Midterm wins, near-misses could signal political change in the Deep South

Tennessee Democratic state Rep. Justin Pearson turns to his wife, Oceana Pearson, during his election night party in Memphis. Pearson narrowly lost his race for Congress, and his defeat — and Democratic optimism — is part of a pattern that repeated across the Deep South up and down the midterm ballot. (Photo by Brad Vest for Tennessee Lookout)
The midterms are over but Tennessee state Rep. Justin Pearson is back on the road, visiting churches and community centers across the congressional district he narrowly lost. He wants to thank voters who supported him. And he’s determined not to lose the connections he built during a long-shot campaign that has come to exemplify Democrats’ growing ambitions across the Republican-controlled South.
He came closer than most anyone expected to winning. Pearson’s Republican legislative colleagues redrew the U.S. House district earlier this year to break up a longtime Democratic stronghold around the majority-Black city of Memphis, diluting it with Republican-heavy areas to net the state an additional GOP seat in Congress.
And it worked. Barely. Pearson lost to Republican Brent Taylor by about 1 percentage point in the newly drawn district, which the nonpartisan Cook Political Report said President Donald Trump would have won by 21 points.
“I was campaigning in communities that were over 60% rural, white, Southern, and we came within one point,” said Pearson, who is Black.
“It is possible to win here.”
His narrow defeat — and Democratic optimism — is part of a pattern that has repeated across the Deep South up and down the midterm ballot, where the blue wave that engulfed other parts of the country only lapped at Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi and Tennessee. In these states, Republicans held onto power, for the most part.
But Democrats made significant inroads that would have seemed unthinkable a year ago: from a nail-biting Senate race in Mississippi where the Democrat squeaked out a win over the Republican incumbent to down-ballot races where Democrats flipped state legislative seats in areas where Trump won with wide margins just two years ago.
“You knock enough doors, you talk to enough people, you go to enough places, and you’re hearing the same stories,” said Pearson. “Republicans who say, ‘You’re the first Democrat I’ve ever voted for,’ and people who’ve never voted in their lives saying, ‘I’m registering to vote to vote for you because I want something different.’”
But how durable are those gains? In a region full of Republican legislative supermajorities, where Trump remains popular and where few Democrats have held statewide offices in more than a decade, do the midterm results signal a change in the South’s political future, or were they an anomaly driven by a unique set of circumstances?
Many experts remain skeptical that states such as Alabama or Mississippi are on a path to become neighboring Georgia, which is now a solid battleground state where Democrats won every statewide seat on the ballot this year. They see midterm results as not an embrace of Democrats so much as a negative referendum on Trump.
“I know Democrats get excited in places like Alabama and Louisiana and Mississippi when Democrats win elections,” said David Hughes, a political science associate professor at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette who studies the politics of the American South. Voters were primarily motivated by anger over issues including high costs, the Iran war and congressional redistricting, he said.
Black voting advocates in the South say the midterm surge was not just a ‘blue wave’
“It’s interesting, but it’s largely a fluke and there will be a reversion to the mean.”
But Southern Democrats see glimmers of opportunity for lasting, even generational change in wins such as Democrat Scott Colom’s in Mississippi, where he beat Republican incumbent Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith on a razor-thin margin to become the first Black senator from the state since Reconstruction. Or in U.S. Rep. Shomari Figures, who defeated his Republican opponent in an Alabama congressional district that state legislators redrew this year to favor Republicans.
And they see it in surprisingly close gubernatorial races in Tennessee and Florida, where Republicans eked out wins with one or two percentage points over their Democratic opponents.
None of that means the Deep South has suddenly become a different place politically, said Anneshia Hardy, a voting rights activist in Alabama who studies Southern politics.
“But it does mean that we need to pay closer attention to what’s happening beneath the statewide results,” she said. “The political landscape is not nearly as static as our electoral map suggests.”
On a national level, she said, Democrats could learn from the South about building coalitions and creating political opportunities where they don’t already hold power.
Quoting Andre 3000, the famed Atlanta rapper and half of hip-hop duo Outkast, she said, “‘The South got something to say,’ and I hope folks are listening.”
Voting rights and Black political power
In a region that was the epicenter of the fight for voting rights 60 years ago, the recent congressional redistricting ignited a fire among voters, and particularly among Black voters, who showed up to the polls in numbers rarely seen in a midterm election, activists and experts told Stateline.
The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Louisiana v. Callais earlier this year all but nullified a provision in the federal 1965 Voting Rights Act that required states to draw electoral maps to give racial minority voters the opportunity to elect their chosen candidates.
Republican state legislators rushed to redraw their congressional maps to favor GOP candidates in Alabama, Florida, Louisiana, North Carolina, Tennessee and Texas. Democrats tried gerrymandering in California and Virginia.
That redistricting decision was pivotal for Southern voters, and for Black voters in particular, Pearson said.
“I think if that had not happened, we would not have seen a number of the victories we saw,” he said. “To have such an ignited and excited Black Democratic voting base, I think the attack on voting rights was the key issue that really awakened people’s attentiveness and conscientiousness.”
Black politicians win newfound power across state, federal governments
Midterm turnout is typically much lower than it is for presidential elections. But this year saw historic turnout, even in the South. Democrats saw their share of the vote increase in every county in states such as Alabama, where Democratic turnout nearly doubled over 2022 numbers while GOP votes declined slightly. Nearly 1 million Mississippians turned out to vote, rivaling presidential election years.
One-third of Mississippi and Louisiana ballots were cast by Black voters. In Georgia, turnout among Black voters increased more than 11% over the 2022 midterms while white turnout shrank.
Activists say the high turnout in the South was built on decades of voter outreach and community organizing, particularly in Black communities. It just needed a spark to ignite, they said.
Republicans lit the match when they began gerrymandering in earnest earlier this year.
The newly drawn maps provided a tangible example for casual voters to see how state and national leaders wield power, and how they can take it away from their constituents, Hardy said. Louisiana, the state at the center of the Supreme Court’s Callais case, saw voter turnout surge especially in parishes — the state’s equivalent of counties — where congressional lines were redrawn, said Louisiana political consultant Mary-Patricia Wray, who’s worked on statewide campaigns for both Republicans and Democrats.
“Voters are very much aware that when we elect our legislature, it will be in charge of redrawing our maps again,” Wray said. “I think that awareness truly did drive Black turnout in Louisiana specifically, and I think it did in any state where there was a potential to have an impact on congressional maps.”
Democrats nationally had their best performance with white voters in years, tying with Republicans for white voters after not having won white voters in a presidential election since 1964. In the growing urban center of Madison County, Alabama, a majority-white electorate flipped three state house seats from red to blue, and sent down-ballot Republican incumbents packing, including the incumbent sheriff. In suburban, majority-white Rutherford County south of Nashville, Tennessee, Democrats flipped three state House seats.
“One of the surprising things about Democrats doing well in the South was that many of these weren’t on the radar” of the national Democratic party, “and they won anyway, with little resources,” said Kent Syler, a political science professor at Middle Tennessee State University.
“Now they’ve demonstrated that there’s an opportunity here, you’re going to see more recruitment of top-quality candidates and you’re going to see more resources for those candidates, because this election proved you have a chance.”
Looking ahead
Louisiana and Mississippi are two of just three states — Kentucky is the other — that will hold elections for state offices and legislative seats in 2027.
And Democratic near-misses in those states are already fueling speculation over the next round of elections. Democrat Jamie Davis, who lost the Senate race in Louisiana to Republican U.S. Rep. Julia Letlow by about 25,000 votes, less than a two-point margin, is reportedly eyeing a run for governor.
Young, diverse voters showed up for midterms as older, Trump voters stayed home
But the political climate remains volatile.
“Neither party can take anything for granted. The electorate is just ticked off,” said Hughes, of the University of Louisiana at Lafayette. “If Democrats don’t find a way to deliver (on their promises), I have confidence that the voters will turn them out of office down the line.”
One thing the South showed national Democrats as well as Republicans, several experts told Stateline, was that more moderate candidates who avoided national disagreements over wedge issues tended to do better at the polls.
“I saw a preference for moderate incumbents over extreme incumbents at every level of the ballot,” for both parties, said Wray, the Louisiana political consultant.
Hughes thinks it will take a greater demographic shift — voters moving in from other states and bringing their politics with them, plus a continued rise in turnout from Black voters and other minority groups — to create the conditions in states such as Alabama that propelled Georgia or North Carolina to swing-state status.
Democrats across the South are hoping for more investment from national groups, now that the South has shown a win is possible. They’re looking at the tens of millions poured into races in Texas and Georgia, arguing even a fraction of that could make a difference in state houses and governor’s mansions across the region — and from there, influence political control of the nation’s highest offices.
Pearson said he’s working on creating a political action committee to continue building on the Democratic successes and near-successes of the midterms.
“I believe the litmus test for America’s democracy is what happens in the South,” he said. “We can perfect this American experiment if we invest in the South and I’m more hopeful and optimistic about us doing it than ever before.”
Stateline reporter Anna Claire Vollers can be reached at [email protected].
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
