block planned USDA reorganization
By Drew Friedman
Federal unions are again suing to stop the Agriculture Department’s planned reorganization, arguing that it will unlawfully force thousands of USDA employees to choose between relocating or losing their jobs.
In a lawsuit filed Tuesday in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, a coalition of federal unions requested a preliminary injunction to halt the department’s reorganization plans. The plaintiffs contend that the reorganization underway violates the Administrative Procedure Act and is occurring without congressional approval.
The new legal action comes shortly after a federal judge denied the plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction in a separate lawsuit involving the Trump administration’s broader federal workforce reductions. A Sept. 2 decision from U.S. District Judge Susan Illston allowed USDA’s reorganization plans to continue for the time being, ruling that the plaintiffs’ motion belonged in its own lawsuit rather than being folded into the broader case.
The plaintiffs in the new lawsuit include the American Federation of Government Employees, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the National Federation of Federal Employees and the National Treasury Employees Union — all unions representing employees in various USDA components affected by the reorganization.
USDA declined to comment for this story, citing a policy of not commenting on pending litigation.
USDA has spent months carrying out a multipart reorganization plan that involves relocating more than half of its Washington, D.C.-area workforce to hubs across the country, affecting roughly 2,600 employees in the National Capital Region. About 90% of USDA employees already work outside the D.C. area.
Trump officially plans for civilian federal pay freeze in 2027
Trump administration officials have said the reorganization is meant to move USDA work closer to the regions it serves. In a congressional hearing this summer, Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins said the relocations across the country will be a “massive value add” for USDA research.
In an Aug. 28 court filing, an acting official at USDA stated that 64% of the 725 USDA employees who have, so far, been told to relocate have accepted their reassignments.
“In other words, at least one out of three relocated employees is leaving the agency rather than relocating,” the unions countered. “That rate substantially understates the actual number of workers who will ultimately be unable to report to their new locations for a variety of reasons, including because it does not include workers who are unable to relocate but initially ‘accepted’ relocation in order to pursue hardship exemptions or reasonable accommodations to avoid moving.”
The plaintiffs further argued that the reorganization is a veiled attempt to conduct a reduction in force, as USDA has not outlined plans to replace employees who choose to leave their jobs rather than accept a management-directed reassignment (MDR).
Hundreds, if not thousands, more MDR letters are expected to go out to USDA employees imminently, the lawsuit states. The planned reassignments will lead to “widespread attrition,” the unions argued, as many of the D.C.-based employees being told to relocate cannot do so for personal and financial reasons.
“USDA knew, and continues to know, that the office closures and forced relocations caused by the USDA reorganization plan will cause substantial employee attrition,” the lawsuit states. “USDA’s intent in taking these actions is to cause significant workforce reduction. Prior to making the decision to engage in and implement these actions, USDA did not assess the effect of the employee attrition on agency functions and ability to perform statutory mandates.”
The unions warned that the USDA reorganization will lead to a deeper loss of institutional knowledge and expertise at the affected department components. Under the Trump administration, USDA has so far seen a net loss of more than 16,200 employees, Office of Personnel Management data shows.
“The consequences will extend far beyond Washington,” NFFE National President Randy Erwin said Tuesday. “Forcing experienced USDA employees to choose between uprooting their families and losing their jobs will drive out expertise, devastate USDA and its agencies, and disrupt critical services that support farmers and rural communities, feed families, advance agricultural research, and protect our forests and public lands.
“Congress said no to this reorganization for a reason,” Erwin said. “The administration must follow the law.”
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
