Commentary: The Trump administration is pro-extinction

In 2023, a North Atlantic right whale was spotted off the coast of Georgia with rope lodged in its mouth. (Photo courtesy of Georgia DNR/NOAA Fisheries)
“Save the Whales” used to be one of the few slogans everyone could get behind, right up there with “Do unto others” and “Peace on Earth.” Over the past year, the Trump administration has proven that even this feel-good, common-sense maxim is too much to ask. A string of recent policies implemented or backed by the Trump administration threatens to drive North Atlantic right whales and countless other endangered species to extinction.
The administration has released a series of rules decimating the Endangered Species Act. The consequences are not theoretical. They concern whether we will allow preventable human activity to keep killing species that have no way to protect themselves.
Most recently, the administration has decided that destroying an endangered species’ habitat or otherwise killing an endangered animal by “accident” — no matter how predictable and preventable the “accident” — is no longer banned by the Act.
That distinction is dangerously divorced from reality. These days, endangered species do not generally disappear because someone sets out to kill them. They disappear because people build roads, clear forests, develop open waters, deploy fishing gear, and do other economic activities that make survival impossible. If foreseeable harm can simply be dismissed as an accident, the Endangered Species Act becomes far less capable of doing the job Congress created it to do.
This terrible decision puts North Atlantic right whales at especially high risk. Collisions with boats and ships, the highly avoidable “accidents” that the government could allow, are a leading cause of death for right whales. The whales are currently protected from these collisions by dynamic vessel speed limits that kick in at times and places where right whales are likely present. That would be more reassuring if the Trump administration hadn’t pledged to roll back those speed limits as well.
The permitting bill making its way through the Senate and supported by the Trump administration would put endangered species at even greater risk, by weakening science-backed safeguards and making it easier for development projects that threaten wildlife and their habitats to move forward. It would also fast track data centers, one of which has been proposed as an undersea facility in Eastport, further jeopardizing right whales.
To round out their anti-whale agenda, the Trump administration is also actively stripping away safeguards against the other primary killer of right whales: entanglements in fishing gear. They supported a bill — recently passed by the House and currently in the Senate — that would extend an existing moratorium on new policies around fishing gear until 2035. The moratorium would exempt the lobster industry from requirements of the Endangered Species Act and the Marine Mammal Protection Act for another seven years beyond the six years Congress already gave them.
Outgoing Democratic U.S. Rep. Jared Golden of Maine claimed that he co-sponsored the bill because it “will protect our heritage lobster industry from unnecessary and costly new regulations related to the protection of the North Atlantic right whale.” Let’s be very clear: The lobster industry is an important part of Maine’s heritage, but the 382 critically endangered whales need additional protection during times of high risk from the strangling ropes used in a slew of commercial fisheries, including the lobster fishery. Even Maine’s own Department of Marine Resources has told senators that it and groups representing lobstermen believe the bill is not essential.
This bill would take us in exactly the wrong direction when solutions to fishing gear entanglements are at our fingertips. Scientists and partners have spent years developing and refining “on-demand” gear, which has far fewer dangerous vertical lines for marine life to get ensnarled in.
Right whales were named because whalers considered them the “right whale” to hunt, due to their slow speed and tendency to float near the water’s surface. We may have stopped killing these gentle giants with harpoons, but we never stopped wiping them out. Human activity is the only known cause of death for adult North Atlantic right whales in the modern day — not one has been documented living long enough to die from old age.
With funding and some political will, right whales, boaters, and the fishing industry can co-exist and even thrive. But instead of embracing this brighter future, our government wants to actively undermine right whales’ survival for short-term, questionable benefits.
“Save the Whales” was never really just about whales. It was about whether, when we have the power to stop something precious from disappearing forever, we choose to use that power.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
