Colorado Republicans sue to block Amendment 87 tax hikes
Two Republican state lawmakers on Thursday filed a lawsuit backed by a conservative political group in an attempt to block Colorado’s new graduated income tax system from taking effect.
The lawsuit, brought by Republican state Sens. Barbara Kirkmeyer of Brighton and Byron Pelton of Sterling, argues that the measure violates the Colorado Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights, also known as TABOR.
Amendment 87, which voters approved in November, replaces the state’s flat 4.4% income tax with a graduated system that charges higher rates based on how much people and businesses earn. To do so, it had to delete a provision of TABOR requiring all income be taxed at the same rate.
Under TABOR, the lawsuit says, Amendment 87 should have been broken into two ballot questions: one to increase taxes, and one to delete TABOR’s prohibition on graduated income tax brackets.
“The constitution wasn’t followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn’t overturned,” Kirkmeyer, who serves on the legislature’s Joint Budget Committee, said in a statement.
The filing was announced in a press release by Advance Colorado, a conservative political nonprofit that is supporting the lawsuit. The Colorado Sun considers Advance Colorado a dark money group because it does not disclose its donors.
Amendment 87 is expected to raise more than $2 billion annually to be spent on education, childcare and healthcare. It raises taxes on households and businesses that earn more than about $500,000, and cuts them for those making less.
Previously, the state Title Board and state Supreme Court allowed the measure to appear on the ballot, overruling conservative opponents who argued that it violated the state’s single-subject rule. That requirement generally restricts proposed laws to a single topic. The new argument is slightly different, contending that TABOR itself prohibits a tax increase from being combined with a constitutional change.
The lawsuit also argues that voters were given bad information by the state’s nonpartisan voter guide, known as the blue book.
It singles out a table showing that those making $500,000 to $1 million in federal taxable income would get a tax cut under Amendment 87.
This table is confusing, as The Sun has reported previously, but not necessarily inaccurate.
Amendment 87 raises taxes for Colorado residents who make more than $500,000 in state taxable income. However, the table is skewed by the fact that many higher earners only live here part-time. So for many households that make more than $500,000 in federal taxable income, the amount that’s subject to state taxes is actually much lower, resulting in a tax cut under the measure.
The lawsuit makes misleading claims of its own.
It accuses the ballot language of lying to voters about how the money will be spent, quoting comments made by Gov. Jared Polis earlier this month that there would be “zero dollars” left for education or childcare within three years.
“The notice promised benefits the measure will not deliver,” the lawsuit says.
In reality, the legislature hasn’t approved anything of the sort. Polis’ comments were a warning that there wouldn’t be money available for those services if lawmakers allowed Medicaid costs to continue growing.
Type of Story: News
Based on facts, either observed and verified directly by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
