Utah News Dispatch
20/11/2026 17:02

Utah lawmakers eye another attempt to repeal law allowing developers to form cities

Homes in the Red Ledges private community in the Heber Valley, Utah are pictured on Sept. 19, 2026. (Katie McKellar/Utah News Dispatch)

Rep. Tiara Auxier narrowly lost reelection after a blue wave of Democrats swept the Utah House — but this week, Auxier teed up another attempt to repeal a controversial development law that was a contentious election issue this year, especially in Utah’s Wasatch Back. 

Even though Auxier won’t be returning to Utah’s Capitol Hill next year, it’s likely the repeal will be carried forward by another legislator. 

Auxier on Wednesday presented draft legislation to the Political Subdivisions Interim Committee to fully repeal SB258, a law passed in 2024 that created a pilot program allowing up to three private landowners in mostly undeveloped, unincorporated areas to petition to create a “preliminary municipality,” which would be a first step toward the formation of a city or incorporation into a neighboring county. 

‘Threat’ to block state funds from Wasatch County stirs anger over ‘top down’ development pressure

Proponents of the law, which requires at least 10% of housing in the preliminary municipality to be affordable housing, have argued it’s meant to help ease Utah’s housing crisis. They have also argued it’s meant to bolster private property rights, allowing developers a new pathway to pursue projects in areas where county officials refuse to approve their proposals. 

Critics, including Wasatch and Summit county officials, have called on lawmakers to repeal the law. In their resolution calling for the repeal, Wasatch County leaders called it highly problematic, saying it allows developers to “entitle large-scale projects while sidestepping the infrastructure, housing, oversight and accountability standards every other community in Utah must meet.” 

Auxier on Wednesday said lawmakers need to reckon with the law’s problems, recognize it’s not fulfilling its intended purpose, and end the pilot program early. 

“We’ve taken governmental land use authority out of the hands of locally elected officials and placed it with a board controlled by people selected by the landowners seeking developmental approval,” she said. “I don’t think that’s local control, and I don’t think that it fits with our constitutional principles of representative government.”

It’s not the first time Auxier has tried to repeal or change the law. In 2025 she unsuccessfully sponsored a repeal, and in 2026 she ran a “compromise” bill to put more guardrails around the “preliminary municipality” process — both were unsuccessful. 

GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.

SUBSCRIBE

Now, she’s trying again for a full repeal. But this time, as the legislation is currently written, it would also dissolve all preliminary municipalities created under the program, including those that have already been green lit by the lieutenant governor’s office. 

Seven preliminary municipalities have been attempted, most in Wasatch County, and most have either been rejected or are still under consideration. At least one has been approved: Echo Canyon in Grand County. 

“My intent would accomplish two things: it would end the preliminary municipality form of government entirely, and it would restore county land use authority going forward while protecting private rights that are actually valid and legally enforceable,” Auxier said. 

For two years, Auxier said “we’ve been trying to fix this process,” but she argued it’s beyond fixing. 

“What I’m asking us to do now is to consider whether the process itself is built on a government structure that never should have been created,” she said. 

Despite pushback from some lawmakers, the committee made up of both House and Senate legislators voted Wednesday to endorse Auxier’s proposed repeal as a committee bill, teeing it up to be prioritized during the Utah Legislature’s upcoming general session scheduled to begin in January. 

Though Auxier will be out of office by then, the repeal bill will likely be taken up by another legislator since it’s been endorsed by the committee. 

Last month, the House’s top Republican, House Speaker Mike Schultz, told Utah News Dispatch he’s open to making changes to or fully repealing the law. 

Utah House speaker says he’s open to repealing controversial development law

Chris Gamvroulas, president of Ivory Development (which is pursuing the Lost Creek preliminary municipality in Browns Canyon near Park City and Hideout), said the original law was meant to give property owners who had vested property rights an “off ramp” from “weaponized county government,” which he said happened in Grand County. 

“This isn’t just, like, a giveaway,” he said during Wednesday’s hearing. “No one in their right mind wants to use this tool. This is an off ramp when there’s weaponized county government. And you have to be cognizant of that and give a little bit of grace to that.” 

Gamvroulas said if there is a repeal of the bill, lawmakers should replace it in some way to better balance property rights. 

“The preliminary municipality is the second worst policy you could have,” he said. “The only worse policy you could have is the status quo of weaponized county government against property owners.” 

Several sitting lawmakers, incoming legislators and others spoke in favor of Auxier’s repeal. That included outgoing Rep. Mike Kohler, a Republican who didn’t run for reelection for House District 59, representing Wasatch and Summit counties. 

Tiara Auxier, R-Morgan, is pictured on the House floor at the Capitol in Salt Lake City on the first day of the legislative session, Tuesday, Jan. 21, 2025. (Photo by Spenser Heaps for Utah News Dispatch)

Kohler’s Democratic successor Celeste Johnson, and Johnson’s unsuccessful Republican opponent Luke Searle both spoke in favor of the repeal during Wednesday’s committee hearing. 

“It’s flawed. … It creates chaos, and everybody up there is pretty concerned about it,” Kohler said. “It’s not fair. This needs (to be) repealed.” 

Another vocal critic, Jeff Pierce — a Park City investor who ran for the Republican nomination for Utah House District 59 earlier this year but narrowly lost to Searle — also called on lawmakers to support Auxier’s repeal. 

“You have the power to dissolve these cities. Please do it. Do the right thing. Take the voter’s side,” he said. “You just got wiped out in an election because of corrupt bills like this. Now get rid of it.” 

Some lawmakers including Sen. Don Ipson, R-St. George, and Sen. Calvin Musselman, R-West Haven, expressed misgivings about fully repealing the law and voted against endorsing it. And others, including Reps. Jordan Teuscher, R-South Jordan, and Jill Koford, R-Ogden — who both lost to Democrats this month — urged lawmakers to proceed cautiously to balance local control with private property rights. 

“I’m so tired of this issue. My head hurts,” Musselman said before voting against endorsing the bill. “I’ve already faced the reality that this is going to happen. A repeal is going to happen. Whether or not we have some kind of mechanism (to replace it) I don’t know.” 

Musselman encouraged legislators to talk to the Utah Attorney General’s Office and risk management officials to get a picture of potential liability to both the state and counties if they were to face lawsuits from landowners and developers if a repeal were to happen and if existing preliminary municipalities were to be dissolved.  

Ipson said in order for the bill to pass the full Legislature, it will likely need changes. 

“Whoever has this bill has to know that it has to have some work on it,” Ipson said. “It can’t go like it is.”

YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.

SUPPORT
📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Utah News Dispatch.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Analyzing Utah’s blue wave: Many Republicans didn’t turn out; others crossed over to vote blue
Utah News Dispatch
A new report is shedding light on how Utahns’ voting patterns contributed to this year’s blue wave election, …
Bill Clinton tells new governors he hopes new political landscape can ‘take some of the poison out’
Utah News Dispatch
As dozens of newly elected governors gathered in Park City, Utah after the midterm election’s historic blue w…
Commentary: Without prairie dogs, black-footed ferrets disappear
Utah News Dispatch
The black-footed ferret is among the planet’s most endangered species. A native of central North America, it …
Utah lawmakers introduce bills expanding where high-level nuclear waste is allowed
Utah News Dispatch
The U.S. Department of Energy hasn’t released its final decision on sites for “nuclear lifecycle innovation c…
Lawmakers’ plan would restrain Utah data center development – and MIDA
Utah News Dispatch
Utah lawmakers facing intense outcry over data centers gave a first glimpse Wednesday of a wide-ranging plan …
Lawsuit challenges SNAP restrictions on sugary drinks, food in 18 states, including Utah
Utah News Dispatch
A lawsuit filed Wednesday seeks to block more states from restricting what kind of items food stamp recipient…