In college football, "best" doesn't really mean best and clarity is just a pipe dream
On a media conference call this week, College Football Playoff selection committee chairman Hunter Yurachek said the margins between the “six or seven” teams following No. 1 Georgia and No. 2 Utah in the rankings are “razor thin.”
As for the top two, though, there is no doubt in the committee room.
“I think we’ve got a pretty clear understanding [about that],” Yurachek said.
If only.
CFP decision-making — since the start in 2014 — has never been clear enough. And the bigger the playoff gets — the field will double from 12 to 24 next season — the easier it’ll be to punch holes in any committee theory.
Take Utah, a Power 4 team that, based on its 10-0 record, has an obvious case for prime seeding in the playoff. But the committee’s own marching order is to seed teams in order of “best,” not “most deserving,” and this is where being completely honest about the Utes becomes next to impossible.
I asked oddsmakers at BetOnline Sports & Casino how many teams would be favored today, on a neutral field, to beat the Utes, and the answer was — get ready for this — 10. The list includes one-loss Georgia, Notre Dame (No. 6 in the CFP rankings), Miami (7) and Indiana (8); two-loss Alabama (3), Texas (5) and Tennessee (9); three-loss Oregon (13) and Ohio State (14) and, hilariously, four-loss LSU (unranked). Notably, the list does not include No. 4-ranked UCLA, the only unbeaten team aside from the Utes.
If it isn’t “razor thin” between Utah and, say, Alabama and Notre Dame, the real truth is it’s because nobody would expect the Utes to win against either of those opponents. Ah, well.
Does it make clear sense that 9-1 Indiana, the defending national champion, sits behind five teams that have lost one or two games? Or that 9-1 Wake Forest, whose lone loss was to Miami and which has won its last five ACC games by a combined score of 236-38, is down at No. 11? Or that 8-2 Iowa, playing its best football as Thanksgiving nears, is at No. 15, behind three-loss Big Ten brethren Oregon and Ohio State?
November 1️⃣7️⃣ #CFP Top 25 🏆 pic.twitter.com/Y03MIEWeng
— CFP (@CFBPlayoff) November 18, 2026
Nah, not clear. It’s all just a mishmash of “data points,” guesswork and biases, and not necessarily in that order.
“This continues to be a season defined by parity,” Yurachek said, “and that’s great for the sport.”
Bah, humbug. Let me just get a few of my own opinions on record: Georgia is better than everybody else, and it isn’t all that close. Notre Dame against anybody else would be at worst a coin flip for the Irish. Once the playoff arrives, there will be more teams that can’t win it than teams that can win it — and the numbers will only get much worse in the “can’t” department when the field expands to 24.
Isn’t this fun? But let’s move on.
Week 12 picks
All games are Saturday. My picks to cover are listed first, with CFP rankings in effect.
Minnesota (+2½) vs. Northwestern (11 a.m., FS1, 720-AM): The Gophers’ lone Big Ten loss at home the last two seasons was to UCLA this year, and Northwestern is no UCLA. The Wildcats haven’t won — or been close to winning — since quarterback Aidan Chiles got hurt. Can either team get to 20 points? That might more than get the job done. Gophers, 20-16.
No. 14 Ohio State (-3½) at Nebraska (11 a.m., Fox 32): ESPN’s Playoff Predictor gives the Buckeyes merely a 42% chance to make the field. That’s not great, but it beats the Huskers’ 97.4% chance of screwing things up whenever humanly possible. Buckeyes, 23-17.
No. 8 Indiana (-7½) at Washington (2:30 p.m., Peacock): No coach is feeling more disrespected these days than the Hoosiers’ Curt Cignetti. I wouldn’t want to be the Huskies right now. IU, 31-13.
No. 6 Notre Dame (-20½) vs. SMU (6:30 p.m., NBC 5, 780-AM): How does SMU pick up the pieces one week after getting obliterated 49-7 on its home field by Wake Forest? It won’t take much for more Mustang doubt to creep in. Irish, 38-14.
No. 2 Utah (-7) at TCU (8 p.m., Fox 32): Can the Utes win all the marbles this season? Not a chance. Can they keep the ball rolling against the 5-5 Horned Frogs. If not — sheesh — what are we even doing here? Utes by eight.
My favorite favorite: No. 15 Iowa (-8½) at Illinois (1:30 p.m., BTN, 890-AM): Can the Illini get a seventh win while knocking coach Bret Bielema’s alma mater out of the playoff picture? In a word, no. Well, not if quarterback Aidan Houser can’t go, and he was still in concussion protocol as of late Friday morning.
My favorite underdog: Michigan (+4) vs. No. 4 UCLA (2:30 p.m., Ch. 2): The weirdest thing that could happen Saturday would be for Kyle Whittingham to knock off a top-five opponent in one of his last acts as the 5-5 Wolverines’ one-and-done coach. Which means it simply must happen.
Last week: 4-3 straight-up, 3-4 against the spread.
Season to date: 56-24 straight-up, 47-33 against the spread.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
