Commentary: Will Virginia join other states in banning a pesticide linked to Parkinson’s disease?

A farm in Prince William County. A bill to ban pesticides containing paraquat in Virginia stalled in the General Assembly this year. (Photo by Sarah Vogelsong/Virginia Mercury)
Once in a while you are surprised to find out that a hazardous product you assumed had been long since banned is still available and in regular use. Toxic chemicals fall into this category with depressing frequency.
The U.S. regulatory system, often criticized for being slow to approve new projects and products, has never been good at removing dangerous chemicals from the marketplace once they are on the shelves.
And so it is that herbicides containing the potent neurotoxin paraquat are still legal for use in Virginia, in spite of mounting evidence connecting paraquat to brain diseases including Parkinson’s. After a failed effort in the General Assembly to change that, health advocates hope this is the year Virginia bans paraquat.
Paraquat, sold under a number of brand names including Gramoxone, kills all the vegetation it touches with what the manufacturer describes as “lightning-fast burndown.” This allows farmers to broadcast-spray it “before, during, or after planting, but before crop emergence.” It is also good for killing the foliage on potato plants to make the tubers easier to harvest.
Not surprisingly, paraquat also poisons animals that ingest it, and it likewise poses a threat to any humans unfortunate enough to be around when it is being sprayed. This can include farmworkers who aren’t wearing protective equipment or downwind neighbors who inhale drifting aerosols.
As a short video from the Environmental Working Group (EWG) describes, people who are exposed to paraquat often don’t know it until it’s too late. EWG is one of the advocates seeking a Virginia ban on paraquat, along with the Sierra Club, Parkinson’s Foundation and American Parkinson Disease Association.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency classifies any product that contains paraquat as a restricted-use pesticide, keeping it out of the hands of zealous homeowners. Farmworkers who use it must undergo training from the manufacturer to become a certified applicator. However, compliance with pesticide safety requirements in general tends to be inconsistent.
The good news is that paraquat is used on less than 2% of Virginia farms. The bad news is, that still amounts to 200,000 acres. And Virginia does not require notification of neighboring landowners when pesticides are sprayed on farms, so nearby residents don’t know they are at risk.
Needless to say, paraquat is not used in organic farming.
Paraquat is banned in more than 70 countries, often going back decades. The list includes Canada, Europe, most Middle Eastern and West African countries and much of Asia. In the U.S., Vermont became the first state to prohibit its use, California has begun a phase-out, and bills to ban its use have been introduced in a dozen states.
Ironically, most paraquat sold in the U.S. is manufactured in China, even though its use is prohibited there. The largest U.S. distributor, Sygenta, is owned by a Chinese state enterprise.
Paraquat’s value as an herbicide was discovered in 1955, quickly followed by discovery of its potential for neurological harm in humans. Indeed, the 50’s and 60’s were something of a heyday for finding terrific new chemicals that were also seriously problematic. DDT was popular, too, before it killed off most of our bald eagles. The first of thousands of PFAS chemicals began making Teflon a household name around the same time, driving a still-thriving industry linked to cancer, immune system diseases and birth defects. These join tens of thousands of other legacy chemicals that are known to be dangerous but remain legal to use; in most cases, the EPA has never tested them for safety.
In the case of paraquat, the EPA knew of its toxicity from the time that it was approved in 1964. Ten years later, the agency considered canceling its registration, but didn’t, even as concerns about paraquat’s harms continued to mount. In 1978, EPA added paraquat to the list of restricted-use chemicals requiring training and protective equipment for those who used it.
By the 1980s, scientists were documenting an association with Parkinson’s Disease. Over the years, evidence mounted showing that farm workers and nearby residents of farms where paraquat is applied develop Parkinson’s Disease at a rate much higher than the general public.
A 2011 study funded by the National Institutes of Health found that farm workers who applied paraquat were 2.5 times more likely to develop Parkinson’s than non-users. In 2013, a study by paraquat manufacturer Sygenta confirmed the NIH finding.
EPA rejected calls for a ban but moved to tighten restrictions on paraquat in 2021, then reversed course in 2025, saying the matter needed further study. Following that decision, 20 former EPA officials and scientists signed a letter calling on the agency to ban paraquat.
In Virginia’s last General Assembly session, Del. Nadarius Clark, D-Suffolk, and eight other Democrats introduced House Bill 1375, which would have banned the manufacture, sale and use of pesticides containing paraquat. The Farm Bureau and the Virginia Agribusiness Council opposed the bill, arguing that safer alternatives cost more.
An Agriculture subcommittee narrowly recommended the bill after adopting amendments to allow existing inventory to be sold and used. However, the full committee continued the legislation to 2027, a polite way to kill it. The vote was unanimous – including Clark himself, who serves as the vice chair of the committee.
From where I sit, the surprise decision to continue the bill suggests that the committee may have been acting on a request from the governor. Abigail Spanberger had only recently taken office, and her secretary of agriculture and forestry, Katie Frazier, was formerly executive director of the Virginia Agribusiness Council.
My call to Clark’s office was not returned, however, and advocates say they believe the vote was intended to delay, but not to defeat, action on paraquat.
Geoff Horsfield, legislative director for EWG, told me in a phone call that he thought the committee vote simply reflected members’ unfamiliarity with the issue. Clark has already agreed to put the bill in again, he said, and a Senate patron will be announced soon. The job of advocates now is to educate legislators – and the public – about the dangers of paraquat to Virginians.
Horsfield emphasized that “this is a public health issue, not a farm issue.” Parkinson’s is the fastest-growing neurological disease in the country, he added. With EPA doing nothing, states have to act.
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
