Commentary: Future docs: Get rid of Medicaid middlemen

(Photo by Ariel Skelley/Getty Images)
We are second year medical students at the University of Minnesota, just beginning our journey into medicine, looking forward to the incredible privilege of being physicians.
We have already seen the power that medicine has to improve people’s lives. We have also seen shortcomings in the medical system that can prevent patients from receiving care. Chief among them is the role of insurance companies, whose tactics interfere with patient care by forcing doctors into a constant struggle to gain approval for treatments that they prescribe. Health insurance companies claim that they must micromanage doctors because overuse of medical services is the primary cause of high healthcare costs, and doctors are the main cause of the alleged overutilization. This is despite patients in the U.S. utilizing the healthcare system less and paying more for those services than comparable high income countries1,2.
Removing these health insurance middlemen from our public healthcare programs — such as MinnesotaCare and Minnesota’s version of Medicaid, known as Medical Assistance — would reduce healthcare costs and improve the quality of care. Private insurance companies are taking our hard-earned premiums, and rerouting the money directly into their pockets. The full extent of the money that is not used for healthcare by insurance companies is opaque, although current statute says that 15% of money paid to private insurers may go to non-healthcare related costs, which includes paying armies of administrators and loosely defined “quality improvement activities” that can be spent on marketing, travel and entertainment due to how loosely they are defined.
In contrast, state-run Medicaid programs, whose only non-healthcare spending goes to administrative cost, have a steeply reduced overhead. Indeed, Medicaid overhead is roughly 4%, allowing for more spending more on actual healthcare. The main argument for why we in the United States need insurance companies rests on the assumption that doctors and patients can’t decide what care is best for them and will order unnecessary tests and appointments. Our healthcare system allows administrators hired by your health insurer to determine if you qualify for the surgery that your doctor recommends or the medication that decreases your risk of having a heart attack.
Additionally, there is little evidence supporting this assumption that without the supervision of health insurers, Americans would vastly over-utilize healthcare.
A 2025 study published by the National Bureau of Economic Research found that patients in the privatized version of Medicaid use healthcare a similar amount when compared to the public versions of the programs but are significantly less satisfied. When private health insurance companies try to reduce wasteful spending in the medical system, their blunt tactics of prior authorizations and denials of care often deprive patients of access to necessary care. More than a quarter of physicians surveyed by the American Medical Association found that insurance denials led directly to life-threatening events for a patient.
A study by Physicians for a National Health Program found that removing health insurance middlemen would cut 10-17% in Medicaid total spending. This is calculated by taking into account the money saved by deprivatizing Medicaid and adding in the potential of a modest increase in healthcare usage, which results in cost savings. So why don’t we just ditch these private health insurance companies?
There is currently a bill in the Minnesota Legislature poised to do just this: the Patient Centered Care bill. This bill, which will get a fresh airing with a new Legislature next year, establishes a system in which the state of Minnesota directly pays healthcare providers for the services that they provide for Medicaid patients. Instead of allowing insurance companies to gamify the healthcare system to maximize profits, the bill moves the destination of healthcare dollars back into the hands of Medicaid patients and their doctors.
As future physicians, we support the removal of private insurance from Medicaid as a step towards fixing our broken healthcare system. We encourage you to check out the PCC bill, and you can contact your state representatives to ask them about it, too.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
